Introducing Karl Valvanchi - a rewrite by Sally Ann Melia

Status
Not open for further replies.

Sally Ann Melia

Sally Ann Melia, SF&F
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
115
Location
S A Melia is an English SF&F writer based in Surre


Thanks for your feedback last week, I have completed this rewrite, and I am now working though the longer text.

The earlier versions were listed under the heading Guy Erma and the Son of Empire.

Chapter 1 Introducing Karl Valvanchi

Karl sent in the missile droids first, but they confirmed what Karl already knew: the cave was empty. The droids counted twenty folded bunks, and as the SDLA slept in shifts, that meant forty men. A large unit to be this close to the centre, Karl thought and a first cold finger of fear touched the nape of his neck. Where were they now? And who was in command?

“Send in the cyborg,” said Karl, “slowly.”
Janice had been a nurse. Her human body had been resuscitated with a robotic core and brain at her family’s request, so she might live on as a cyborg. However, she belonged to the Zaracan military and right now Karl needed her to do a job he would never have given to a human. The cave would be protected. He directed her by the shortest route towards the back packs and watched impatiently as she dug into their possessions. The fear was still there, like an itch he could not scratch, but he had to be sure. Then he saw it, she was pulling out a silver-coated medallion moulded to resemble a geodesic dome bearing an inscription. The screen translated:

Loyal to Empire . Fearing only God

“Dome Elite,” Karl whispered with a sigh. The fear had grown, now it felt like a hand on his neck. Yet this was an irrational fear. Even reinforced with the Elite, the SDLA were not a threat, or were they? Would they attack the centre? Surely not, they did not have the weapons, and forty was never enough men. So what were they doing here? Karl heard a noise and looked up. Another backpack fell forward, its contents rolling across the floor. This triggered the snake. A coiled machine gun droid, it spiralled upwards behind Janice.


“Snake,” Karl shouted the alarm. The cyborg dropped to her belly, above and behind her the machine unleashed a circle of fire, starting high and spinning low. Its long body was a chain of bullets. She rolled fast across the floor, the bullets flying overhead. Silence. It was all over, only the snake head remained.
“Fifteen, fourteen,” Karl counted down the seconds and watched, “Thirteen, twelve, eleven…”


The snakehead span towards Janice. She rose to her toes like an athlete all set to race when an enormous explosion blasted her to the floor.
“Damn them,” Karl cursed, “a five second fuse. Why did they set a five second fuse? Damn them.” As an after-thought he added: “I’m going in.”
“No Karl,” the voice from Control sounded far away.
“It’s alright. I’m suiting up.”

Setting all other considerations aside, Karl landed his shuttle, and headed out towards the cave. Pulling down his visor, he looked for the imprints of the cyborg’s feet, and matching his footsteps to hers, he ran to the spot where the she lay. Around him, the missile droids spun fast, continuously checking, nothing moved. It felt good to be active, Karl swiftly bent to pick up the head. The blood had jellified on contact with the air. He scooped it into the neck cavity. Both head and blood would be recalibrated and reused. This was valuable work. He dragged the torso towards him, and put it under his arm, one of the legs dragged across the floor, the other rolled away.

“Don’t worry about the legs, Karl.” Control reminded him. Karl nodded. Janet’s hand was on top of the backpacks. He pulled the medallion from her pinched fingers and pushed it in his pocket. She was wearing family rings. With a sigh, he hooked the hand into his belt by the thumb. For her family, he thought, then touched the floor:
“This matting has a lead filament, that’s why the droids did not sense the snake.”
If the matting could conceal one snake, Karl started to sweat …
“Karl, you’ve done enough, just get out now.”

Outside Karl examined the craft parked alongside his shuttle.
“I want to destroy their transport. They are fully fueled and ready to go anywhere, even the space platform.”
“Karl, those are United Races registered craft. You can’t destroy them, you know that.”
“OK, but are you ready for an attack?”
“Relax Karl, you know we are ready.”
Even as Karl listened, his communicator lit up, a second call.

“Mezzatorra to Control. We are under attack. Large attack at least forty assailants. They came over the south perimeter. Please assist.”
Mezzatorra? The hand of fear was cold at his throat now, and his breathing had become shallow. What did they want with Mezzatorra? He spoke quickly:
“Karl Valvanchi here. Have you locked down?”
“Yes, lock down was successful. All personnel are secure.” The voice was Sonia’s, a recently arrived twenty-year-old assistant for the R&D team. Karl also knew why it was Sonia. The manager at Mezzatorra was sending him a subliminal message. Look, we’re not worried; the most junior member of staff is reporting the attack. So why was Karl so scared? And scared of what? As with all their bases small and large, Mezzatorra had a large comfortable secure vault. Lock down had been successful, that meant all of the staff were safely in this secure citadel, most likely the most difficult choice they faced was whether to have breakfast or simply go get some more sleep in the vault bunk room.

