Surface Detail by Iain M Banks

Vertigo

Mad Mountain Man
Supporter
Joined
Jun 29, 2010
Messages
8,767
Location
Scottish Highlands
A tour de force; this was certainly the best SF book I’ve read for at least a year, probably longer. I hesitate to say it’s the best Culture book I’ve read only because it’s at least 4 years since I last read one (it was before I started keeping accurate records) which is in itself a bit shocking, since this has reminded me that Banks is, without a doubt, my favourite SF author (and up there for my non-SF authors as well).

Surface Detail has everything you could ask for. Multiple threads weave and dance their way through the story, both driving the plot on and giving it colour. Most of the characters have depth and completely believable motivation. Banks’ wry, dark humour is never far away. The pace is consistently maintained throughout, bringing the story to a comfortably tied off conclusion (though he does indulge in a little epilogue briefly telling us what happens to the main characters following the conclusion).

As for the plot itself I can only say I am, once again, completely in awe of Banks’ fertile imagination and once again put into mourning over his untimely demise. Surface Detail tells the story of a war over Hell. In a future where minds can be loaded into virtual realities, death does not have to mean oblivion. Upon death you can choose to return in a new body or continue to exist in a virtual reality. To all intents and purposes Heaven is now a reality; a virtual reality. However, some of the many civilisations throughout the galaxy believe they still need a Hell as well. A real one, not some mythological place requiring faith, but an alternative virtual reality in which those who have done wrong will suffer for all eternity with no parole; a place living wrongdoers can be made to visit, seeing what awaits them should they not mend their ways; a place where each civilisation can conjure up the most horrific evils and tortures to be wreaked upon the souls trapped there. Not all civilisations consider this to ‘humane’ (stretching that word to cover other species) and that such a barbarous concept should be opposed. And so a war is being fought over the right to run these Hells. A very civilised war that is waged only in a special virtual reality created for that purpose; no real death and carnage; no innocent civilians slaughtered; no piteous refugees. The only problem is what happens when one side starts losing? What will stop them from moving the war from the virtual to the real?

A great page turner that had me reading into the wee hours for several nights running!
 
Nice review, Vertigo.

I am rather embarrassed to say that I don't actually have this in my library yet. I need to look for a nice Hardback version.
 
Sorry you didn't get on with it HB, it was just the sort of story I love and had me hooked.

I should have mentioned the Minds; we spend a lot of time with a warship Mind who is simply great fun. If you've met and loved Asher's Sniper then you'll love the Falling Outside The Normal Moral Constraints who has a major role throughout the book.

I should also add that the book does raise some interesting questions regarding Hell(s) whose existence I don't believe has ever been claimed by any god or anyone speaking for a god (Christian, Moslem or otherwise) though I may be wrong. The idea of Hell seems to be a purely human creation.
 
Not much to add to my previous review. Seven years on I’d forgotten just how good this book is. It’s just brilliant.

To add to my previous comments, I found this particularly interesting in my reread of the whole series in that it shows the Culture deliberately trying to take a back seat in something that would normally, and indeed is, an issue of significant moral concern to them. Officially take a back seat that is; one particular Culture ship, the Falling Outside the Normal Moral Constraints, dances a decidedly fine line on that and Banks clearly had a lot of fun writing it! However, the Culture, and indeed other higher level galactic civilisations, must step back from this one for fear of being seen to be bullying lover level civilisations. A delicate balance that Banks uses to further flesh out the moral tugs of war that a civilisation like the Culture would have to wage to try and prevent evil whilst not doing evil itself. Several times during the evolution of the Culture Banks stated that he probably could not do much more without rehashing issues previously covered. And yet he kept coming back to his “train set” (as he once put it) with something new to say.
 
As much i think that TPoG is my favourite Culture novel, I think that Surface Detail is his best one. The imagination shown here is just staggering, I was a little unimpressed with the revelation at the end, though.
 
As much i think that TPoG is my favourite Culture novel, I think that Surface Detail is his best one. The imagination shown here is just staggering, I was a little unimpressed with the revelation at the end, though.
Yes, I'd have to agree with your view on the final revelation; it's not like it actually held any significance to the story or in anyway changed the conclusion or how the reader viewed it. Nothing would have changed had he left it out so making it the final word, so to speak, detracted from the real conclusion. I guess he'd always had it in his head whilst writing it and felt he ought to tell the readers but really there were enough pointers that it was no great surprise.

Funnily enough I think I'd agree with you that for me too TPoG is also still my favourite whilst this is possibly his best one. TPoG had a moral simplicity to it whilst still addressing serious moral issues. I think that simplicity made it very accessible and easy to like.
 

Similar threads


Back
Top