TEiN sitting in the stocks: waiting for the tomatoes

Status
Not open for further replies.

TheEndIsNigh

...Prepare Thyself
Supporter
Joined
Mar 16, 2008
Messages
3,282
Hi folks.

Below is the opening chapter to my new book as mentioned in my blog. Cast your comments, eggs and tomatoes as you will. Hope you like it.


The Zoanz

"Got you,” Jane said, activating the micro suction. The sperm, struggling and twisting was drawn into the needle and held fast. She rotated the turntable holding the petri-dish and focused until an egg filled the screen. Gently, ever so gently she pushed the needle through the outer membrane until it punctured. Releasing the suction ejected the sperm and the egg was fertilised.

Doctor Jane Fields relaxed. It was another potential embryo. The DNA of the sperm had been altered. The mosquito would produce only male offspring. Eventually, female mosquitos would be the rarest thing in the world. She rotated the turntable again and captured another sperm. There were only another 4021 left. She looked at the clock, only eleven; she was feeling peckish and definitely regretting volunteering to help in the process.

By lunchtime she had reduced the task to 3953 which was, she thought, pretty impressive, but the refectory beckoned. Looking at the menu she felt someone was taking the piss with the 'The Specials'. Devilled Eggs was top of the bill. Grinning, she selected the cheese salad sandwich and looked around the tables. By the window sat Peter, ah Peter. The seat opposite him was empty. As she made her way through the tables she reached up and loosened another button on her blouse. He probably wouldn't notice it, but it was worth a try.

"Peter, mind if I sit here?"

He looked up, offering recognition, but as she bent down to place her tray he was already studying his newspaper so missed the offered view of her cleavage.

'And some fell on stony ground', she thought as she settled to the task of freeing the sandwich from its Kevlar like wrapping.

Looking up the sight that met was not what she had hoped, but rather the headlines of the newspaper he was reading.

"MYSTERY OF MISSING SATELLITES".​

She grabbed the paper from Peter's hand and read the lead story.

‘NASA was at a loss to explain the apparent disappearance of the Martian orbiter satellites.

"Contact with the satellites and the Martian colony, was lost yesterday, but the problem is temporary and communication to the colony is expected to be restored later today," a NASA spokesman said.'

"Peter!" she said, "Have you read this?"

"Oh that, yes, it's probably atmospherics," he said, "They claim it's happened before."

"Well, they must have kept it qui...”.

Peter was looking at her strangely. Had he finally noticed? Wait, he was looking past her, his mouth open with a growing sense of apprehension, no more: fear.

She looked over her shoulder. In in the sky there were hundreds of spheres. At first she thought they were hovering just above the buildings, but then some of them passed behind a cloud and she realised they must be high, very high. ‘My God’, she thought, ‘they must be massive’. Now she understood the reason for Peter's fearful look.

Something caught Jane's attention, the outside of the building was in chaos. People were staring into the sky in disbelief or praying for deliverance. In contrast others, like wolves, were forming packs to prey on the weak and helpless. Already the boundaries of civilisation were breaking down.

"Peter, what are they? What should we do? Peter! Peter!" She hit him across the face. It did the trick: he broke from the trance-like stupor and grabbed her hand.

"Quick, we have to move,” he said. "Follow me. No! Forget the bag, we haven't time."

"Where?" she said, pushing the table away as he nearly dragged her across it.

"Your labs,” he replied, "It's the most secure building on campus. If we get there we can lock it down and be safe until we find out what the f*ck is going on."

Jane followed, now she knew the plan; quite a reasonable plan: she was determined to follow it. Her lab was secure and only a few people had access rights. As a biological research centre it had everything needed to resist even determined attempts to enter. Since the protests against genetic manipulation, all such faculties had had to introduce quite draconian measures to prevent Joe public gaining access. Yes, her building would be like a safe room which had all the bells and whistles needed to resist even a heavily armed assault.

Outside several bodies lay bloodied robbed of anything valuable. In the thirty minutes since the spheres arrived they had reduced mankind to its most basic level.

