Modern Plagiarism

Ray McCarthy

Sentient Marmite: The Truth may make you fret.
Joined
Jul 16, 2014
Messages
8,090
Location
The Mid West (of Ireland)
Not long ago there was the Hetro Romance that was ripped off and published as gay romance, a clever ploy to avoid being noticed.

But how did this Author hope to remain undetected?

The girl who stole my book: How Eilis O'Hanlon found out her crime novels were swiped by a stranger - Independent.ie

Insincere, the second in her series about Elizabeth Ireland, was scheduled for publication near the end of October, only a few weeks away. Looking up a summary of the plot, it was clear that this, too, had been lifted from our second novel, The Dark Eye.

Tear Drop, it seemed, was not a one-off.

Was Joanne Clancy planning to plagiarise our entire series? More immediately, was she really going to risk continuing this deception after being rumbled online?

There was one burning question: Who was Joanne Clancy? All we knew about her is that she claimed to be from Cork, and had published 26 works in various genres from erotica to romance to crime, many featuring a recurring character who went by the name of Detective George Ellis.
 
What was the outcome? Was the original author able to do anything to prevent publication?
 
What was the outcome? Was the original author able to do anything to prevent publication?
Amazon removed the plagiarist and banned them for life (although how this works for what is probably someone using a pseudonym is unclear), and while the plagiarist received some money, that already transferred to them, they received nothing** from the point where the plagiarism was confirmed.


** - If they paid the money to the original authors (the original books were written under a pseudonym by two people), I didn't notice this. I didn't see any mention of it being given to charity, so Amazon seems to be the winner here. (Note that I may have missed the relevant text explaining what did happen.)
 
The fact that the second book was called "Insincere" is pretty amazing too. Actually, I'm surprised that anyone would bother: the effort of changing the original book would surely be so great that you might as well write a completely new one.

I'm also interested to see that there is such a thing as Ireland-specific clickbait articles. I had foolishly assumed that every country got the same ones!
 
Ireland-specific clickbait articles
It's a paper Irish Newspaper. Not the Online only UK Independent
I may have missed the relevant text explaining what did happen
The real authors don't know what happened in the end. The Plagiarist vanished, "She" wouldn't reply to more emails etc. It's not clear if the rest of the vast output (with no gaps) was plagiarised, but either way the bogus author may have netted maybe £100K.

The publicity wont do the newly released eBooks any harm :)
 
An alleged Interview with "Joanne Clancy"
Author Interview | Joanne Clancy
Thanks for the link. :)

I'm not convinced by the authenticity of the author image included with that interview...

...or by the answer to the question, "Are you a plotter or pantster?":
I used to be a pantster, but I’m a definite plotter now. I write an outline of the story and then I plot it chapter by chapter, but I do leave some room for manoeuvre.
 
I'm not convinced by the authenticity of the author image included with that interview...
Nor am I.
Zero hits on Google reverse image search
I'm not sure it's even a woman ... I emailed the newspaper with my research findings, which are 100% definite, but could be based on fictitious submissions.
 
I suspect this is just the reality in a digital world where anything can be copied.
 
I suspect this is just the reality in a digital world where anything can be copied.
Although, in the case above, it appears that the originals were never available as ebooks, so the plagiarist either typed in her versions using the orginals as a (sentence-by-sentence) guide or (less likely) scanned in the contents of the original books.

From the article linked to in the first post:
A year later, we published a sequel - The Dark Eye, again featuring Saxon and her female lover, Detective Chief Inspector Grace Fitzgerald, this time teaming up to investigate an apparently politically motivated killer, known as The Marxman. After a change of agent and publisher, two more novels in the series followed - The Judas Heart (2007) and Circle Of The Dead (2008), both published by Penguin Books.

By this time, however, the editor at Penguin who had championed the books had left for Australia, and, sadly, our new agent died. Feeling like we were back at square one, and not knowing how to start over, Ingrid Black slipped off the radar. In time, the books fell out of print and copyright reverted to us as the original authors.

At various points over the next few years, we toyed with the idea of releasing the Saxon stories as e-books. It seemed silly not to. They represented many years of work. Why not give them a new lease of life?

We set up a Twitter account in the name of Ingrid Black to prepare for publication. Our first tweet: "Now all I have to do is figure out how you put a book on Kindle, and I'll be a millionaire by Christmas. That's how it works, right?" Though, of course, it wasn't done by that Christmas. Or the next one. Procrastination was our middle name.
 
reality in a digital world where anything can be copied
Professional Book piracy or Google:
  1. Cut off binding with industrial book trimmer
  2. Industrial autosheet feeder on industrial scanner
  3. Professional OCR
  4. Cheap proof readers, maybe India.
Professional Video/Cinema Piracy:
Bribe someone in studio
OR
Bribe Projectionist
OR
Point semi-pro HD camera on tripod at decent 42" TV in a dark room. Nearly perfect HD copy.
(there is even SW to remove Broadcast logos and/or watermarks!)​

Pirate Streaming:
There are legal, free, third party "virtual" sound cards and video adaptors used for legitimate purposes. If installed, you select them as default display and sound card and then record.
OR
Use analogue audio line out for audio and if video, point HD camera at monitor.​

No digital originals needed.

Analogue sources and on Digital, DRM and antipiracy schemes are NO inconvenience AT ALL to commercial pirates. They only inconvenience regular consumers, and in case of DRM or other Anti-Piracy (or US laws) contravene the Berne convention on Copyright and remove consumers traditional "fair use".
 

Similar threads


Back
Top