ralphkern
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Aug 19, 2013
- Messages
- 1,156
Following from Brian's thread about SP work, I thought I'd post some reviews of novels that I have personally found to be excellent. All are, of course, welcome to add any they spot.
My intention is not to foster a debate between the relative merits of SP vs TP, but simply highlight some excellent works which might be overlooked due to their SP status.
My own personal criteria for adding to this thread is it must be an SP work, be of a high standard and not from a Chronner.
First up for me is Xenophobia, a novel by my current favorite author, Peter Cawdron.
As mentioned, Cawdron is my current favorite author and I have found all of his books to be of the highest quality. I have not read anyone who has quite his same skill in painting picture with words. There are no grammatical errors or typos in them I have seen (the most oft quoted reason for not considering SP).
I have decided to include only one of his works, although all that I have read so far are fantastic and often exhibit different skills. My Sweet Satan is a deliciously spooky version of 2001 that actually gave me the chills. Anomaly is an excellent science based story about first contact with aliens and Galactic Explorations is a highly imaginative far future set of 4 linked novellas covering, well, Galactic Exploration. All of his books would fall under Hard Science Fiction as their primary category in that they are impeccably researched and realistic.
Xenophobia is in my opinion Cawdron's most rounded work where he showcases all of his considerable talents in one book.
The POV character, Elizabeth Bower is a Doctor for Medicine Sans Frontiers in a war torn nation when the US army unit assigned to protect her hospital is suddenly given orders to pull out. Unfortunately, the hospital is besieged by rebel forces and it is clear that their withdrawal will lead to the massacre of the patients and staff. A small team decide to stay behind and escort who they can to friendly lines.
Through their unreliable communications, they realize that the reason for the withdrawal order is because a huge alien vessel is closing on Earth with unknown intentions.
Fending off skirmishes from the rebel forces they begin the long trek to safety while trying to learn what is going on in the wider world.
The novel combines two threads. A deeply human one which is somewhat relevant in our current political situation. Refugees fleeing from war, death, torture and rape and a much larger scale one, that of first contact with an alien race. And by alien, I mean truly alien. The aliens are plausible, but incredibly different from anything I have read before. The characters are often faced with interesting ethical dilemmas in relation to both aspects.
The final quarter of the book... well I'm going to resist the urge to give any spoilers but it is awesome. The conclusion is fascinating and satisfying. Clearly the book is designed as stand-alone, but it both answers the main questions a reader will have about the aliens and their motivations while still leaving enough to have you hungering for more. In my opinion, this isn't leaving things open for a sequel, simply that all good SF makes one ask questions and wonder. This is in a similar vein to Clarke and Reynolds.
While this isn't an action orientated book (contrary to what it may seem in the title) - the set pieces are tense and thrilling. One part particularly stands out when some characters are used as sport by a sadistic warlord. The military aspects are realistic, compelling and convincing. While I'm no medic, many of the scenes with Bower acting in her capacity as a doctor have an air of authenticity to them.
The technical side. This is an ultra close 3rd person, which I must admit is usually not my fave POV as I generally find it too claustrophobic. However this is written so well it overcomes my natural inclination for a bit of a wider perspective. It helps that Bower is such an appealing character - that trace of arrogance which a person in her position would need to excel at her job yet moments showing her caring side. As mentioned, there are no SPAG errors and it shows itself as being tightly edited.
If someone has an interest in 'realistic' first contact novels, medical stories, war stories (as opposed to action stories), I can't recommend this highly enough.
My intention is not to foster a debate between the relative merits of SP vs TP, but simply highlight some excellent works which might be overlooked due to their SP status.
My own personal criteria for adding to this thread is it must be an SP work, be of a high standard and not from a Chronner.
First up for me is Xenophobia, a novel by my current favorite author, Peter Cawdron.
As mentioned, Cawdron is my current favorite author and I have found all of his books to be of the highest quality. I have not read anyone who has quite his same skill in painting picture with words. There are no grammatical errors or typos in them I have seen (the most oft quoted reason for not considering SP).
I have decided to include only one of his works, although all that I have read so far are fantastic and often exhibit different skills. My Sweet Satan is a deliciously spooky version of 2001 that actually gave me the chills. Anomaly is an excellent science based story about first contact with aliens and Galactic Explorations is a highly imaginative far future set of 4 linked novellas covering, well, Galactic Exploration. All of his books would fall under Hard Science Fiction as their primary category in that they are impeccably researched and realistic.
Xenophobia is in my opinion Cawdron's most rounded work where he showcases all of his considerable talents in one book.
The POV character, Elizabeth Bower is a Doctor for Medicine Sans Frontiers in a war torn nation when the US army unit assigned to protect her hospital is suddenly given orders to pull out. Unfortunately, the hospital is besieged by rebel forces and it is clear that their withdrawal will lead to the massacre of the patients and staff. A small team decide to stay behind and escort who they can to friendly lines.
Through their unreliable communications, they realize that the reason for the withdrawal order is because a huge alien vessel is closing on Earth with unknown intentions.
Fending off skirmishes from the rebel forces they begin the long trek to safety while trying to learn what is going on in the wider world.
The novel combines two threads. A deeply human one which is somewhat relevant in our current political situation. Refugees fleeing from war, death, torture and rape and a much larger scale one, that of first contact with an alien race. And by alien, I mean truly alien. The aliens are plausible, but incredibly different from anything I have read before. The characters are often faced with interesting ethical dilemmas in relation to both aspects.
The final quarter of the book... well I'm going to resist the urge to give any spoilers but it is awesome. The conclusion is fascinating and satisfying. Clearly the book is designed as stand-alone, but it both answers the main questions a reader will have about the aliens and their motivations while still leaving enough to have you hungering for more. In my opinion, this isn't leaving things open for a sequel, simply that all good SF makes one ask questions and wonder. This is in a similar vein to Clarke and Reynolds.
While this isn't an action orientated book (contrary to what it may seem in the title) - the set pieces are tense and thrilling. One part particularly stands out when some characters are used as sport by a sadistic warlord. The military aspects are realistic, compelling and convincing. While I'm no medic, many of the scenes with Bower acting in her capacity as a doctor have an air of authenticity to them.
The technical side. This is an ultra close 3rd person, which I must admit is usually not my fave POV as I generally find it too claustrophobic. However this is written so well it overcomes my natural inclination for a bit of a wider perspective. It helps that Bower is such an appealing character - that trace of arrogance which a person in her position would need to excel at her job yet moments showing her caring side. As mentioned, there are no SPAG errors and it shows itself as being tightly edited.
If someone has an interest in 'realistic' first contact novels, medical stories, war stories (as opposed to action stories), I can't recommend this highly enough.