Jane's building was across an open plaza from the refectory. They were lucky, having nothing valuable; they managed to cross the square with only a minimum of violence. Peter floored one of two guys who showed more interest than he should in Jane. The other, Jane left doubled up in agony after she kicked him in the bollocks.

"Enter the code!" Peter said, fending off another attacker.

She placed her tag near the sensor and entered the digits. The door opened and they rushed through, it closed behind them. The second door held firmly shut. Normally it would have opened automatically, but the system had detected two people.

"Dr. Jane Fields with Peter Evans I.D. six, four, four, one."

"Scanning! Peter Evans, Department of Biological Engineering." The system had read Peter's tag. "Confirm status!”

"Peter Evans, guest,” Jane said.

"Status accepted and logged."

The second door slid open, closing immediately after they went through. The front door was opening again. Jane looked to see who came through. It was Desmond Felton, her deputy, he was alone and bleeding from a nasty gash above the eye.

The system allowed him straight through, seeing Peter he was puzzled.

"He's with me," Jane said, "We were eating together. It was his idea we come here."

Felton accepted it without comment.

"Anyone else makes it in?” he said.

"We've only just arrived,” Jane said, "Most of the staff and students were in the kitchen when I went out to lunch. They may not know what's happened."

"Are we sure it's an invasion?” Felton said matter of factually. He had stated what the three of them were thinking, but hearing it out loud just made it sound more unbelievable.

"What else could it be?” Peter said. "Those spheres are well beyond anything I've heard about. In any case, given what's happening outside, we need to protect ourselves. Jane! Lock it down."

Felton gave Peter a look as though to say who put you in charge, but he could see it made sense and nodded to Jane.

"He's right Jane, better play it safe."

"System. Bio Lab lockdown,” she said.

"Protocol?” the system responded, following the pre-programed dialog that would end in the building turning into a small fortress.

"Management Only." Management only allowed only Bio Lab management personnel to enter the building and since that was herself and Felton, no one else would be coming through the door without their knowledge. Anyone with a correct access code would cause the system to ask for confirmation.

"Accepted!”

Three things happened. The outer glass door acquired an armour plated shield as did all the windows and fire exits. The positive air pressure system was extended to the whole building not just the areas near the labs. The emergency mains backup system became fully active.

They headed for the building's kitchen and dining area. There were about twenty people sat in a circle; they were all glued to the screen. It was showing the BBC main news. So far the reporters were saying the spheres had done nothing so all that was available was speculation and theorising about what it all meant.

When the three of them entered, the assembly broke into a chaotic rabble of questions.

Peter shouted for calm and reason.

"Look! We know as much as you do, maybe even less. Switch on the security screens,” he said.

Someone got the idea and the screens changed to a sixteen panel view of the cameras covering the building. Peter touched the section showing the front door and square and it expanded to fill the whole screen.

Large numbers were clamouring to get in. One guy was smashing the keypad with his phone as though it held some magic property that would open the door.

"That's Simon Ward," she said. Can't we let him in?"

"No!" Peter and Des shouted in unison.

"There are too many," Des said, "If you open the door he will be trampled anyway and then the others will have to be dealt with".

Jane seemed unconvinced looking to Peter for support. There was none.

"Look at this!” one of the students said, holding up his phone. The small screen was virtually impossible to see. "Switch to Al Jazeera News".

The screen filled with pictures of a great city. Most of it had been destroyed.

"Where the f*ck is that?” said one of the students.

There was no commentary, but the news banner at the bottom of the screen filled in the detail.

'Pictures from India News Corporation. Deli has been destroyed.'
 
First of all the usual warning: I'm a very novice writer and critiquer, so bear that in mind when you read my comments.

I like the story - it's exciting and lots of action from the word go, but it seems a tad familiar (Independence Day, etc.). Also I wondered if society would break down quite that quickly at just the first glimpse of spheres in the sky, with people killing each other for their belongings. Personally I'd be off to gather the family and run with them to the most remote place I could find, there to hide out eating berries lol!

Looking up the sight that met was not what she had hoped, but rather the headlines of the newspaper he was reading.

Sight that met her eyes was not...?

