Beginning/Prologue Part 2 - 747 words

Status
Not open for further replies.

wulfsbane

Don't Believe In Fate
Joined
Apr 26, 2013
Messages
84
Ok, here's the second part of the section I posted earlier. You may want to go read that if you haven't read it, or just reread it anyway so you read it as a single section. Regardless, here it is.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Just as the men around him began to break free of their shock and charge the lone archer, a strange white mist rose from the bodies of the fallen, blanketing the plain of corpses. Rin paid it no heed, charging through it screaming. Soon the mist became so thick he lost sight of the archer. He slowed his pace and turned about, barely able to make out the silhouettes of his comrades. What was this strange mist? It had grown cold. So cold he could see his breath misting in the air. He shivered and felt suddenly uneasy.

The mist was moving, coalescing into shapes. Rin looked harder, trying to discern what they were becoming. They were turning into the shapes of... men. A shiver of terror went through him as he suddenly discerned a Soltish face looking out at him from the rapidly clearing mist. Ethereal warriors, both Solts and Blood Men, were forming, creating a battle line of spirits. An army of ghosts of the fallen.

Rin began to back away in fear, but he heard someone shout, “Do not flee! We shall avenge Vallus if we have to kill every last one of these foul spirits!”

Men gravitated to the sound of the voice, rallying around the Solt who had shouted the words. They were still thousands strong. We can still win this, Rin thought. The ghosts were fully formed now, Solt and Blood Man alike standing together. Rin saw one that appeared to be leading them. He stood at their front, small wisps of mist rising from his body as he moved. They charged.

The Solts stood fast, bracing themselves for the charge. As the ghosts drew closer, Rin could make out the details of their leader. He looked somehow... familiar. He looked like... No. It cannot be, he thought desperately. He stood frozen in horror as the figure drew closer. It was. It was Vallus. He did not want to believe it, but there could be no doubt now. He wore the same grin he had worn all his life, twisted now into something sinister and malicious. He could hear the Solts around him murmuring in despair. An anguished scream came from his right, “No!”

He did not have time to think of anything more before the ghosts crashed into the line, their mouths open, screaming a silent warcry. Rin lashed out with his spear in panic and terror, but his weapon passed right through the ghosts, and then they were upon him. A ghostly spear knifed through his gut, passing through his armor as if it were nothing. A searing pain exploded in his abdomen. He fled, the pain clouding his mind and pushing him on. He clutched at his side as he ran, feeling under his armor for the wound. He found none. No break in his skin, no blood at all. Only pain.

He looked around and saw to his shame that he had been one of the first to flee. Looking back he saw the Soltish line crumbling beneath the ghostly onslaught. I should be there, he thought, I should be there, fighting with them, not fleeing. Despite his thoughts, pain and fear and his instinct to survive drove him on. He sprinted faster, away from the battle to the cover of the tall grasses, where he collapsed on a small hill on the plain. From there he watched the massacre. Many men fell to ghostly weapons before the entire army was in flight. They seemed to be able to outrun the ghosts, and for a moment, Rin dared to hope that some of them might escape. That hope was crushed as the cavalry of the Blood Men swept in, easily outdistancing the men on foot and slaughtering Solts as they fled. Others armed with spears skewered fleeing men, and others still shot shortbows from their saddles. The screams of the dying filled Rin’s ears, echoing in his head.

Anger consumed him. He could not look away. He did not want to look away. He etched every death into his mind as he saw it, burning it into his memory so that he would never forget. He wanted to remember every death the Blood Men caused so that he could make them pay the price for each one. He swore to himself, standing alone on the hill, that for every fleeing man they cut down, every terrified soldier they slaughtered, he would repay them in full one day.
 
0 replies? There is sometimes a reluctance to comment on a "Part 2".
Further to what I said about Part 1, I was not convinced by this line: "... he heard someone shout, “Do not flee! We shall avenge Vallus if we have to kill every last one of these foul spirits!” ". These are primitive people - I think their natural reaction would be to fall back in disarray. Even 21st century soldiers might react the same way.
I see why you have put this as a prologue - it could take an awfully long time for your hero to figure out how to deal with deadly and invincible ghost warriors, and get revenge.
Exciting as the battle passages are, you need to ensure that your readers care what happens to these characters.
 
I liked the appearance of the ghost army but I don't know what it means in terms of the over-all narrative, that living soldiers might be terrified or unnerved by the apparitions cannot be killed by ghost warriors, that ghost warriors die again. My understanding of the first extract you posted has now shifted -- a certain realism has gone.

At the moment, coincidentally, I'm rereading Homer's Iliad and that is filled with the appearances of gods in a mist alongside the brutal and realistically described injuries and death of charioteers and foot soldiers. Your extract has something of the same quality -- Rin's anger at the end and the oath he vows. But after two extracts I'm getting a little battle-fatigued, wanting to see Rin in a different context.
 
I'm going to critique both here.

Number 1 is very good. I find doing individual fights to be very challenging and this one was both clear and realistic IMO, good work. I especially liked the ending where you surprise us with Vallus being killed, and the mysterious archer forms something of a hook to read on.

Number 2 is still good but I have some questions. What happened to the archer? Also, how were the blood men able to kill everybody if the swords of the dead can only cause pain but no real injury? I guess some of them were still left but that's not made that clear. Also, even if there are some living blood men left it must be less and why are the dead warriors such a problem if they can't really injure someone? I can see why Rin...uh..ran, but veterans of even a few battles are commonly inured to pain and will fight right through even very painful episodes, particularly if their blood is up, and you make it clear they are rallying. Then the blood men just mop them up.

Finally, why isn't Rin more upset that Valus was one of the dead attacking him? First the grandfather he loves is killed and then arises as a ghost. I would think that would be the first thing in his mind, but you don't even mention it at the end.

Despite all this criticism it was still very good overall
 
This was very vivid and I could really feel the protagonist's emotions. If I wanted to quibble, you may be a little too fond of ellipses (which should, in my opinion, be used very rarely.)

“Do not flee! We shall avenge Vallus if we have to kill every last one of these foul spirits!”

The above speech seems a little long and a bit formal for something shouted during a raging battle. It struck me as a bit too Hollywood. I might expect something like "Don't run! Kill the ********!"

Otherwise, good job.
 
Thanks all for the great criticism! :) Your advice has been a great help.
 
Oh, and joandrake, an oversight on my part for not putting it in, but the ghost's weapons can kill if you get hit enough. The idea I had was that since they are spirits of a sort, they damage the target's spirit or soul, killing them if their soul becomes damaged enough. Thank you, though for pointing that out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top