Laura and the Manxome Foe

Status
Not open for further replies.

Zoe Mackay

Not all those who wander... Oh, actually, I am.
Supporter
Joined
Aug 19, 2014
Messages
491
Location
London
So, this was the story I wrote for the Psecret Psummer... wotzit thingy, and I thought I'd post up the opening section. (It's about a quarter of the whole thing, which is a short story @3600 words). I don't write many fight scenes, so I'm particularly interested on whether that works.

Thanks in advance for any comments!

--

I killed my first monster when I was nine years old.

Back then, the summers were endless, full of adventure and stories. After school finished, my brother Carl and I were shipped off to stay with Aunt Jane and Uncle Scott in Hampshire, right in the middle of the New Forest. We would leave the house just after breakfast, scrambled eggs and toast every day, and play in the woods behind Jane and Scott's cottage, coming back only for lunch and tea, then heading straight back out again.

We weren't supposed to go too far from the house. “Not until you're older,” Aunt Jane would say, though I was already convinced that I was as mature as I was ever going to be. There were no problems I could not solve, no injuries I could not cure – usually by the swift application of a dock leaf and some brackish stream-water of questionable sanitation.

That day, Carl and I had ventured further than we ever had before. Down past Mr George's cottage, past the back of the local shop, even past the imposingly high wall that surrounded the house of Mrs. Smith.

Village gossip held that Mrs. Smith was “a bit of a character”. She “kept herself to herself”.

All of the children were convinced that she was a witch.

When Stephen, son of the Housemans – who ran the local shop – had measles and had to stay in bed for a whole month with the curtains drawn, we knew that Mrs. Smith had cursed him. After all, hadn't we been throwing rotten crab-apples at her wall that very week? Or at least the one before, and that was pretty much equivalent. Everyone knew that it took a while to work magic.

We kept as far away from Mrs. Smith’s wall as we could, given that there were stinging nettles on the other side of the path, and it was because of that Carl spotted the track that went directly into the forest. It wasn’t a path, really, just a trodden crease that cut through the nettles.

“It’s a fairy road,” I told Carl. “We should follow it.” And so, intrepid explorers, we plunged into the forest. Now, of course, I know that area of the forest is visited often, and the only thing you could discover is an abandoned campfire or a beer can, but then it was an adventure. Carl held my hand tightly as we looked around at the grotesquely gnarled tree boughs, half-excited, half-scared, jumping every time the wind blew the branches.

We can’t have gone far before I knew it was there. I couldn’t tell you whether it was sound, scent, or sight, or maybe some other unnamed sense, that alerted me, but something did. I froze, genuinely scared.

“What is it, Lor?” Carl said, sensing my fear and reverting back to the name he’d called me before he’d turned five and decided I deserved my full “Laura”.

“I don’t know.” I looked around at threatening trees that had, moments before, looked merely strange. And there, in the dark shade between a particularly thick trunk and a snarl of brambles, I saw my first monster.

They’re hard to describe. I think that’s what Lewis Carroll was struggling with in Jabberwocky, and he was certainly working from second-hand information. But still, the jaws that bite and the claws that catch. There are worse descriptions. To this day I couldn’t draw one, and any words that I have are poor imitations of reality. They are a smeared palette of emotion, red and purple and black, bad colours painted by a cruel artist.

“Run,” I told Carl, shaking my hand out of his. “Run home. Go. Go.” I wasn’t thinking, wasn’t planning. I just wanted Carl away from it. He stood still for a second, always contrary, preparing to refuse, but something in my voice must have scared him enough. Out of the corner of my eye, I saw him run, back down our once-intriguing fairy road.

I didn’t want to look away from the monster, expecting it to attack at any time, but I knew I needed something to defend myself, to at least slow it down to let Carl get away. I grabbed a fallen branch, one that looked long and sturdy enough to be some use. A small girl and a stick, more than a match for a monster.

It emerged slowly from its hiding place, bringing the darkness with it. I raised my stick and charged towards it, slamming the branch down onto it. As I did so, the stick lit up and, as if resonating to a hidden note, sang in my hand. Over and over again I hit it, feeling as if I was watching myself do it from a remote, detached place. The monster screamed, the sound like the blast of a hurricane on my face. Still I kept hitting it. My body was not under my control; instead, I observed with a clinical eye the glowing stick, the angles of impact, the reaction of the creature.

Then, without warning, the light went out of the branch, and it was just a branch again. I snapped back from my safe mental vantage point, and felt the burn of acid fear in my throat. I turned and ran, not looking where I was going, my arms waving in front of me. Afterwards, I worked out from the scratches and stings that I must have run straight through a nettle patch and a gorse bush, but at the time I was simply running in an uncontrolled flight that ended when I tripped over a wrought iron garden bench. I lay on the ground, clutching my shin and wailing like a little kid.
 