‘NASA was at a loss to explain the apparent disappearance of the Martian orbiter satellites.

"Contact with the satellites and the Martian colony, was lost yesterday, but the problem is temporary and communication to the colony is expected to be restored later today," a NASA spokesman said.'

This came across as a bit clunky. Maybe the first line could be put in with the rest, as a quote from the paper, because I found the change of tense confusing.

In in the sky

Repeated word.

Since the protests against genetic manipulation, all such faculties

Facilities might be better?

Outside several bodies lay bloodiedcomma robbed of anything valuable.

"Anyone else makes make it in?” he said.

There are some more punctuation issues which could improve the way it reads, but since I'm possibly the world's worst offender with punctuation, I'll leave to my betters to point them out!

It's a really gripping beginning though. Looking forward to the rest.
 
I caught a few punctuation things, not many, but will see if Chrispy comes along. If not, I'll do a line by line, fwiw.

Overall, I liked it. The use of her full name at the start of the 2nd paragraph jarred for me and pulled me out of close third. I think there are plenty of places you could get that info in more smoothly. In general, I didn't feel hugely close to the characters. That doesn't feel like a problem, it's close enough for a lot of sf, and I'm not sure fighting to get closer would improve things markedly.

My one big problem is how quickly people broke down, societal wise. I suspect it might be part of the story, how quickly it happened, but if not I simply don't believe they'd behave as they did here. To get to that point there has to be a flashpoint - a person yelling we're all doomed, a running news show showing Delhi being destroyed at the beginning, something more than a distant threat. Confusion would be the response I'd expect, not anarchy. Not yet. Especially in a work environment trained in emergency drills. (Years ago, I worked in the main shopping centre in Belfast, during the Troubles. Our staff were drilled in taking a bomb-scare call - and one of them had - on finding a suspect device, on evacuating the premises. When people are trained in what to do when the s**t hits the fan, I think they are less inclined to break down quickly in general.)
 
Great to see you back here, TEIN! I've got no time now, and I'm out for the day in a bit, but I'll try and have a look later.
 
I agree about the breakdown speed as it way too fast for everything happen that way. Some people won't even notice before an alien will stand at front of them. Some of them won't come from their buildings like for ever. BUT ... I accept it in the story as there was far more things that kept me reading than pushing me out. So take that as a good sign, please.
 
Hope you like it.
I do :cheeky grin:

I'll have to come back later with a more clear answer, (time to run, my "go to work" alarm just went off) but I was hooked right off, held throughout, disappointed when I ran out of words... the characters for the most part felt real, and reacted in real ways to what was going on. Jane is especially good; Peter delightfully dense... I thought the masses devolved rather quickly for being a campus setting, but then thought better of it, so I'll figure out which side of that fence I'm on later.

Only thing I could ask for is a reason Peter didnt react to his paper being taken away, or a reaction.
 
So, good stuff.

I'm a bit concerned about going from fertilizing to disappearing Martian Probes to Invasion in such a short hope but if it's short story then maybe that works.

I'm not so concerned about the paper snatching; that happens a lot.

I'm wondering though::

She looked over her shoulder. In in the sky there were hundreds of spheres. At first she thought they were hovering just above the buildings, but then some of them passed behind a cloud and she realised they must be high, very high. ‘My God’, she thought, ‘they must be massive’. Now she understood the reason for Peter's fearful look.

Something caught Jane's attention, the outside of the building was in chaos. People were staring into the sky in disbelief or praying for deliverance. In contrast others, like wolves, were forming packs to prey on the weak and helpless. Already the boundaries of civilisation were breaking down.

"Peter, what are they? What should we do? Peter! Peter!" She hit him across the face. It did the trick: he broke from the trance-like stupor and grabbed her hand.

"Quick, we have to move,” he said. "Follow me. No! Forget the bag, we haven't time."

"Where?" she said, pushing the table away as he nearly dragged her across it.

"Your labs,” he replied, "It's the most secure building on campus. If we get there we can lock it down and be safe until we find out what the f*ck is going on."

Something about this part seems cheesy to me.
Not too cheesy just a mild cheese.
 