Sonia was still talking, laughing as she did.
What was so funny, wondered Karl?
“Most of us were still in bed, so it’s a bit like a pyjama party here.”
Karl nodded bleakly; at length he forced himself to reply.
“I won’t switch the camera on, but you’re all OK?”
“May I submit the formal lock down report?” she asked.
“Go ahead.” Karl listened to the formalities and tried to regulate his breathing. The SDLA were not a risk, even reinforced by the Dome Elite, what was the worse they could do? And this was good training for Sonia, he thought, as he placed the cyborg’s body parts in a padded crate. She has such a sweet husky voice. Sonia reputedly already had two lovers. This was not uncommon on an exploration base with such a skewed male – female ratio, but in Sonia’s case there had been gossip. Her chosen lovers had been identical twins; also she was herself so beautiful. Karl smiled as he remembered her soft curls. He had almost thought, no he was too old for her, or if not too old certainly too… he sought for the word, too jaded perhaps. Anyhow Jake and John were a better choice.

“Did you say there was only one pallet in the yard?”
The detail brought him up short, the fear returned once more, as he listened for her reply.
“Yes, that’s right. That’s what is so unusual; the SDLA would not normally bother for one pallet of Monazite.”
“Look I’m not far off. I’ll buzz them. If they’re not gone already, that should scare them off.”
“Oh great, thanks Karl. Why don’t you stop for breakfast? Jake’s planning to cook his speciality lizards.”
“Hum… Jake’s speciality lizards… What was that?”
“Oh. Look. I better check. See you Karl.”


Chapter 2 Welcome to the Dome

With a whispered prayer, Guy Erma kissed his Dome medallion and slid it inside his shirt. He stepped up to the edge of the mat. In truth, he knew he did not need God’s help today. No all he needed to win this fight, was to be ruthless, and to be quick. The gong had rung. To delay now was to be disqualified. Guy gripped the short fighting blades and somersaulted forward. He landed within reach of his opponent.

He twisted into a spinning high kick that caught and cut the other’s shoulder pad. He found his feet while the other was still unbalanced, then crouched and sliced his other leg in a circle just off the floor. In so doing, he swept his opponent’s feet from under him. The other boy fell. Guy was quick to leap up and on top of him, riding astride his adversary’s chest with two blades pressed to his neck.

“Do you yield?” Guy roared into his face
“I yield… I yield…” The other was so fearful he almost wept, and to see this sent a thrill through Guy stronger than any other emotion. His heart beat fast, as he rose panting, exhilarated and joyful: ‘He had won!’

No one watching, why would they? Across the vast competition space there were over two dozen blades mats, almost all played host to a fighting duo. As always his gaze was drawn to where the gym opened onto the vast panes and verticals of the Dome. The light was bright, yet dark geometric shadows fell across the space. Guy loved this gym felt he always fought better here, in the light and shadows of the Dome.

In the light and the shadows of the Dome, so help me God. It was a prayer of the Dome Elite. One day I will say those words, thought Guy, and wear that uniform.

Now that's a real prayer.
He sighed. So help me god.
 
This is much better. There are several comma splices. Are they a stylistic choice?

Then he saw it,
Comma splice
she was pulling out a silver-coated medallion moulded to resemble a geodesic dome bearing an inscription.

*****************

“Dome Elite,” Karl whispered with a sigh. The fear had grown,
comma splice, perhaps add 'until'
now it felt like a hand on his neck.

*************************

The cyborg dropped to her belly,
comma splice, perhaps change to new sentence

Setting all other considerations aside,
I'm not sure of the purpose of this clause
Sally Ann Melia said:
Karl landed his shuttle, and headed out towards the cave. Pulling down his visor, he looked for the imprints of the cyborg’s feet, and matching his footsteps to hers,
Why were her footprints visible on the matting?

Karl swiftly bent to pick up the head. The blood had jellified on contact with the air. He scooped it into the neck cavity. Both head and blood would be recalibrated and reused. This was valuable work. He dragged the torso towards him, and put it under his arm, one of the legs dragged across the floor, the other rolled away.
I would expect the body parts to be heavier than indicated here, and Karl seems surprisingly casual about this unpleasant task.

I can't spare any more time for this now, but I hope this helps.
 
IMO this is much better - you're using the same points of information, but you give them meaning and purpose this time.

The result is that we have a much stronger sense of tension from the start, and I really enjoyed that - especially that now Karl is wondering about the direction of any danger to himself and his colleagues.

We're left with a sense that something important is happening, a sense of exposure for Karl, and a mystery unfolding - points that did not come over very strongly in the previous draft.

My feeling now is that the text just needs a little tidying for greater immediacy - but we're into editing territory rather than rewriting now, which is good.

For example, I would - personally, because of my tastes - look to tighten up the opening paragraph to shorten the sentences for for greater impact:

Karl sent in the missile droids first. They confirmed that the cave was empty.

The reason being, like this the opening sentence now carries a stronger punch, and the second sentence sets up mystery. However, we are in the realms of personal stylistic taste here.

Another minor quibble would be try and finish Chapter 1 with something hookier - you've set up a sense of tension and mystery - I'd love to see a line at the end where Karl is unable to figure out what all that just happened means - thus help maintain the tension and mystery you started with.

