Atypical structure request on overweight, grieving lady.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Phyrebrat

www.beanwriting.com
Supporter
Joined
Feb 13, 2011
Messages
6,187
Location
In your bedroom wardrobe...
Hi,

I have been working on keeping my short stories (relatively) short and here is the opening of one I recently finished in which a woman sublimates her dissatisfaction at life and general ennui by -ahem- giving birth to multiple 'adults' in a theatre who then dance away to nothing.

It's not sci-fi, it's not fantasy (whaddaya mean people don't give birth to adults? ;) ) and the delivery section comes out of leftfield.

The question is regarding the theatre section - where the main 'action' happens; in terms of column inches it is meant to be kept minimum and interrupted with the POVs reeling mind and what has brought her to this place. It's a little under 5k and here is the first 1.3k.

Is this structure accessible? Is it acceptable to you? I fully anticipate it's not everyone's cup of tea and I should say Samuel Beckett is one of my heroes so I often find myself going in an absurdist direction with genre (as Mouse and VenusianBroon could confirm :eek: ). I don't expect much participation in this crit but I have no one else to run this by.

Not looking for a line edit (unless you fancy) more an impression and whether it is a hard read.

Thanks

pH


Mary looked across the auditorium and down at the rows of penguin-men and hummingbird-women who perched expectantly in the stalls. Each row down there was bristling with expectation at the prospect of seeing the latest piece of recommended dance theatre, and she felt that they were just as excited to be witnessing this on its premiere night as opposed to any real appreciation of the artist himself. If the press had told them to go and see this “unmissable” piece of dance in their underwear they surely would have done so. They sat in their splendid plumage; the penguins in black and white tuxedos, the hummingbirds in iridescent organza, silk and taffeta finery, most with fascinators, hair piled in elegant nests.

And she, then, a dull city pigeon in the upper circle, her broken grey umbrella sulking under the seat, her khaki woolen coat that was wearing away at the lapel folded damply across her lap, and in an uncomfortable blue-grey trouser suit that she had bought for her mother's funeral.

'I'm very sorry, madam, that's the only colour left in your size,' the assistant had said, clearly aiming for an air of kindness but looking awkward from the tightness of her brow. Mary had been putting on weight for about a year now - as soon as she began caring for Mum - and this was the first time in a year that she had been forced to buy something fitted. Her friend Josephine had been kind in her assessment of her weight gain telling her it was only her body retaining fluids, “to help flush out the toxins,” but she'd never clarified to Mary what the toxins where or why fluid retention would assist in the actual expulsion of them. In any case, Mary had happily consumed this small morsel of enablement and carried on with her diet of ready-made meals and bready snacks. When Mum had passed mercifully early from the colonic cancer that she had been suffering from in secret, the impact of her poor convenience diet had been highlighted; she had gone to the cheap market boutique
Haslets to buy a suit for the funeral. Humiliated, but nineteen pounds ninety-nine lighter in her purse, she had left the store.

Mum had left what money she had to Mary as sole heir. Mary gained even more weight during the process of executing the estate, a comfort diet taking the place of the convenience one. She paid off a few utility bills and argued for levity with the local council for an unpaid council tax bill of over a year and a half. The council showed the same degree of mercy as the cancer had.


When she had boxed Mum's possessions she had tarried over the diaries which her mother wrote with almost religious devotion. Would Mum's memory be best served if she destroyed or kept them? She couldn't imagine reading them - it would seem like an invasion of privacy. As she pondered their future she turned the half-completed one for 2014 over in her hands. The back cover flapped open and an autumn of receipts helicoptered their way down to the yellowing blue Lino. Amongst them was a sealed envelope. Mary stooped to pick it up, leaving the receipts where they lay and almost dropped it again when she saw what was written on the address side.

Mary​

And here she was. Her mother had left her one ticket to this performance. How she had heard of it, let alone procured a ticket so far in advance was a mystery, but she was here now. And ecstatically happy.

