The Man Who Fell to Earth by Tevis Walter

Vertigo

Mad Mountain Man
Supporter
Joined
Jun 29, 2010
Messages
8,763
Location
Scottish Highlands
T.J. Newton is an extraterrestrial from Anthea (never stated but quite obviously Mars) who is masquerading as a human and using his more advanced technology to make a big enough fortune to build a spaceship to rescue the few remaining survivors of his species from their dying planet to live on Earth.

This is obviously a classic made particularly famous by Bowie’s portrayal of Newton in the, probably more well-known, film of the same name. Written in the early sixties and set in the, then, future eighties Tevis uses Newton’s experiences to preach against the catastrophe towards which the world of the sixties seemed to be inexorably heading. Environmental issues are addressed but Tevis focuses mainly on his clear expectations of imminent worldwide political destruction. I must say I found this aspect of the book a little trying but I’m not sure how much of that is down to the fact that, despite Tevis’ clear expectations to the contrary, we did survive that era (though whether we will the next is more open to debate). There were also several desperately implausible events the worst of which is something of a spoiler.
In what world does Tevis think it likely that the US government would release to complete freedom a known extraterrestial, without any conditions or restraints? I mean, come on, if anything such a think was probably even less likely in the sixties than it is today.

The prose is excellent, as befits an author who taught English literature and creative writing at university, making it an easy and moderately short read. The characters are well drawn, if not particularly likeable and the plot well-constructed. But I found I struggled to really be gripped and convinced by the story, leaving me feeling somewhat ambivalent. Good but not excellent.

3/5 stars
 
I thought I'd read this in the dim and very distant past, but I couldn't remember any of it when I picked it up last year, so perhaps not. I definitely haven't seen the film.

Anyway, I was also rather ambivalent about it -- I felt more that I ought to think it was good, rather than I actually did think it -- and I'd agree with your 3/5 judgement. I keep a somewhat haphazard record of what I'm reading and I see that in my notes I have a detailed account of the plot, but unusually I didn't add any other comments, which suggests I couldn't think of anything or couldn't make up my mind what to say about it at the time.

I imagine if I had read it when I was younger I'd have thought more highly of the actual plot, but it does seem rather naive in so many ways. I don't know if we're perhaps now more ready to expect political and bureaucratic duplicity and manoeuvrings, but it goes beyond that for me. While Newton is himself seen as unsophisticated in his impressions and ideas about Earth, I still couldn't buy into the way Trevis has him fall in with a semi-illiterate, semi-functioning drunk who then becomes his employee. I also couldn't summon up any sympathy or empathy for the characters -- they read as very real, but also the kind of people I'd cross the road to avoid!

So, I'm glad I read it, but it's not one I'd want to read again.
 

Back
Top