Hi folks.

Below is the opening chapter to my new book as mentioned in my blog. Cast your comments, eggs and tomatoes as you will. Hope you like it.


The Zoanz

"Got you,” Jane said, activating the micro suction. The sperm, struggling and twisting was drawn into the needle and held fast. She rotated the turntable holding the petri-dish and focused until an egg filled the screen. Gently, ever so gently she pushed the needle through the outer membrane until it punctured. Releasing the suction ejected the sperm and the egg was fertilised. Interesting opener

Doctor Jane Fields Giving her full name like this feels like a mis-step. relaxed. It was another potential embryo. The DNA of the sperm had been altered. The mosquito would produce only male offspring. Eventually, female mosquitos would be the rarest thing in the world. She rotated the turntable again and captured another sperm. There were only another 4021 left. She looked at the clock, only eleven; she was feeling peckish and definitely regretting volunteering to help in the process. Interesting

By lunchtime she had reduced the task to 3953 which was, she thought, pretty impressive, but the refectory beckoned. Looking at the menu she felt someone was taking the piss with the 'The Specials'. Devilled Eggs was top of the bill. Grinning, she selected the cheese salad sandwich and looked around the tables. By the window sat Peter, ah Peter. The seat opposite him was empty. As she made her way through the tables she reached up and loosened another button on her blouse. He probably wouldn't notice it, but it was worth a try. Not so interesting.

"Peter, mind if I sit here?"

He looked up, offering recognition, but as she bent down to place her tray he was already studying his newspaper so missed the offered view of her cleavage.

'And some fell on stony ground', she thought as she settled to the task of freeing the sandwich from its Kevlar like wrapping.

Looking up the sight that met was not what she had hoped, but rather the headlines of the newspaper he was reading. Nothing very interesting about her lunch hour so far.

"MYSTERY OF MISSING SATELLITES".​



"Well, they must have kept it qui...”. Interesting development.

Peter was looking at her strangely. Had he finally noticed? Wait, he was looking past her, his mouth open with a growing sense of apprehension, no more: fear.

She looked over her shoulder. In in the sky there were hundreds of spheres. At first she thought they were hovering just above the buildings, but then some of them passed behind a cloud and she realised they must be high, very high. ‘My God’, she thought, ‘they must be massive’. Now she understood the reason for Peter's fearful look. I feel that introducing the spheres here is rushing the story too much.

Something caught Jane's attention, the outside of the building was in chaos. People were staring into the sky in disbelief or praying for deliverance. In contrast others, like wolves, were forming packs to prey on the weak and helpless. Already the boundaries of civilisation were breaking down. It doesn't seem likely that social breakdown would occur such a short time (a few minutes?) after some mysterious spheres appear in the sky. More likely after sufficient time had elapsed for most people to see them and the media to identify them as a deadly alien menace - say a day or two at least. (And how long did it take to identify the Islamic State (IS) as a menace?)

"Peter, what are they? What should we do? Peter! Peter!" She hit him across the face. It did the trick: he broke from the trance-like stupor and grabbed her hand.

"Quick, we have to move,” he said. "Follow me. No! Forget the bag, we haven't time." What bag? And how many seconds does it take to pick up a handbag? She had to hit him to wake him up and then he pulls his macho stuff? Is Peter an idiot?



Jane's building was across an open plaza from the refectory. They were lucky, having nothing valuable; they managed to cross the square with only a minimum of violence. Peter floored one of two guys who showed more interest than he should in Jane. The other, Jane left doubled up in agony after she kicked him in the bollocks. As I said, I doubt that social breakdown would occur so quickly

"Enter the code!" Peter said, fending off another attacker.



The second door slid open, closing immediately after they went through. The front door was opening again. Jane looked to see who came through. It was Desmond Felton, her deputy, he was alone and bleeding from a nasty gash above the eye. It's not clear what's happening here. Have they entered a room? (Describe it.) Is the front door the same one they came through, or another? How exactly does Jane see who is coming in?

The system allowed him straight through, comma splice seeing Peter he was puzzled.

