Military Son (1400 words)

Status
Not open for further replies.

The Big Peat

Darth Buddha
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
3,760
Hello all.

This is an idea that I may or may not pursue. The main reason I'm posting this up here is to see if it grabs people, if it resonates. I'm not looking for big detailed critiques here: this is draft zero, its rough, I may not even pursue it. It would be wasteful for people to give plenty of their time to it in such circumstances. I'd feel guilty.

The questions I would be asking is

- Does this grab people?
- How high up on the cliche-o-meter does it ping?
- Is the balance of action to thought good?
- If there is any awful passive tense that grabs people's eyes going through, then please bring it to my attention.

The first question is the big one though but all feedback is welcome


“By the gods’ giving hands, I do declare you are the most horrendous honour guard I’ve ever seen!”

From his position at the left of the Imperial cadets’ formation, Magar had no idea how accurate the statement was. For all he knew, the parade was perfectly aligned, but it didn’t matter. The Drill Sergeants would still keep them out here all day in search of whatever lay beyond perfection. Personally he suspected the only thing waiting there was blisters and a bad back; only one of the legendary nine heroes of the Empire would have dared voice that thought.

“Eyes Right! Betrayer’s balls, you can do better than that, I didn’t hear anything rattling! Cadet Magar! Stop daydreaming or you’ll start screaming! You’re not the Emperor’s son here! You’re not even useful!”

He let the words wash over him and stood as straight as possible. This was his fifth and final year as a cadet; if he hadn’t heard it all before, that was only because the Drill Sergeants were very inventive. It would be someone else’s turn soon enough.

“Eyes…. Right! Right, Cadet Isak, right! If you give me a heart attack, you will hang for murder!”

Isak spluttered an apology and Magar suppressed a sigh. The poor lad had been so excited when he’d heard that they would be the honour guard for the reception of the ambassadors from the elven Kindred of the Pines. He was learning different now. You never wanted anything big to happen to you in the cadets, because it always meant pain.

“Breath and bones, it will not hurt you to stand still Cadet Harato! If you can’t stand still, a turn around the yard will cure you. Go! Now! Faster!” The Drill Sergeant watched him go then whipped around. “Anyone else feeling restless?”

A clearer invitation to silence had never been heard. The only sound was Harato’s feet slapping against the drill yard’s stone. Magar barely dared breathe. The stress of the situation was getting to the Sergeant and someone else would suffer for it.

“Very well then. Eyes… R-”

Someone broke wind, a loud and prolonged trumpet blast. The Drill Sergeant turned the same colour as a raddish.

“Everyone ten turns around the yard! Like a greased weasel!”

The drill yard of the Imperial Military Academy was a big area; ten turns was about three miles. There was no point sprinting that. He settled into the middle of the horde as it thundered around, hoping to stay out of sight. Normally he quite enjoyed running. Normally he didn’t do it after a day of parade. His muscles were already stiff and complaining and he’d barely even started. Ten turns. They’d barely have time to do anything before dinner - which probably meant they weren’t having any.

“Cadet Magar! Cadet Magar!”

He looked left to see the Drill Sergeant bellowing his name. Besides him was the Commandant. He ran to them, putting on a little burst of speed and half-expecting to be told go away again the moment he got there. The Drill Sergeant had form for that. He halted before them and saluted, finger tips brushing slick skin.

“At ease, Cadet Magar.” The Commandant had the air of a man with a speech prepared, but all he said was, “The Throne wishes to see you. Dismiss him, Sergeant Orday.”

“Sir! Cadet Magar, wait for it…” The Drill Sergeant draw out the pause until the Commandant had gone out of earshot. “You run as fast as you can in future Cadet, or you’ll run as far as you can. Understood?” It was delivered in a murmur inches away from his face. Then he suddenly shouted “Cadet Magar, dismissed! Report to the Throne immediately! Do not forget to wash, you smell like my wife’s cooking.”

So much for running the middle then. Magar sprinted off the square. If there was one person in the whole Empire Magar believed less in annoying than Drill Sergeant Orday, it was his father. The Emperor.


His hair was still wet when he was ushered into the Emperor’s presence. The air was fragrant with cedar oil and jasmine, the light softly glowing from the many lanterns hung up on the rafters. It was a small room and plainly furnished; his father liked to get away from the pomp of court when he could. He’d put aside his robes for a plain linen suit with minimal embroidery. Yet he was still wearing the crown and three chains of the Triple-Emperor of Avila; Magar has never seen him without them.

