The Inexorable Rise - Act 1, Chapter 1

BT Jones

Well-Known Member
Supporter
Joined
Feb 12, 2020
Messages
715
Location
Australia
So, this is the first 1,500 words of the first chapter of the first act of my first story. Fell entirely free to read this or not. No obligations. It's dense, dark, foreboding, and not for everyone. This chapter was originally 7,500 words and incredibly weighty. It's down to about 4,400 now. I've resisted posting this up to now because (rather snobbishly) I always felt it should be read in one sitting all the way through and not broken into 1,500 word sections - in the same way classic albums should be played form start to finish, at the right time, in the right way, with the right sound system.

Alas, the forum rules (and, I imagine, understandable SFFer unwillingness to dedicate that much time) prevent me from doing so. That bugged me at the start, but I have definitely come to appreciate why that is the case now, and can certainly see this from other people's point of view about how much time they can dedicate to someone else's work.

Anyway, here it is. It's a definite red-herring in terms of what the rest of the Act is like (the last line of the Chapter - not included here - is a far better indicator). I just can't let it go. For how I see it in my head, for what this sets up, and the atmosphere it provokes, I am resolute that this is the right way to start of the story.

Feel free to read or not. Zero issues if no one has the time.
(Cue shameful tagging of @Guttersnipe, @Joshua Jones, @Jo Zebedee, @elvet, @Provincial & @jd73 (because, although we don't really know each other, we voted for the same 3 stories in the October 300, which I like to think means our tastes are aligned). Apologies also if I'm not allowed to tag this many people.

The Inexorable Rise
Act 1 - Cinereous
Chapter 1


I have weight.

I am of body, of dimension. I can feel the distance to my limbs, even if I cannot yet move. I am whole again, reconstituted... but how? And, where am I?

I see only darkness. What is this place? How long have I been here? Where was I before? I recall disembodiment, an untethered sensation. I was detached, floating. The memory feels proximal and I reach for it, but with every inch further I mentally extend, so too does an invisible spit lancing my soul. It is a sudden ominousness, like irons slung across my shoulders.

I grasp for the particulars of the memory and a picture forms in my mind: a room of grey-green stone, meticulously carved from ancient metamorphic rock, coated in a dark blanket of dust like rusting frost. There is a pale-yellow light filtering down from above through some indeterminable aperture.

Yes, the vestibule; I remember it now. I remember myself within it, as unified as I am now. I recall the harshness of the air, and its noxious edge. I recall the churning sound, somewhere beyond the walls or beneath those stone pavers. Or was it above? I recall wondering. I remember lifting my head, seeking the source of that noise…and as my memory avatar does so again, the shackles return, as does the searing needle to the heart.

As the image lifts, so too does a suffocating sickness at my core. Then the memory finally reassembles, but the associated emotion is not the wondrous satisfaction of a forgotten name recalled, nor glee at finally grasping the solution to an age-old puzzle. The feeling is akin to reconciling with the shadow of your darkest day. The reminiscence is like a blown-apart body reassembled with pins and mortar.

That chamber: it is where I ceased being whole. It is where the echoed sense of separation I awoke with stems from. My memory’s gaze fixes on the ceiling of the antechamber and the vision is clear: the source of the noise – that stirring, rushing agitation – hangs overhead, suspended from it, within...

…those pipes – Merciful Upholder, those pipes. How could I forget those infernal conduits?

This is not right. This cannot be. I cannot be here, wherever it is I now find myself, and I cannot be whole. This cold darkness around me; it is an illusion, the disembodied fantasy of an accursed soul, desperately picturing a place and a form of existence that is anything other than where and what they are. Remains: that is all I was and all that I am - the processed remnants of what was once a living soul.

Great Fountainhead, the memory is rancid as it rushes back to me now; standing on the stone floor of the vestibule one moment, levitating towards those pipes the next – of form and of body in the first instance, and torn asunder in the second. I was shredded, dissected. But there was no blade, no instrument at work. I was dismembered, disarticulated, as if by the very air itself. And every molecule of what remained was drawn through those pipes.