"He's with me," Jane said, "We were eating together. It was his idea we come here."

Felton accepted it without comment.

"Anyone else makes it in?” he said.

"We've only just arrived,” Jane said, "Most of the staff and students were in the kitchen when I went out to lunch. They may not know what's happened."

"Are we sure it's an invasion?” Felton said matter of factually. He had stated what the three of them were thinking, but hearing it out loud just made it sound more unbelievable.

"What else could it be?” Peter said. "Those spheres are well beyond anything I've heard about. In any case, given what's happening outside, we need to protect ourselves. Jane! Lock it down."

Felton gave Peter a look as though to say who put you in charge, but he could see it made sense and nodded to Jane.

"He's right Jane, better play it safe."

"System. Bio Lab lockdown,” she said.

"Protocol?” the system responded, following the pre-programed dialog that would end in the building turning into a small fortress.

"Management Only." Management only allowed only Bio Lab management personnel to enter the building and since that was herself and Felton, no one else would be coming through the door without their knowledge. Anyone with a correct access code would cause the system to ask for confirmation.

"Accepted!”

Three things happened. The outer glass door acquired an armour plated shield as did all the windows and fire exits. The positive air pressure system was extended to the whole building not just the areas near the labs. The emergency mains backup system became fully active. I'm not convinced that a building in some sort of urban location (which you haven't described, actually) would have powered shields for all the doors and windows. If it needed this sort of security I feel it more likely that it would be in a rural location with a high barbed wire fence around it, and some armed guards.

They headed for the building's kitchen and dining area. There were about twenty people sat in a circle; they were all glued to the screen. It was showing the BBC main news. So far the reporters were saying the spheres had done nothing so all that was available was speculation and theorising about what it all meant.

When the three of them entered, the assembly broke into a chaotic rabble of questions.

Peter shouted for calm and reason.

"Look! We know as much as you do, maybe even less. Switch on the security screens,” he said.

Someone got the idea and the screens changed to a sixteen panel view of the cameras covering the building. Peter touched the section showing the front door and square and it expanded to fill the whole screen.

Large numbers were clamouring to get in. One guy was smashing the keypad with his phone as though it held some magic property that would open the door. Begs the question of why they want to be inside this building with an alien invasion going on. To avoid the social breakdown?

"That's Simon Ward," she said. Can't we let him in?"

"No!" Peter and Des shouted in unison.

"There are too many," Des said, "If you open the door he will be trampled anyway and then the others will have to be dealt with".

Jane seemed unconvinced looking to Peter for support. There was none.

"Look at this!” one of the students said, holding up his phone. The small screen was virtually impossible to see. "Switch to Al Jazeera News".

The screen filled with pictures of a great city. Most of it had been destroyed.

"Where the f*ck is that?” said one of the students.

There was no commentary, but the news banner at the bottom of the screen filled in the detail.

'Pictures from India News Corporation. Deli has been destroyed.'

Looking through the above it looks like I've been rather negative about your story. That's not my intention so much as the way I approach a crit. Rather I've raised the kind of questions that any reader might.
You have aimed for a fast pace, but that isn't a guarantee of success. The real priority is keeping the reader's interest, which means giving them enough detail to build the characters and paint the setting, as well as keeping the story moving.

I have cut bits to keep this post under 10,000 characters.
 
I expect people would go bananas fairly rapidly, but at first they would all stand pointing cellphones at any alien invader types, at least till their batteries ran down. Then they would panic and start looting supermarkets.
 
Like this, Springs?

TEIN said:
The Zoanz
"Got you,” Jane said, activating the micro suction. The sperm, struggling and twisting
Comma
was drawn into the needle and held fast. She rotated the turntable holding the petri-dish and focused until an egg filled the screen. Gently, ever so gently
Comma
she pushed the needle through the outer membrane until it punctured. Releasing the suction ejected the sperm and the egg was fertilised.