Overall, much better. I hope you're feeling happier about it? :)
 
It took me a couple of days, but then I just heard the changes in my head and wrote them down.

Actually now I now know what to look for in others parts of e manuscript. As I said, extremely helpful.

And you are right about the last line ... I tried about six variations, probably at least another six to come.

Thanks

Sally
 
Sorry I did not mean 'hear the text' but I do think a couple of days always sorts out problems.

Sometimes it has taken me five days of thinking to get to the numb of a problem, and sometimes it is worth saying to yourself. I'm blocked and I need to push through to the other side.

These critiques have been very helpful, it just took me a few days to process the information..

Thanks
 
It still has the lack of detail I noted in the first version.
Just my opinion, but since this is an alien world, not East Grinstead, one could perhaps afford a bit more descriptive detail. If readers don't like descriptions of alien landscapes and futuristic hardware, one has to wonder why they would want to read SF at all.

How is Karl viewing the scene? How does he deploy the cyborg, since his shuttle is in flight at the time?
Overall this is probably better but it's hard to see what exactly has changed. You've dropped the plague escape part, I see.

Now we have a bit of Chapter 2 as well.
This isn't bad, but the main thing this shows us is that Guy Erma likes fighting. This doesn't really encourage me to read on, as I'm not interested in reading about fighting unless I'm given a reason to care about the fighters first, which isn't the case here. In fact I would say that I'm inclined to dislike Erma already.
 
Hi Sally,

These additional comments may (or may not) be useful. (Why is it always easier to do someone else's housework or critique someone else's writing?)

Janice had been a nurse. Her human body had been resuscitated with a robotic core and brain at her family’s request, so she might live on as a cyborg.
Technical information here would make the cyborg (and its use) more believable. For example, you might refer to an electronic forebrain in direct communication with the missile droids, and a human hindbrain reacting to danger.

The background on Janice might be used with greater effect later. For example, when Karl collects the body parts, he might react to memories of her family entrusting her to his care, or reflect on his duty to notify them.

“Damn them,” Karl cursed, “a five second fuse. Why did they set a five second fuse? Damn them.” As an after-thought he added: “I’m going in.”
The use of 'Karl cursed' directly after the curse is redundant. The substitution of an interaction with his environment (e.g. drummed his hand on the instrument panel) would serve double-duty by also creating a sense of place. The term 'As an after-thought' makes Karl seem impulsive, and also could be replaced by an action - unless you want to portray him as a flawed protagonist.

If the matting could conceal one snake, Karl started to sweat …
The anxiety about additional snake droids would add more tension if it was expressed as Karl entered the cave.

The manager at Mezzatorra was sending him a subliminal message.
Subtle rather than subliminal, perhaps.

He twisted into a spinning high kick that caught and cut the other’s shoulder pad.
This made me wonder how he cut the pad.

I hope this helps.
 
It still has the lack of detail I noted in the first version.
Just my opinion, but since this is an alien world, not East Grinstead, one could perhaps afford a bit more descriptive detail. If readers don't like descriptions of alien landscapes and futuristic hardware, one has to wonder why they would want to read SF at all.

How is Karl viewing the scene? How does he deploy the cyborg, since his shuttle is in flight at the time?
Overall this is probably better but it's hard to see what exactly has changed. You've dropped the plague escape part, I see.

Now we have a bit of Chapter 2 as well.
This isn't bad, but the main thing this shows us is that Guy Erma likes fighting. This doesn't really encourage me to read on, as I'm not interested in reading about fighting unless I'm given a reason to care about the fighters first, which isn't the case here. In fact I would say that I'm inclined to dislike Erma already.


Hi Geoff,,

Some of what you say ties in with other comments I had last night at my writer's circle. I like sparse writing but I could so with more reactions in thoughts or feelings in places. Ditto descriptions, I will try and drop in a few more words.

Good point re cyborg, and shuttle in flight.

As for Erma, well you can't please all the people all the time, so I take that on the chin. Just to say in my opinion you' re probably wrong.

The point being that we like or dislike writing very quickly I do as well. Not sure what the magic formula is, but if I do find out I will not be posting it here. LOL.

Sally
 
I have to say that I agree with Geoff about the second chapter. It's very tightly written and works well in terms of showing both what's going on and what Guy is thinking, but I don't think he comes out as a nice guy. He seems overly aggressive and keen to humiliate his downed opponent. He comes across to me as a bad sportsman rather than someone who is keen to win.
 
A quick opinion, for what it's worth. Probably zilch.

I found it really interesting to contrast these two chapters. (I didn't read earlier versions.) I couldn't get into chapter 1, but I like chapter 2, and I "like" Guy. I don't much care at this stage whether he's a nice person. He's a fanatic, and that makes him interesting. Also, the situation in ch2 is clear, easy to visualise, and the writing is punchy. I didn't find that with ch1, and also i didn't quickly get a sense of who or what kind of person Karl is. He didn't grab my interest, and the complex situation quickly chewed me up and spat me out.

For my taste (and possibly mine alone) you'd do better to start with ch2.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top