1.04: Star Trek: Picard - Absolute Candor

Dave

Non Bio
Staff member
Joined
Jan 5, 2001
Messages
23,258
Location
Way on Down South, London Town
This series is picking up some speed now. The reason for the diversion from the mission to Freecloud to Vashti makes sense, as Picard says, "I am an old man" and there will be close combat fighting to come soon. It was obvious when the small boy was introduced (with even more back-story info-dumping) that he would become the next member of the crew. However, with the addition of Seven of Nine too, isn't the crew getting a little large for them all to be given airtime and with some redundancy in the character's roles? Or is Seven not joining the crew? There is much speculation but at the moment she has simply been rescued. Also, despite saving Picard's ship, there is speculation that she may have come to thwart his mission rather than to help it. Still the prospect of Seven of Nine interacting with Locutus of Borg has been something fans have long awaited. Someone suggested last week that Agnes Jurati might also be spying. If so, she is a very good actor as well as a scientist.

The other useful reason for stopping off at Vashti was to see a Romulan refugee colony. So, now we know a little bit about how they are surviving, their feelings towards Picard and the Federation. That is the way that back-story should be introduced.
 
The reason for the diversion from the mission to Freecloud to Vashti makes sense, as Picard says, "I am an old man" and there will be close combat fighting to come soon.

Oh, I love that old man stubbornness. They never have enough of time zic-zacking around the galaxy. It has to happen now, because tomorrow there might not be a chance. It certainly is true to anyone of us, and to most of things in the Star Trek universe. The numbers alone suggests that there simply is too many places to visit, and as the Federation hasn't invented an extension to one lifetime, orders has to come first.

Picard is too old to accept any other way. He cannot sit in his chair and enjoy the comforting atmosphere at the vineyard, even if it's recreated at the holodeck. That would be a foolish, but he's unlike the other old man, Spock, who stole the prototype to cause the Kelvin incident. It suggested that the old men need speed. The fastest vessels in the universe. In Spock's case, it was able to break the quantum and temporal barriers and it Picard's case it looks super sleek, but I don't think it's breaking Warp 9.

4JmvYam.jpg


Well, not yet anyway. But I also like that even though Picard is retaining his status, he is limited by the size of his wallet. The Romulan Space is still remaining and it's different now than when the Federation was all powerful. It was wonderful to see that they didn't made the daring run through the planetary defence network, but actually Picard had no choice but to pay the bill... or cheat with the old teleport trick.

The rules said that nobody could enter with the ship, unless a pass was granted, but the technology allowed him to pass the barrier, even more so than in the past. But I don't think that Scotty's trick of teleporting into a warping ship is allowed in this version of ST.

In case someone is unsure of the locations, this is the best map to show both quadrants at the end of the DS9.https://brilliantmaps.com/star-trek-map/

It was obvious when the small boy was introduced (with even more back-story info-dumping) that he would become the next member of the crew.

T4DaKjb.jpg


Oh, I like him. He wasn't taking sh*t when he was young and he ain't doing it now. I don't think they could have done the introduction any better. He is intense and exactly what the Old Man needs. Even when he was in Wolverine, he needed fierceness to complement his age. There is strong flame burning in Picard, and it can explode. I believe he's going all in to save Dahj. But he won't sacrifice his chips, unless it's needed.

However, with the addition of Seven of Nine too, isn't the crew getting a little large for them all to be given airtime and with some redundancy in the character's roles? Or is Seven not joining the crew?

No. Don't worry about the production, Sir Patrick Steward is more than talented to guide his people. I don't even know how many times he's been in Westend or in Old Vic in some role or another. He's classically trained and he can guide the other actors better than anyone. The directors and editors also show the quality as the whole thing has been cut perfectly together. I believe they could have even a bigger crew.

I also loved that the Romulan senator, before he lost his head gave Picard bollocking in Cockney. There was no hiding the accent. It also confirmed the theory that the federation managed to assimilate the pub culture outside its borders. Therefore also confirming the Irish Romulan theory. :cool: :inlove:

Picard is not going throw a lady out from the ship, especially when she owns one for Seven-of-Nine. The interesting situation is that now there's two security officers and one supreme weapon. What will happen when Seven-of-Nine arrives to the Artefact?
 