She looked past the empty seats to her right at an equally drab spectator; a man in a dark green tweed suit, also damp. His jowly face glowed a whitish blue as it stared down in deep concentration at his mobile phone screen. His eyebrows struggled to meet like weak magnets covered in iron filings, and what Mary took for rainwater covered his face in a sheen that combined with the jowls, giving the impression of a melting waxwork. He snapped round noticing her gaze and nodded self-consciously at his phone, making some meaningless gesture with it that made Mary want to snap yeah, it's a phone you moron.

She studied her doughy hands cradled in her lap and wondered when they had become so plump. She'd noticed her belly and breasts growing larger - and even the point when she had begun to have trouble getting her boots on past her ankles - but her hands had grown by stealth. This thought brought her attention to her backside which now felt particularly restricted by the theatre seat. Her hips strained at the trouser suit's tight polyester and fought to spill over the cushion and squeeze under the arm rest. God, you really are fat, now, not even plump!

She had comforted herself with apple pies and black pudding after Mum's death. Not together of course, but still, they made a strange combination that would have suggested pregnancy yens if that in itself were not a ridiculous suggestion; provided of course He had not decided, some two thousand years later, to create another immaculate conception.

She thought of the Biblical connotations of apples and blood.


As she sat on her sofa, wedged against the far right end with her laptop burning her thighs, she browsed for meaningful poems and passages that she could include in the service for Mum or read herself. A plate of fried slices of black pudding sat on the centre cushion of the sofa and when that was nothing but crumbs which looked like the small clumps of rotten black underlay that somehow migrated from under the carpet, she would often sigh, close the laptop and walk to the kitchen. After five minutes she would return with a glass of red wine in a huge chalice goblet Josephine had brought her from Glastonbury, and a plate from which a family sized apple pie metastasised. No cream. Just wine and pie. She grew heavy in the thighs and wide hips became broader, ankles disappearing, breasts swelling and migrating East and West as well as South. She didn't look like an egg, so much as a spinning top.


She was dizzy with excitement. Or from breathing too fast from the walk up to these upper circle seats. What had Josephine said when she'd shown her the ticket she'd found in Mum's diary? Some term for the seats, which she couldn't recall. Mary had been in the kitchen with Josephine toasting Mary's completion of the closure of the Estate. They had made it a little ritual with Josephine providing some almost transparent paper and a red pen;

'Use it to write a message, one that will allow your memories of your mother to transcend the grief you feel. Set her free, Mary and let the gods do the rest!' she had beamed, pushing the paper across the small kitchen workspace. That was it, the gods. Josephine had upset Mary when she'd looked at the ticket and snorted, 'Oh my, Mare, what a sense of humour your mum has, she got you tickets in the gods! At least you'll be near her when you watch him perform!'


Mary had screwed her face up at this, and Josephine had been careful to apologise for her callousness saying she was trying to keep things buoyant. Mary hadn't replied, but simply written the simple lines on the parchment, oddly inspired Josephine's words,


Mum, you were a goddess! Now there's just me, I hope I can become as you. Help me transcend the loss of the only thing I love. M.​
 
As an overweight lady who has lost her mother and done quite a bit of grieving, I feel particularly qualified to comment here. Frankly, to my eye, Mary doesn't sound as if she's grief-stricken, even if her mother's death is now several months in the past -- and grief has a habit of making one break down into tears months and months (even years) later. She doesn't read to me as being ecstatically happy at being there in the dance theatre, either (Covent Garden, I trust!), though you tell us she is. There's not nearly enough emotion here for either ... um... emotion. If she's excited as you say she is, she'd be on the edge of her seat, thinking about the performance to come, not reliving the past, and certainly not thinking about her fat hands. That's more likely to happen if she actually isn't that interested in dance or the dancer (would she really call him an artist, and not even artiste with an "e"?), and she's gone there out of a sense of obligation to her mother's memory. That would also tie in better with the ennui and dissatisfaction you talk about.

