The Big Peat
Darth Buddha
- Joined
- Apr 9, 2016
- Messages
- 3,774
The Flame Bearer is the 10th book in Bernard Cornwell's series about his fictional creation and ancestor, Uhtred of Bebbanburg. By now the young hot tempered killer who struggled between his loyalties in the first books is older and wiser, and the continual burr against his skin that was Alfred is a receding memory. The one thing that isn't is Bebbanburg itself and that great fortress is where we start and end the book.
Sounds good yeah?
Unfortunately Uhtred isn't the only one who comes across as old here. I frequently found myself wondering how much more story there was to mine out of the Saxon warlord and his time when reading this story. The story itself is thin and padded out by Cornwell continually returning to Uhtred thinking about his old bugbears. The result was something that almost felt more like a pastiche of Cornwell than the real McCoy itself.
Make no mistake; it is still an enjoyable story. Uhtred's insouciant irreverence is as strong as ever and is employed to its full range in a number of dramatic-comic moments in the middle of the book. Cornwell still writes as good an action scene as anyone. If you give this book to your average historical adventure-action fiction fan, they'll like it.
But most of Cornwell's books are loved by fans of that genre. And I didn't love this book by quite a long chalk. I can only hope that his other fans tell me I'm off my rocker but this now feels like a series that needs to end sooner rather than later.
Sounds good yeah?
Unfortunately Uhtred isn't the only one who comes across as old here. I frequently found myself wondering how much more story there was to mine out of the Saxon warlord and his time when reading this story. The story itself is thin and padded out by Cornwell continually returning to Uhtred thinking about his old bugbears. The result was something that almost felt more like a pastiche of Cornwell than the real McCoy itself.
Make no mistake; it is still an enjoyable story. Uhtred's insouciant irreverence is as strong as ever and is employed to its full range in a number of dramatic-comic moments in the middle of the book. Cornwell still writes as good an action scene as anyone. If you give this book to your average historical adventure-action fiction fan, they'll like it.
But most of Cornwell's books are loved by fans of that genre. And I didn't love this book by quite a long chalk. I can only hope that his other fans tell me I'm off my rocker but this now feels like a series that needs to end sooner rather than later.