The Ninth Galaxy Reader, ed. Frederik Pohl

Extollager

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2010
Messages
9,271
Are any of these really good stories?

 
I may have read more but I know I've read the Farmer, Pohl, del Rey (usually known as "Vengeance Is Mine"), Zelazny, and Lafferty (though not in a million years). The Farmer and Zelazny are short-shorts (or flash), I don't recall the Pohl well (which might be considered a strike against it, but I wouldn't be surprised if it was really good) and I do like the del Rey. Not sure I'd call it "great" but it's at least "really good," I think. Overall, that anthology looks like it also might not be "great" but is probably at least "pretty good."

Oh, and I reviewed that del Rey story for Black Gate if you're interested: Gods, Robots, and Man: The Best of Lester del Rey.
 
I read this @four years ago and put a review on Amazon:

This is the 1970 Pan paperback edition. There are 12 stories totalling 228 pages and a brief introduction by Frederik Pohl.

I have enjoyed this anthology more than others I have read recently. There isn't really a weak story (well, maybe one), and some are excellent.

I do not know enough about science fiction to give detailed comments on this collection. I'm also concerned that in the detail I might give away too much of the storylines. My main motivation for reviewing is to give an easily accessible list of contents to those browsing through anthologies on Amazon.

Here is a list of the contents together with a brief scene setting comment or quote (definitely not plot spoiling):

(1) "An Ancient Madness" by Damon Knight
First lines: "Thirty sisters, as like as peas, were sitting at their looms in the court above the Gallery of Weavers. In the cool shadow, their white dresses rustled like the stirrings of doves, and their voices now murmured, now shrilled."
Lovely story.

(2) "The King of the Beasts" by Philip Jose Farmer
Only two pages long, but remarkably effective.

(3) "The Watchers in the Glade" by Richard Wilson
First lines: " Nevins, who had been ill, did not rejoin the others for nearly two weeks, after they had been cast away by the mutineers. It was dusk when he walked into the glade of flame-coloured grass where they had decided to wait. Jeffries was the only one to greet him."
Surprisingly good story. Five journalists and two medics have been stranded on an uninhabited world.

(4) "Jungle Substitute" by Brian W. Aldiss
Third paragraph: "The city stood high on piers above the plain. The plain as yet would be dark. That was what gave Robin the thrill: the thought of that grim black land where no humans went, where terrors dwelt. Covertly he circled himself."
Excellent story of humanity/robots living in massive self-contained cities.

(5) "How the Old World Died" by Harry Harrison
First lines: " `Tell me how the world ended, Grandfather, won't you please?' the boy pleaded, looking up at the seamed face of the old man sitting next to him on the trunk of the fallen tree." Five page story.

(6) "The Children of Night" by Frederik Pohl
Odin Gunnarson, of public relations firm Moultrie and Bigelow, has jetted in to Belport to rescue a failing campaign. No other PR firm had been prepared to represent the Arcturan Confederacy.
Well-written story.

(7) "To Avenge Man" by Lester Del Rey
Hal Norman and Sam (an original Mark One robot) find three Earth spaceships parked by the Lunar Base Dome when they return over the crater wall in their cat-track vehicle.
Good story

(8) "The Monster and the Maiden" by Roger Zelazny
Excellent two page story of, as the title indicates, a monster and a maiden.

(9) "A Flask of Fine Arcturan" by C.C. MacApp
Arcturus V is ideal for producing the new hardwood whisky bottles.

(10) "Wrong-Way Street" by Larry Niven
Mike Capoferri has spent several years, along with thirty other scientists, researching the alien ship found next to the deserted alien base on the moon.

(11) "Wasted on the Young" by John Brunner
First lines: "The doorbell sounded. Hal Page had been attending to two final tasks: first, checking around the apartment and making sure everything was ready for this, which was going to be one hell of a party; second, trying to decide where to put the notice."
He's really worried about that notice.

(12) "Slow Tuesday Night" by R.A.Lafferty
First lines: "A panhandler intercepted the young couple as they strolled down the night street. `Preserve us this night,' he said as he touched his hat to them, `and could you good people advance me a thousand dollars to be about the recouping of my fortunes?'"


In SF I was only reading anthologies at that time (I got through@130 of them, all 1975 or earlier, before I stopped), and from the review I definitely thought it was worth reading. Without digging the book out of the garage, I can't remember too much of the stories, so I can't say which one specifically I thought was weak. Although the Lafferty is well-known, for me it's not one of his best. I can recall something of the Richard Wilson and Frederik Pohl, and remember liking them, but my memory would need to be jogged further to remember more of the others.
Anyway, I obviously liked it.
 
Last edited:
That's really helpful, Hugh. It looks like I may need to get a copy after all. I'm looking at a project of rereading the books I compiled in mid-1968, as a kid not quite in my teens. Since as a boy I gave this book just 2 out of 4 and to this day tend not to be a huge fan of Galaxy, I thought maybe I'd give this one a miss, but now I doubt that I will.