The old Startrek Crew was larger and gave people space to have their own attention without much trouble. Plus characters like Seven of Nine only need a basic "catch up since Voyager". Much like Picard she's already got a large part of her backstory established. All we need is the "update" to see the changes. Which so far it appears she's become a bit more "human" and lost some of her colder edge - though granted that's based on only a few moments of interaction. She's also got very good timing so I wonder how long she's been following and watching before being forced to attack. I hope she stays around, if just because it would be nice to have one or two points of old-series reference in the regular cast alongside Picard. Even though he's given a good argument why he's not reaching out to them (and Seven isn't one of his old crew - in fact any association with her and him is "new" information to us) having some from the past reach out to him makes perfect sense.

I liked how Picard baited the romulans into a conflict and then found himself out of his depth. Whilst he took his anger out on his new warrior companion (and I get a sort of feeling that Picard wanted to do Lord of the Rings* ;)) we are seeing that Picard has to start adapting. He's not got a capital ship behind him; he's not even got Starfleet behind him. I think in some way he's having to learn that some of his original "power" came from that, not just himself. That his speeches held weight when he had Starfleet behind him and now he's just an old man. He can't make promises; he can't enact great change on his own with a sweep of the hand.

It's even neat to see him having to learn he's not the captain of the ship he's hired. An interesting power dynamic that so far appears to remain amicable, however a hothead captain might well take issue in time if Picard keeps issuing orders. It's clear that he's got some demons in his past to have almost made a crew of his own holo units and also made them all appear like himself.



Overall a good episode, its still building things, but has kicked the action up a bit which I think is going to help the series. We see Picard take another blow, but we also see that he's still got many of his old talents. Who knows perhaps he might have talked down the former senator had he been blocked rather than killed. Perhaps we'll get to see that side of things later.




Edit * it actually really pleases me to see this in Startrek too. The original series (especially the films) always contained a sense of "space magic/fantasy" alongside the sci-fi. It's something that steadily, I think, got lost over the years. Next Generation had a bit of it; DS9 had some but mostly with regard to the Wormhole Aliens and its fantasy element didn't really come through heavily except in very specific episodes mostly dealing with them and at the very end. However many of the newer series have been very much spaceships in space. It's gratifying to see this visual return to some of the fantasy aspects, both in terms of martial warriors with swords; but also in terms of the visual style and aesthetics that the CGI allows them to achieve in ways that were impossible in the past.
 
Who knows perhaps he might have talked down the former senator had he been blocked rather than killed. Perhaps we'll get to see that side of things later.

I think it really depends on the situation. Picard needed to his guy in action, not just to hear good things and he tried to talk the Senator down. He gave up his arms and refused to fight but the Senator wanted to continue, not yield and listen. I don't think he would have lost any of his influence if he had done it. The Senator even claimed that people had worshipped Picard... so it would not have been a big loss. The problem is that they need to show the audience what the boy can do, and that they are not afraid of showing blood or decapitations in the screen.

Everyone of these episodes has had a fight scene, none of them has been completely peaceful. What I don't get is that how come the planetary defence system was so useless. I don't think it was completely powered, because it could have made the situation very different. Why is that they didn't feel once they had got Picard and the Boy on board?
 
I'm guessing Captain Rios is the first QPR fan ever to command a starship? :giggle: (Santiago Cabrera's a big fan)
 
I am normally impatient when backstories get in the way of action, but that has not been the case here.
I am naturally curious about everything Picard has experienced since Star Trek: Nemisis and about the state of Starfleet. I think that they are doing a nice job of weaving things together while throwing in enough action to underwrite what they are building.
With a second season already ordered and a third informally approved, Picard has the luxury of time.
 
Things are moving forward, albeit slowly. I will admit that I'm enjoying the Romulan development immensely as I've always felt they've been neglected in favour of the Klingons. Lovely to see a TOS Bird of Prey. I play the Romulans in Star Fleet Battles so I love their look.

I guess there's a minimum of two needless profanities per episode now. At least they got it out of the way early in the episode and we could move on.

The last third of the episode was pretty predictable from Picard's arrival at Vashti and everything that happens from that point on. Even so, it was enjoyable. The surprising elements of the series for me are how much I like Dr. Jurati and the La Sirena holograms.