First of all, I think this piece was very good! The story flows,it's easy to read, I enjoyed it , and it made me want to read more. The only thing that was noticeably missing from the fight scene was the monster's reaction. I would expect it to fight, to try and grab the stick, to try and avoid being hit, etc. Now it reads like it just stands there (screaming) and lets the girl beat it up. Maybe it's some kind of a masochistic monster?.. :) But overall, nicely done!
 
Strong opening line - good. And a lovely attention to detail in the narrative.

You make a point, you stick to it, we share Laura's adventure and her fears - we truly journey with her.

There were a couple of sentences I might have personally done differently - but those are minor creative nit picks. I can't think of any real technical criticisms at all. A job well done. :)
 
I really enjoyed this. I think it's written well. It's accessible, with a good pace and intrigue. I would definitely be interested in reading the rest - and I can be a fussy one with what does and doesn't hook me. And yes, the opening line is excellent.

I'm pretty much on the same page as the others who have commented: The monster possibly needing/having a reaction during the fight. And perhaps expanding a bit on the fear she feels when she sees the monster (more specifically I would consider expanding on "I froze, genuinely scared"... Not by much, just maybe adding another sentence of description so there's more than the fear just being given as fact.

All in all though, there's not much to say... I don't often venture away from the writing challenges, and I was sort of hoping I'd have a little more suggestion to give on the first critiquable piece I chose to read - alas! (y)
 
The fight needs a little more to heighten the feel of danger, or even reactions from the monster. You build up to this point, so you should enjoy the moment a little more. A very distinct voice and style and one that worked for me. I wanted more, what more could you want?
 
Contrary to the others I think the fight scene is just right, if she is using magic. Of course maybe it's just a poor woodland creature being bludgeoned to death by frightened girl. I'd have an open mind on it till I saw how the story develops. But as it is, it has the ambiguity a short story often needs. It does work as a complete short I think.

The monster possibly needing/having a reaction during the fight.
I think that would spoil the POV, which is the frightened little girl.

The fight needs a little more to heighten the feel of danger, or even reactions from the monster. You build up to this point, so you should enjoy the moment a little more.
I think that would impair the POV and over egg it.
 
Hi - thanks for the nice comments and the useful feedback. I think that I can get a little more detail into that one section, and it will just feel a fraction more climactic and cathartic, and that's kind of what I'm after, without running into point of view issues or getting unnecessarily mechanical.

There are, I think, more things I need to work on in the second part of the story (where we meet Mrs. Smith, find out more about the monsters' nature, and someone close to our hero is threatened)
 
Nice work.

Just being picky... Paragraph 15, second sentence is, "I grabbed a fallen branch, one that looked long and sturdy enough to be some use."

Would that be better if you add the word 'of' in it as follows: "I grabbed a fallen branch, one that looked long and sturdy enough to be of some use."
 
Hi! I enjoyed this, really good - I liked the scene setting (particularly how it's quite evocative of classic English children's writing on one hand, but with a modern, slightly more cynical tone in the narrator's voice).

On the story itself: I'd think about building up a bit more to the encounter with the monster. I didn't really feel scared, as it just came out of nowhere - maybe you could work on their journey into the woods, a few more bumps in the night? I also wasn't convinced at the 9-year old girl immediately attacking the monster - fair enough if she does, but I think we need an explanation for why she acts that way.

Obviously it's an opening, but I think the scene needs filling out to make the reader feel it a bit more

Hope that's useful, keep up the good work!
 
They are a smeared palette of emotion, red and purple and black, bad colours painted by a cruel artist.
This is glorious...
It emerged slowly from its hiding place, bringing the darkness with it.
as is this.

I would have worded a few sentences differently, but I'm not sure whether I'm picking up on grammar, or dialect or protagonist voice.
 
I enjoyed this.

If you wanted to get more mileage out of that first line.

I was nine years old when I had my first (killed). Oh just realized that's the problem-should be kill. Sorry for any confusion.
[Had my first killed sounds rather grammatically incorrect to me.]
Good catch on that @Loren
Having a child at age 9 would be bad enough without the other.

Rather than giving away the fact it was monster.
 
Last edited:
I enjoyed this.

If you wanted to get more mileage out of that first line.

I was nine years old when I had my first killed.

Rather than giving away the fact it was monster.

I am not sure where you are from, but in the USA when you say, "I had my first killed," that implies that you killed your child, as in first born.

That's much different than saying, "I had my first kill."
 
I'm in the US and I've never heard that. Must be regional.

I am not sure where you are from, but in the USA when you say, "I had my first killed," that implies that you killed your child, as in first born.

That's much different than saying, "I had my first kill."

But there are a lot of things I've never heard-led a really sheltered life.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Kill

Oh and I've only lived in the US for 64 of my 64 years so there is that too. Maybe I just missed out.

First kill around here is the first time you bag a deer during deer hunting.

See above correction to clarify I meant kill not killed. mea culpa.

@Loren --obviously it took me a while to figure out where that was coming from.
But having my first killed is rather ambiguous. The first question would be first what? or in Star Trek that would be Riker.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top