Doctor Jane Fields relaxed. It was another potential embryo. The DNA of the sperm had been altered. The mosquito would produce only male offspring. Eventually, female mosquitos would be the rarest thing in the world. She rotated the turntable again and captured another sperm.
Rather a lot of very short sentences for a low intensity scene.
There were only another 4021 left. She looked at the clock, only eleven; she was feeling peckish and definitely regretting volunteering to help in the process.

By lunchtime she had reduced the task to 3953 which was, she thought, pretty impressive, but the refectory beckoned. Looking at the menu she felt someone was taking the piss with the 'The Specials'.
This is really one extended concept, so perhaps a semicolon instead of a full stop? (not grammatically essential)
Devilled Eggs was top of the bill. Grinning, she selected the cheese salad sandwich and looked around the tables. By the window sat Peter, ah
Probably a comma here (try saying it out loud. Where no-one can hear you, preferably).
Peter. The seat opposite him was empty. As she made her way through the tables she reached up and loosened another button on her blouse. He probably wouldn't notice it, but it was worth a try.

"Peter, mind if I sit here?"

He looked up, offering recognition, but as she bent down to place her tray he was already studying his newspaper so missed the offered view of her cleavage.

'And some fell on stony ground', she thought as she settled to the task of freeing the sandwich from its Kevlar-like wrapping.

Looking up
Comma
the sight that met
missing
was not what she had hoped, but rather the headlines of the newspaper he was reading.
"MYSTERY OF MISSING SATELLITES".
She grabbed the paper from Peter's hand and read the lead story.

‘NASA was
Probably, as this is direct from the newspaper quote, 'NASA is'.
at a loss to explain the apparent disappearance of the Martian orbiter satellites.
"Contact with the satellites and the Martian colony,
No comma.
was lost yesterday, but the problem is temporary and communication to the colony is expected to be restored later today," a NASA spokesman said.'

"Peter!" she said, "Have you read this?"

"Oh that, yes, it's probably atmospherics," he said,
Probably full stop (period) rather than comma, if you're starting a new sentence with 'They' capitalised.
"They claim it's happened before."
"Well, they must have kept it qui...”.

Peter was looking at her strangely. Had he finally noticed? Wait, he was looking past her, his mouth open with a growing sense of apprehension, no
Comma; 'no more' would indicate the fear had finished.
more: fear.

She looked over her shoulder. In in the sky there were hundreds of spheres. At first she thought they were hovering just above the buildings, but then some of them passed behind a cloud and she realised they must be high, very high. ‘My God’, she thought, ‘they must be massive’. Now she understood the reason for Peter's fearful look.

Something caught Jane's attention,
Comma splice
the outside of the building was in chaos. People were staring into the sky in disbelief or praying for deliverance. In contrast others, like wolves, were forming packs to prey on the weak and helpless. Already the boundaries of civilisation were breaking down.

"Peter, what are they? What should we do? Peter! Peter!" She hit him across the face. It did the trick: he broke from the trance-like stupor and grabbed her hand.

"Quick, we have to move,” he said. "Follow me. No! Forget the bag,
Technically a comma splice, but works fine.
we haven't time."

"Where?" she said, pushing the table away as he nearly dragged her across it.

"Your labs,” he replied,
Full stop rather than comma.
"It's the most secure building on campus. If we get there we can lock it down and be safe until we find out what the f*ck is going on."

Jane followed, now she knew the plan; quite a reasonable plan: she was determined to follow it.
Interesting punctuation here.
Her lab was secure and only a few people had access rights. As a biological research centre it had everything needed to resist even determined attempts to enter. Since the protests against genetic manipulation,
Do you really need a pause here?
all such faculties had had to introduce quite draconian measures to prevent Joe public gaining access. Yes, her building would be like a safe room which had all the bells and whistles needed to resist even a heavily armed assault.

Outside several bodies lay bloodied robbed of anything valuable. In the thirty minutes since the spheres arrived they had reduced mankind to its most basic level.

Jane's building was across an open plaza from the refectory. They were lucky, having nothing valuable; they managed to cross the square with only a minimum of violence. Peter floored one of two guys who showed more interest than he should in Jane. The other, Jane left doubled up in agony after she kicked him in the bollocks.

"Enter the code!" Peter said, fending off another attacker.