This was the first episode that at the end I was disappointed and wanting to see more. Hopefully, it continues to improve.
 
I think Seven was following, probably on the orders of Janeway. If Janeway is still in Starfleet she would have been informed of Picard's visit. She's told Seven to keep an eye on Picard and help when needed.

Picard will still have friends in Starfleet, Janeway is clever enough to know he wouldn't get involved unless he thought it was important whatever the other admirals think.
Just a theory.
 
Episode 4 seen (belated).. WE'RE OFF!:

Well things have finally taken off! Enjoying the fact we're back in space.. loved the look of the Romulan refugee colony (particularly in the flashback sequences) with the giant 'world tree' background, although in the opening planet shot I wish we'd seen the Enterprise E approaching (considering they made some interesting modifications to the D I'd be interested to see what they do with the E). Backstory of the Romulan Samurai dude & his history with Picard was interesting, although Picard now walking around with a Elf looking dude that slices off heads feels a bit weird lol, but no doubt they'll be some big fun action bits with him down the track (which will aggravate oldschool trek purists to no end I'm sure haha).

Enjoyed the space battle, sure enough it was a classic 22nd century Romulan Bird of Prey (nice tip of hat to old Trek), retrofitted for lawless system warlord related activities lol. Interesting to see all these different hologram crew member variants captain Chris has. 7 of 9 has arrived! Will be very interesting to see how much they delve into her past and backstory post Voyager return. Also the holodeck stuff explains why she's in Patrick's 'home' in the trailers. I know people were complaining/making fun of the Picard sword scene in the original trailer, but it was fine, they even made him took kinda tough before he did the expected 'I'm not fighting you/playing your games' thing. Although his comment about having bad knees annoyed me, I don't care if you're 95yrs old, it's 24th century, people aren't gonna have 'bad knees' lol (we're already getting into 3D printing/replicating joints & cartilage now so it's only a matter of time), would rather they just continue to try and hide any difficulties RL Patrick might have, although I still maintain he seems to zip around just fine in real life on talk shows and stuff though lol.

Anyway we're already off to another planet in the teaser for the next ep so things are definitely moving along now lol! Although I'm a little worried about all that silly dress up stuff.. I swear to god if the next ep is like the Casino planet sequence in Ryan Johnson's cr*ptastic Star Wars film and black eye patch gangsta Picard is throwing dice with cheesy overly excited cgi aliens I'm gonna throw my Tv lol.

Oh and I'm probably off the mark with the Lore theory previously posted.. sounds like they're going for something bigger.. harbinger of doom stuff lol!

Guess I better hurry up and watch Ep 5 now instead of reading comments as that's just asking for spoilers haha.

.
 
I love the production values and atmosphere, and I think Picard's dialogue is great. But I'm getting frustrated with the amateur plotting. The story of Dahj was introduced at the beginning - but since then we've had more than 2 hours of backstory while "the hero collects companions for the quest". That's not how it's supposed to be done.

As with the last episode I'm really hoping the actual story can begin now we've got all (?) the necessary backstory out of the way. Judging by the look of the crew, we've got exactly what we needed.

Another criticism - the ship they are using is unimpressive, outside and inside. It just looks like a Federation shuttle and we're missing something of the iconic designs we're used to seeing for ships in Trek. Inside it just looks like a big empty warehouse - except for the stairs and lower level which just looks like a health and safety issue (similar complaint applies to The Expanse).

Overall, though, it's cinematic and atmospheric and there's a nice balance between drama and pathos. But they've yet to really start the story - it's all infodumping and convenience. The production qualities, Picard, and the brand name of Star Trek are carrying the momentum here, but if this wasn't Trek and a completely different show we'd already be expected it to be cancelled at the end of the season.
 
Something else. Why do we have a Samurai Elf on the crew? I like the look - but it's just another fantasy cliche in what should be a sci-fi. Now we'll have to hope that Picard only comes across bad-guys with hand-held weapons - as they pointed out in this episode, he's not got to stand-up well against handguns.
 
Frankly, I think all the supporting characters are two-dimensional and clichéd. The samurai elf could have come from any D&D campaign in the last 30 years. I don't care about Raffi, Rios, or the elf.
 

Similar threads


Back
Top