 
Our tastes may differ...

If you do get round to reading it, I'll be interested to hear what you make of it.
 
I ordered a copy. Again, thanks!

I've also had a go-ahead from a fanzine editor to write an article about these books. "The 1968 List" with a subtitle might be what I'll call it.

I already wrote here about two of the books on the 1968 list.


 
Frederik Pohl’s “The Children of Night”: As I began to reread this story, it seemed to be typical of Galaxy, a satire of the Madison Avenue public relations business with no sense of wonder or excitement although set in the future.

The main character, Odin “Gunner” Gunnarson, has been assigned to manipulate mass opinion in favor of a telemetry and tracking station to be built on Earth for Arcturus, which has been at war with Terrans till very recently. Gunner is like a character in some 1950s movie about publicity, hustling about, telling one person to “Hire these girls I’ve marked for your staff” and another to line up appropriate food for the aliens, etc. One of the items on his to-do list is to invent a “big lie.”

Halfway through, the story becomes abruptly grimmer when Gunner visits a hospital, seeing children who had been maimed by the aliens who captured them when Arcturus attacked a Martian colony. Gunner thereafter meets an Arcturan representative, Knafti, who criticizes him for changing the truth and, for a reason or reasons unclear to me, says the war may have to be fought again.

In desperation, Gunner arranges a tense meeting with a prominent opponent of the Arcturan base proposal, Knafti, and several others. Knafti says he did not do the maiming. Gunner gets everyone angry at him and, accordingly, willing to talk with each other.

The story’s implication is that differences are resolved and the base will be built – a success for Gunner who, however, doesn’t get the girl, his assistant Candace Harmon.

The story's elements didn't quite come together for me, as if Pohl had been trying to juggle too much -- satire, irony, something about inter-species war and peace, horror, etc. I like my sf to be concise but maybe this one needed to be a little longer. Why did the Arcturans attack the Martian colony? Who was responsible for the maiming of the Children and why was it done? Is Pohl setting up a subplot involving why Candace chooses to marry Whitling ratherthan Gunner?
 
With two stories left (Brunner, Lafferty), I'm seeing the Wilson and Niven offerings as by far my preferred ones.
 
The Lafferty and MacApp are obviously meant to be humorous. I don’t go to sf for humor and almost never like sf stories that are supposed to be funny.

I don’t even think much of “To Serve Man.” Or maybe that wasn’t supposed to be funny except for the ending. Damon Knight’s “The Big Pat Boom” I thunk was more successful with me.

I’m pretty sure I’m forgetting one or a few others, but the only humorous sf stories that I like that seem to be coming to mind are C. S. Lewis’s “Ministering Angels” and Terry Bisson’s “Bears Discover Fire.”

I seem to remember a Howard Waldrop story about chickens that might have amused me a little.

Right, don’t invite me to your party, I don’t blame you.
 
Last edited:
So has it been worth re-visiting or trial by tedium? Has your taste remained much the same?

My bar may not be set that high when it comes to old SF stories, as it looks like I enjoyed the anthology more than you. Then again, I was reading a lot of anthologies at the time, so it may not say a lot about the others.

I think at least we're agreed on the Wilson story as having been worth the read.
 
It was interesting to visit this book that I'd managed to read before my 13th birthday. A lot of the material in it must have been over my head and/or not to my taste, but if my 1968 remarks are to be believed, I did read everything. That testifies to the desire for science fiction, that a boy whose taste ran more to "Arena" (the Gorn one) as perhaps his favorite Star Trek teleplay should persevere with this book; but there was not a great deal of sf available to me.

I've wondered if the librarians of the Coos Bay, Oregon, public library of the mid-1960s didn't think much of sf and didn't perceive very much demand for it, and so perhaps they acquired a few SF Book Club offerings per year and figured honor was satisfied. (I have little doubt they'd have had some Wells, Verne, Bradbury, etc. I know they had two or three of the Heinlein juveniles in the kids' section, etc.) They had volumes of Galaxy Readers and The Best from Fantasy and Science Fiction but I'm pretty sure their sets were incomplete. The library's investment in sf, year by year, must have been very small.

This was at a time when many libraries, including this one, didn't offer Edgar Rice Burroughs or Nancy Drew or the Hardy Boys or Tom Swift.

I don't regard that period as Dark Ages pure and simple. If libraries passed up some worthy books as beneath notice, they also didn't spend a lot of the public's money on sheer rubbish...then.

I don't think this library generally bought paperbacks. It's interesting to be old enough that you can remember the time when buying paperbacks or not was evidently kind of controversial for libraries. Coos Bay's library did get paperbacks of the Tolkien books, perhaps finding that people wanted them but regarding them as likely to be a fad.
 

Similar threads


Back
Top