She placed her tag near the sensor and entered the digits. The door opened and they rushed through, it closed behind them. The second door held firmly shut. Normally it would have opened automatically, but the system had detected two people.

"Dr. Jane Fields with Peter Evans I.D. six, four, four, one."

"Scanning! Peter Evans, Department of Biological Engineering." The system had read Peter's tag. "Confirm status!”

"Peter Evans, guest,” Jane said.

"Status accepted and logged."

The second door slid open, closing immediately after they went through. The front door was opening again. Jane looked to see who came through. It was Desmond Felton, her deputy,
Comma splice
he was alone and bleeding from a nasty gash above the eye.

The system allowed him straight through,
Comma splice.
seeing Peter he was puzzled.

"He's with me," Jane said,
Full stop.
"We were eating together. It was his idea we come here."

Felton accepted it
That?
without comment.
"Anyone else makes
make?
it in?” he said.
 
"We've only just arrived,” Jane said,
Full stop.
"Most of the staff and students were in the kitchen when I went out to lunch. They may not know what's happened."

"Are we sure it's an invasion?” Felton said matter of factually. He had stated what the three of them were thinking, but hearing it out loud just made it sound more unbelievable.

"What else could it be?” Peter said. "Those spheres are well beyond anything I've heard about. In any case, given what's happening outside, we need to protect ourselves. Jane! Lock it down."

Felton gave Peter a look as though to say 'who put you in charge?', but he could see it made sense and nodded to Jane.

"He's right Jane,
Comma splice.
better play it safe."
"System. Bio Lab lockdown,” she said.

"Protocol?” the system responded, following the pre-programed dialog that would end in the building turning into a small fortress.

"Management Only." Management only allowed only Bio Lab management personnel to enter the building and since that was herself and Felton, no one else would be coming through the door without their knowledge. Anyone
else?
with a correct access code would cause the system to ask for confirmation.

"Accepted!”

Three things happened. The outer glass door acquired an armour plated shield
Comma
as did all the windows and fire exits. The positive air pressure system was extended to the whole building
Comma?
not just the areas near the labs. The emergency mains backup system became fully active.

They headed for the building's kitchen and dining area. There were about twenty people sat
seated?
in a circle; they were all glued to the screen. It was showing the BBC main news. So far
Comma?
the reporters were saying
Comma?
the spheres had done nothing
Comma
so all that was available was speculation and theorising about what it all meant.

When the three of them entered,
Do you need this comma.
the assembly broke into a chaotic rabble of questions.

Peter shouted for calm and reason.

"Look! We know as much as you do
Perhaps 'we know no more' or something like that?
, maybe even less. Switch on the security screens,” he said.

Someone got the idea and the screens changed to a sixteen panel view of the cameras covering the building. Peter touched the section showing the front door and square and it expanded to fill the whole screen.

Large numbers were clamouring to get in. One guy was smashing the keypad with his phone as though it held some magic property that would open the door.

"That's Simon Ward," she said. Can't we let him in?"

"No!" Peter and Des shouted in unison.

"There are too many," Des said, "If you open the door he will be trampled anyway and then the others will have to be dealt with".

Jane seemed unconvinced
Comma
looking to Peter for support. There was none.

"Look at this!” one of the students said, holding up his phone. The small screen was virtually impossible to see. "Switch to Al Jazeera News".

The screen filled with pictures of a great city. Most of it had been destroyed.

"Where the f*ck is that?” said one of the students.

There was no commentary, but the news banner at the bottom of the screen filled in the detail.

'Pictures from India News Corporation. Deli
New Dehi? Or a New York eatery?
has been destroyed.'
 
First off: Thanks for the critiques. All very useful and will be heeded.

To explain the background a bit, this started out as an idea for a short story - hence the seemingly fast pace.

After 7000 words I realised it just wasn't going to work as a short piece so I intend to try to make it into a novel.

Even so your comments are very useful :-

Kerrybuchanan: I think your comments were pointed and valid and you should have no worries about your lack of experience. Thanks

I worried about the Independence day similarity too.
Others have mentioned the break down being too quick - I have a solution.
I'll try the headlines and possibly make it scrunched up as though in a column/paper.
Corrections appreciated and noted
Thanks again.