He was a small neat man whose prominent nose and beady eyes always put Magar in mind of a bird. If he’d not been the Emperor, people would think him a clerk. Magar sometimes wondered what he himself would be if his father was not the Emperor. Not now, not when his father’s eyes were diamond hard and his face pinched together. He knelt, head bowed in obeisance.

“Rise. Sit.”

Magar did so. Sometimes it was funny how the Emperor used much the same voice with his sons as his dogs. Sometimes.

“I trust the parade tomorrow will be exemplary.”

“It will, Greatness, as long as the chefs do not serve beans for breakfast. Or anything of that nature.” The Emperor’s expression went blank so he quickly explained. “When your message reached me, Drill Sergeant Orday had us doing turns of the yard after an incident of flatulence.”

“Ah.” The thin fingers picked up a pen and wrote a small note. There would be no beans for breakfast tomorrow.

He stayed silent, thankful that the Emperor did not think he was being insufficiently serious. This was no time to be a small boy making fun of his father. Something else was written and he cautiously craned his neck to try and see. He couldn’t and quickly sat back when the Emperor looked up.

“When the delegation from the Kindred of the Pines arrives, guides will be assigned to everyone of importance. You, Cadet Magar, will be one of them. You will have two duties. To your assigned guest, you must be the perfect host. You must be open, charming, and able to answer everything relating to their comfort. If your memory of the Palace’s lay-out is dim, refresh it this evening.”

“Every sunfall, once they are gone to the bed, you will go to the Second Under-Steward. You will report every movement, every nuance of conversation. Do not deliberately seek information for this purpose but instead share the fruits that fall into your lap as their guide and friend.”

“Yes Greatness.” So the Emperor’s anger was not directed at him. He breathed a little easier. “Greatness, I know little about the delegation. I-”

“You know enough.” The Emperor put up a hand, emphasising the command for silence. “Your guest will be the Lord Feofin. Treat him with the respect you would treat me.” He stared at his notes. “Beans. Yes.”

The diamond-hard beady eyes focused on him. “Tell me, Cadet Magar, why you think you have been chosen for this role.”

He had been considering that. It was not an usual task for a cadet, but not wholly unusual either. The Imperial Cadets were trained for every conceivable eventuality that might occur in their duties, including diplomacy and espionage. He was an obvious choice for the role too. As a Prince of the Empire, his presence would be a compliment; his youth might help disarm them. And given that he would graduate at the next snow-solstice, it was time he started acting more as a prince. A shame he had not been given longer to prepare though - which in itself pointed to a different answer.

“Greatness, I believe the answer is that the original choice has fallen ill.”

There was a bark of laughter, quickly stifled.

“That is correct. Commendably clear sighted there, Cadet. Retain that clarity.” There was a wistful note in the Emperor’s voice. “That is all. Report to your superiors your change in status.”

“Aye Greatness. Thank you for the opportunity to serve.”

An interesting choice of words there. He slid out of his chair to kneel again, then got up and backed out of the room.

“Oh, and Cadet Magar?”

He turned at the door. “Greatness?”

“Regrettably, it would be unseemly if the Emperor’s son was seen to be spared group punishments.”

He had known that would be coming and therefore didn’t sigh at all.

“I understand, Greatness.”
 
The real question to ask is: Do you like it?
It's overwritten, but that's normal for a first draft.
It could be engaging when you trim it down. As it is I think you're trying to put to much detail into a pretty small section. Perhaps after your tenth rewrite you'll take care of that.
You're trying to make the point that recruit training is hard but you don't need so much of it. It looks like you have two stories here. First training. Second, off to see papa. You need to decide which is the most important and lock onto that. Oh, I like the fart sentence so don't cut that.
So, it has potential but needs work. Presumably it's heading somewhere.
 
I agree with Droflet - you do kind of have two openings here. Both will likely be familiar situations to readers, and either could stand or fall on their own merits.

The first has the benefit of putting the protagonist in a downtrodden situation that will allow a little sympathy, therefore empathy, from the reader.