Anyway, not a hard read, and I didn't pick up any Beckett vibes (thankfully), but for my taste it was a tad overwritten in places -- your poetic style is wonderful when you're doing description, particularly of the natural world, but here it felt at odds with both the woman and the story. More importantly, for me there's too much backstory dumped here, and I'm not convinced all of it is necessary, certainly not so early on when the story perhaps needs to get going a bit more quickly. In particular I wasn't taken with so much emphasis on dealing with the estate. You don't say how wealthy they were, but if she's buying a £20 trouser suit, even if it is pure polyester (strange how they like to make fat-women-clothes in sweat-producing fabric...) even in a sale, she's clearly not got much money, so I just don't believe she'd be talking of "closure of the estate" in this way. (And it should take lower case "e" unless you're trying to make a point. Small "l" for "lino" too.). I'm happy to burble on at length on this if you want some technical detail, but basically, if it's only a bank account or two, it's just a question of taking the death cert in and signing some forms. If there's a house and they were simply cash poor, that's a whole different matter of course, but that doesn't square with the "what money she had" line. And would the mother really have made a will when she's got nothing much to leave and only one child? Most people don't.

I couldn't see the point of italicising the various paragraphs as you have, with the sole exception of the "God, you really are fat" and "yeah it's a phone" lines which are internal thoughts. Although those bits you've italicised are the past, there are other parts which are also recollection which remain unitalicised, so there's no apparent consistency. I'd suggest leaving it all plain, or if you want to separate out those paras for some reason, put them into present tense in italics, to give a kind of replaying-it-in-her-mind feel. By the way, using simple past tense for the "She thought of the Biblical connotations" and "As she sat on the sofa" lines I found momentarily confusing. I know you've dropped the past perfect (pluperfect) after the first sentence in the other flashbacks, but by having those lines as separate paras like this, even italicised, I thought we were back in the theatre again. Another reason to put the flashbacks into present tense, perhaps.

Is the phone man going to be important? If not, I don't think the paragraph on him earns its place here, and again it doesn't feel the reaction of an excited woman.

NB Some errors you'll pick up on editing, (eg did you mean "Mare" not "Mary"?) but the only biggie I can see on a quick read is it should be "leniency" not "levity" when it comes to forgiving bills.

Overall, an interesting beginning, but it's wallowing a bit too much at the moment, I think (kind of like Mary herself!) plus it needs some grounding in real emotion. But a good start. Well done.
 
I quite like the 'overwritten' style, as The Judge has called it, but I found the italics confusing and felt it wasn't necessary.
 
The Italics seem strange.
Other than that, I can't comment easily right now, having been to a funeral on Monday.
Perhaps all the stuff thinking about food is a substitute for writing about emotions? Not sure it works.
 
What a treat to log in to find three replies :) thanks everyone.

This is great feedback and really makes sense to me now I have an objective response from you. I can see how I've jumped and made assumptions in an attempt to cut the length. And I totally put my hand up to overwriting (but thanks, crystal haven for liking it ;) ). I find it hard to shake allegories and imagery once it's in my head, and often when I'm at Sadlers Wells (as opposed to Covent Garden, which is probably more appropriate in terms of dress code) I see the audience dressed up like birds. Time to fire up the Darling-Killing Machine.

The sublimation of food for grief was something I experienced when my brother was killed in Saudi, albeit I stopped eating completely. Also I found it strange that when I got the phone call from my dad telling me I felt a little distant, and felt guilty when I was still enjoying things when I thought I should be feeling grief. He and I were particularly close, but I don't think I can exchange brother for mother. I mnay actually just rewrite it without the loss and just have her as a desparing singleton (which shouldn't be too hard for me to do <sniff> :D )

The stuff about the estate now makes sense - we had to jump through hoops to get his body back from Saudi and then deal with his flat and debts and I can easily tweak this to your measurements, TJ (I swore I lower-cased that E!!!! although Mare was intentional, maybe I should change to Mar' ? Leniency - check. Ta (Lino is apparently a brand but lower case looks better to me, too ) .

Regarding the italics. They can go when not internal thoughts. I just assumed I needed them to differentiate between times but if they cause confusion I can junk them.

The phone man is important - in the circle with her are some other 'downtrodden' people but if he seems randomly inserted I can split his appearances in the text and be a bit more canny with foreshadowing.