Springs:
CTG:

As you said (and as Chris did point out) a few errors there. As above with the breakdown. As I mentioned I have and explanation that should work. Thanks.

hopewrites: Yes, I agree about the paper and will work on that Thanks.

Tinkerdan: Wensleydale perhaps?

Cosmic Geoff: Too many points to comment on but all have been noted and have helped. Fear not about the apparent negativity. I can assure you they are not taken as such, I prefer constructive. Thanks

J Riff: Noted and I am working on it. Thanks.

Chris: Very instructive. Thanks for taking the time to add your corrections - Any chance of a mind link so I don't do then in the first place.

Once again. Thanks to all.
 
TEiN, sorry I didn't get back before. I share the others' concerns over the speed of events, though this could be explained if the spheres were perhaps actively destroying people's minds, activating loss of self-control or something. I also had problems with everyone's reactions -- rather than being tense and dramatic, the scene for me spilled over into melodramatic, as if they were all bad actors in a US afternoon soap opera, rather than real people!

As to the opening paras, oddly enough I read a piece about the fight against malaria and other mosquito-carried diseases only last week, which raised the issue of genetically-modified males carrying lethal genes. However, as a scientist, wouldn't Jane think of the exact species, or at least genus, she is working on, rather than just "mosquito"? There are apparently over 40 genera and thousands of species, not all of which are even blood-suckers, let alone dangerous to humans and their live-stock. In any event, I trust the mosquitoes, or the male-only offspring technique, will be the way the aliens will be thwarted in the end? If not, then I'd suggest using whatever is relevant to the denouement as the starting point to give a sense of unity.

Anyway, an interesting first draft. It didn't pull me in quite as much as your other pieces have done, but that could be my non-science bent talking.
 
Incidentally, r strategy insects (like mosquitos) the screwfly solution (sterilising one of the sexes) is useless, and if somebody puts it forward as a solution, they're going for a grant from the Gates foundation. I might (and this is a fairly long shot) work on tzetze, or Rodnius Prolixus.
 
Chris: A bit off topic but hey, its my topic.

Not quite sure what you meant by your post. The purpose of the work my heroine was doing was to produce not sterile, but genetically modified eggs resulting in only male mosquitoes. The reasoning being that the female would be fertilised and lay the male only eggs. The mosquitoes play no further part in my plot. The idea was to introduce the work she was capable of and the facilities she had at her disposal.

Apparently, listening to a R4 program recently there's a mosquito that just loves to eat other mosquitos. The program also highlighted that following the success of Gates net program that selection is now favouring mosquitoes that bite during the daytime when the nets are down.

Gates' net program (OK it might not be all his doing but he is in there at least) has had an impact though and it is to his credit that he is making the attempt.
 
I found there were elements of telling that I didn’t like much, such as….

Already the boundaries of civilisation were breaking down – stated but not shown too much at the point.

In the thirty minutes since the spheres arrived they had reduced mankind to its most basic level – Why 30 minutes? As the main character had just picked up a paper how would they know?

the outside of the building was in chaos – No more detail was provided, which I would have liked.

Descriptions of what people looked like - was it a sunny day, were there a lot of people about, were never described well. So I felt scene setting needed to fit together better. There were some very nice details from the character in places and a lot of description of them getting into their building, which were fine. But linking these together were vague sections, so it didn’t flow well at all for me. I think more scene setting is needed and more from the character, emotions and what was happening around them and only them. The run back from the canteen should have been a confused affair, why is this happening, and from the character only – so a stricter POV was needed. Reactions and realism, already mentioned. There were some good bits in there, so I know you can write. Take your time with it and work it up properly, don’t rush so much. Anyway, what I think only. Good luck with it.
 
Good that you have a solution for the fast breakdown of civilization. That means this is perfect IMO. Interesting, exciting and true to life as to how life in a laboratory really is. (Or at least seems to be to someone who doesn't work in one, which works out to pretty much the same thing.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top