The second comes across more as an infodump - it shouldn't require the Emperor to tell a cadet about a basic mission of diplomacy, and if the father and son should meet, it's because there must be something to pass between them that cannot be done through an intermediary. If you follow this part of the opening, then rather than show, as you've done, you could simply open with Magar in the middle of his diplomatic mission (setting), worried about messing up (stakes), when something almost immediately happens (or not, as the case may be).

Ultimately, you need to keep focused on why the reader should care about Magar, and it may take a few drafts to properly develop the character's development arc before you can answer that properly.

Overall, though, not bad at all, and impressive for a first draft. My only other suggestion would be to focus on what's going to be remarkable about both your story, and character.
 
I am asking myself that question Droflet, believe me. But its good to get outside eyes on it, both in terms of the story and in terms of my writing in general.

You're absolutely right that I'm trying to pack too much in now that you say it.
 
Ok, to answer your first question, yes, it grabbed my interest, but more so when Magar had to go see his father. I had to read the first sentence three times to understand that it was really a drill sergeant really screaming loud, as they do. "By the Gods giving hands" sounded too polite as the first few words there, "You bunch of ignoramuses" might have been more effective. Very soon it would need something more to hold the interest.
 
Hi Pete,

Good first draft and yes, I read it easily and it kept my attention - especially difficult bearing in mind the genre and my prejudices. What I liked was the sarcasm and cynical world-weariness of Magar. I think some of the drill sergeant's curses were a bit of a miss and maybe if he didn't finish every sentence with a threat or insult, it would read a little easier. I'd personally change the 'if you give me a heart attack' and 'wife's cooking' bits.

As far as clichés; I suppose you could say that, but I'd use the word tropes. You've done it interestingly enough and there is a slight perversion of the trope because it's not just angry, shouty, sarcastic drill sergeant, but there's some self-deprecation and cynicism which I love.

Oh, while I remember: is this set in alternate Spain (re: Avila and Magar)?

There are other things I'd say about efficiency, but as you said it's draft zero and it's clear you're in control of your writing so I'll wait for draft 2 ;)

Nice.

pH
 
The names are just coincidence at this stage.

And I agree with what people are saying about the Drill Sergeant - I think part of the reason I swept on so fast to the Emperor is that as written, its quite limited and incapable of taking up more space. Breaking up and beefing up the cursing would strengthen things.

Phyrebrat - I'm curious on the efficiency thing. Too much wordiness?

Also, every time I try to write something without cynicism and self-deprecation, it tends to fail miserably :D
 
The names are just coincidence at this stage.

And I agree with what people are saying about the Drill Sergeant - I think part of the reason I swept on so fast to the Emperor is that as written, its quite limited and incapable of taking up more space. Breaking up and beefing up the cursing would strengthen things.

Phyrebrat - I'm curious on the efficiency thing. Too much wordiness?

Also, every time I try to write something without cynicism and self-deprecation, it tends to fail miserably :D

Well, from meeting you, I like that your in-person voice is so similar to your writing one. You've made humourous comments at the meets and this reminds me of that.

Re the efficiency, well... baaaah, I don't like to reword people's work, as it's their voice, not mine, but here's an example:

You have:

“Sir! Cadet Magar, wait for it…” The Drill Sergeant draw out the pause until the Commandant had gone out of earshot. It was delivered in a murmur inches away from his face,"shouty bit"

I'd tweak something like:

“Sir! Cadet Magar, wait for it…” The Drill Sergeant paused until the Commandant was out of earshot, leaned in, then murmured inches from Magar's face, "shouty bit"

(I'd also remove the 'suddenly' in the next line, but that's all)

pH
 
I think the drill-sergeant bit could be tightened to make it a bit more original, but I still enjoyed it. In fact I liked the whole thing. Maybe I'm easy to please (though I've always considered myself hard to please). I think it's the cynical but not too weary voice that got me into it. Magar feels like a character I would follow a long way to hear his observations on things.

“Ah.” The thin fingers picked up a pen and wrote a small note. There would be no beans for breakfast tomorrow.

Brilliant.


A bit too Tolkienesque for an elf?
 
Deliberately Tolkienesque actually, but I'm not wed to following his naming conventions. Spur of the moment thing.

And thank you Phyrebrat - I'd have probably noticed that on the second run, but that sort of over wordiness is a besetting sin and I think that example will help me beat it.

Indeed, thank you all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top