How about I change "She thought of the Biblical connotations" to "She'd thought ..." instead?

And ohhhh, poor Samuel Beckett*! I love him! :D

pH
*Not the Quantum Leap variety
 
Oh, I've got to say it, as I would hate to see it all go: I really got the bird imagery and got pulled in by it.
 
Just to say I enjoyed the bird imagery of the first paragraphs, too, and it sucked me in, but having read further, I wasn't sure it fitted with this woman's character and situation as you've stated it -- ennui usually results in everything being a bit grey and flat (and stale and unprofitable, to coin a phrase :whistle:). If she is a dreamer, given to wonderful and imaginative description despite the drabness of her life, perhaps bring this out a bit more -- perhaps her mother has sniffed at her dreaminess in the past, perhaps Josephine has laughed at some of her imaginative flights of fancy.

Definitely the linking of food and grief is a good idea and very common in real life, so no argument from me on that -- and grief is grief, both the same and very different for everyone, so absolutely you can use your own reactions to your own loss. I also agree with how she has let herself go and got fat because she's unhappy/stressed/tired/overworked (tell me about it...). That's all fine, so no need to do away with the idea and the paragraphs dealing with it.

I've also no problem with her experiencing great excitement at being at the dance especially if she is feeling guilty because (she thinks) she ought to be grieving. That's also very natural. My problem was although you tell us she's excited, you're not showing it, and I'm not feeling it, but I'm not getting the grieving, either -- the grieving when she was eating, in the past, yes, just here at the theatre it's not there, but neither is anything else.

Don't turn her into a sad and lonely spinster, even if she is! I like the idea of the mother having magically got this ticket for her as a present, but if she's excited, make her excited and show her feet tapping on the floor, her eyes taking in all the beauty of the room, the painted putti on the ceiling, the stucco'd flowers and fruits hanging in great swags, the elaborate red curtain with the gold arabesques. Having said that, I like the idea of Mary going along to the performance even though she's not that interested in dance, just because she's got nothing better to do in her life -- if you bring out her depression, her disgust at her obesity, her humiliation at her clothes and dowdiness, then the beauty of the dance hitting her, enlivening her, and then the birth and the glory of her "children" dancing away from her will be all the more wonderful!

Get inside her head a bit more, I think, and it will come together better.
 
Actually I really felt her depression as I was reading it. She seemed numb to me. But then you made her excited and that didn't gel with her reactions to me.
 
I liked this and was able to follow the switches back and forth quite easily though I felt the italics helped a lot.
The first paragraph is quite descriptive though I felt it could be tightened.

I also felt the second mention of penguins and hummingbirds might be a bit insulting to readers as it's not difficult to figure out which attire belongs to which and I'd leave off the leading bits of over explaining the penguins in and hummingbirds in. But that's just me.
 
Okay, I take on all these points and will make her more feel-y.

The reason I thought about axing the grief (so to speak) is it muddies the waters and what I'm after is an ennui of life - well, more that she does not have the children she always wished she had. That will allow me to cut a lot of the grieving stuff which seems to be a sticking point (and to do it justice would probably inflate the word count and I'm determined to write something under 5k!). It also means the little ritual she does after this excerpt, with Josephine (who's a pagan) will be easier. But I agree @The Judge, I really don't see her as a lonely or dowdy spinster - just someone who thinks they should have achieved more in life than they have.

@tinkerdan - point taken, I will remove the second reference to the species and just use the descriptions. I think based on the other feedback, though, I will cut the italics out :/

In an attempt to whittle the word count down, I cut a load of waffle about what a theatre fanatic she was and the dance artist she loves was a sort of combination of Akram Khan and Carlos Acosta. I realise now that cutting it means her excitement comes out of nowhere. I may reintroduce it with an economical sentence towards the start and then show her excitement as you've advised.

Actually, I'm more concerned about what happens to these etheric dancers she gives birth to as I only know what happens up till there - I will no doubt come up with something exceptional and clever and Puliztery :D:rolleyes:

pH
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top