A bit surreal (370 words)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Fishbowl Helmet

Ask the next question...
Joined
May 14, 2012
Messages
954
This is a slightly later part of my WIP. I like what's there, but I'd like feedback on whether it works for other people as description of the scene. Does it give you a feel for the scene, does it help you visualize or just confuse?

Constructive criticism always welcome.

##########

I took out the photo of Jessica and her friend on the field trip. It might have been local, might not. Generic cityscape with a few trees and rocks. Brick buildings in the background. No street signs, no cab companies, no local color at all. It could have been taken anywhere.

“Well, ****,” I said to the girls in the picture.

Staring at the picture I knew what I had to do next. I hated using the Sight. The best way to describe magic to people who can’t use it is with drugs. Casting a spell was like doing a rail of coke. Killing someone with magic was like opiate withdrawal. But there was no fix to cure the pain, no dose that could make things right. There was no methadone. Magicians had to ride it out till they were forgiven, or learned to love the sickness. Opening your senses to the world was like an acid trip. Just like any hallucination, it could be a good trip or bad. State of mind was a big factor, so was not being surprised or interrupted.

“Show me what you’ve got.”

I focused on the girls and the trees and the rocks. My attention narrowed down till the only thing I could see was the picture. The colors popped more. Started to swirl and move. A moment later I fell in, past the white Polaroid border and into the shot.

The day was alive. People walking up and down the sidewalk. Cars honking, traffic already gnarled for rush hour. Trees bent and leaves fluttered in the wind. But the scene wasn’t crisp like the photo; seeing things this way turned the world into a broad-brushed, overly bright and gloppy oil painting that refused to hold still. Colors flowed and seeped into one another like the dyed currents of a meandering brook. The brush strokes of the world collided and collapsed, raised mounds of paint like mountains pushing toward me rather than reaching for the sky, then rolled back in eddies, sweeping the mountains into streams of flowing color. Besides the trippy visuals, this place worked on dream logic. Free association and hallucination were the order of the day, causality was ******.
 
Minor technical things:

I'd put a period after "factor" and start a new sentence with "So" at the end of the third paragraph.

I'd say "until" instead of "till" in the fifth paragraph.

I don't care for "popped more" (more than they were popping before?) very much. I'd reword it to something stronger. ("The colors popped out like a 3-D acid trip" or something.)

Otherwise, I very much like the description. The anlogy with drugs is a good one, and the surreal scene at the end is fine. (I think you even used a sentence starting with "But" and a semi-colon in ways to which I have no objections, which is a rare thing.)

Good job.
 
I really like this piece. Especially the comparison of magic to drugs; i don't think i've read anything like that before (mind you my list of books isn't very long.)

I also like the final scene. For some reason it made me think of Antoni Gaudi...
 
I also like this very much. The punchy dialogue bracketed by descriptive paragraphs really caught my attention. I've made a couple of comments and identified a couple of snatches that I think may be unnecessary (highlighted in red), but remember that I'm no expert.

Staring at the picture I knew what I had to do next. I hated using the Sight. The best way to describe magic to people who can’t use it is with drugs. Casting a spell was like doing a rail of coke. Killing someone with magic was like opiate withdrawal. But there was no fix to cure the pain, no dose that could make things right. There was no methadone. Magicians had to ride it out till they were forgiven, or learned to love the sickness. I think that would be an effective, strong sentence to end the paragraph. I'm not sure that the later sentences in the paragraph add anything essential.Opening your senses to the world was like an acid trip. Just like any hallucination, it could be a good trip or bad. State of mind was a big factor, so was not being surprised or interrupted.

“Show me what you’ve got.”

I focused on the girls and the trees and the rocks. My attention narrowed down till the only thing I could see was the picture. The colors popped more. Started to swirl and move. A moment later I fell in, past the white Polaroid border and into the shot.

The day was alive. People walking up and down the sidewalk. Cars honking, traffic already gnarled for rush hour. Trees bent and leaves fluttered in the wind.Should it be "trees bending and leaves fluttering"? But the scene wasn’t crisp like the photo; seeing things this way turned the world into a broad-brushed, overly bright and gloppy oil painting that refused to hold still. Colors flowed and seeped into one another like the dyed currents of a meandering brook. The brush strokes of the world collided and collapsed, raised mounds of paint like mountains pushing toward me rather than reaching for the sky, then rolled back in eddies, sweeping the mountains into streams of flowing color. Besides the trippy visuals, this place worked on dream logic. Free association and hallucination were the order of the day, causality was ******.
 
I liked this the way it is. There are some aesthetic flaws-things it could live with because of the tone.

As for 'The colors popped more.'
Does seem a bit awkward but it fits the narrative tone. putting too much in could disrupt the whole continuum. I'd at best suggest less maybe just 'The colors popped.' It's an old Polaroid the colors might not have been popping at all before.
 
i liked it. i agree that "the colours popped more" is a bit awkward and could probably be reduced to just "the colours popped" as i can easily imagine what that would be like

the magic description paragraph vould use a bit of tidying up (to me) as it seemed a bit unwieldy and jarring at times:

Staring at the picture I knew what I had to do next. I hated using the Sight. The best way to describe magic to people who can’t use it is with drugs. Casting a spell was like doing a rail of coke. Killing someone with magic was like opiate withdrawal.(These two sentences didn't seem to match as to me they say using magic is like doing coke, but using magic is like really bad withdrawal. To draw on your acid references below, maybe something like: "Casting a spell was like dropping a tab of LSD; killing someone with magic was like dropping a tab of LSD followed by the worst opiate withdrawal imaginable.") But there was no fix to cure the pain, no dose that could make things right. There was no methadone. (This seemed a bit superfluous) Magicians had to ride it out till they were forgiven,(?? being forgiven stops the ill effects of magic?) or learned to love the sickness. Opening your senses to the world was like an acid trip. Just like any hallucination, it could be a good trip or bad. State of mind was a big factor, so was not being surprised or (think it works better without this)interrupted.

obviously, just my opinion - i do think it's a good passage and would draw me in
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
Phyrebrat Critiques 13
Fishbowl Helmet Book Discussion 8
Tecdavid Art 13
HareBrain Art 1
Winters_Sorrow General Film Discussion 3

Similar threads


Back
Top