With the image comes the recollection of the pain I felt. How can I possibly have forgotten it? Even now, the spectral echo of that pure, wicked agony coats me like a thick, burning tar, searing my every cell. It was suffering beyond that which could ever be comprehended by a mortal soul. I recall the scream; a vile, harrowing, inhuman shriek, incessant until my voice, too, was deconstructed. Even then, it continued, at an octave inaudible to all but the most fell of beasts – and that was to be merely the opening stanza of the atrocity.

Not even in death was I spared the torment. Just as I could still scream whilst devoid of voice, so too did I see all, even with my eyes extruded. By some ungodly bane, I witnessed every gruesome second of the ordeal. I beheld as my flesh was stripped, my limbs pulled apart, my organs extracted. I watched as the remnants of my body were siphoned into those rusted, decaying ducts like putrid offal, and as my fetid remains coursed across vast repositories, from my wretched vigil I was left in no doubt as to where this was. Merciful Upholder, to recall the horror of my realisation a second time is as if to suffer it anew; for it was not just any place.

It was that place: the eternal forge. Purgatory.

That I could have possibly forgotten about it even for a second is inconceivable. To witness such an edifice is to define the remainder of your existence by it. The sight of it is a tattoo, etched across the eyes in fire. To be there is to be anatomically rewritten from the inside out with its code.

I envy the blissful ignorance of the anaesthetized disconnected masses, so dismissive of the ancient, stone-scribed portents and their modern relevance, without even the vaguest impression of what it is like. I pity the devout, living out their lives with the knowledge that one day, no matter what; they would be destined for that place. Even then, no ancient texts, or apocryphal tales – nothing conveyed in ink or tongue could hope to portray it with any degree of authenticity. The manifestation of one’s worst waking fears cannot begin to capture the look, or the sound, or the smell of that place.

It was indescribable, unimaginable, unfathomable; a titanic foundry, so far-reaching in every direction as to be dimensionless, boundless, infinite – befitting of every conceivable hyperbole. But it was also a place of atrocious contradiction. On the one hand, it was frigid and black, as if all the heat and light that might ever have existed within or around it had been extinguished, eons past. On the other, it was scalding, and dazzlingly bright.

So, too, was the noise confounding; the deafening din of steam jetting from incalculable depths and the ungodly throbbing of a million abyssal furnaces. It sung with a cacophony that quaked every fibre of my being, yet, simultaneously, there was a layer of deathly silence hovering just below the dissonance, audible in equal measure. It was an explosion of noise and the absence of noise, all at the same time; and it was the absence of a great many more things besides.

If life as we would measure it had ever been there, it had been vaporised long ago. It was untouched and unseen, as if nothing sentient had ventured within leagues of the place since the last block in its walls had been set – which is assume it was actually built. It seemed more likely that it had simply existed since before the birth of time itself, as if it was always there and always would be there, untroubled by evolution, expansion, decay. It was aged and yet also ageless, beyond the concept of time – and for an eternity, or a scale akin, so too was my suffering.

With every second that ticked by, I remained lucid and sensitised, despite my disintegration, ablaze with the perception of a thousand burning spears, recurrently piercing my flesh. It was perpetual torture; a violent, execrable death, suffered a hundred times the same way in the same moment. And there would be no end to my sentence. The notion of a time when I would not be there – or a time when I had yet to arrive – was folly. Death had become all there was and all there would ever be; death and that place, orbiting one another in an abominable black abyss, an age before the spark of the first light.

And therein lay the paradox: if I could never leave – if my destiny was to remain inexorably tethered to that place for all time – how can it possibly be that I am not there still? How can I be here, in this new darkness, whole of body, devoid of pain, sensing almost tangible limits around me?

True, it was a realm of bewildering contradiction, but such incongruities were all aligned in their malignant design, retained within the walls of the forge. There was simply nothing else beyond its boundaries, if such limits could ever be located. It was the end of ends.

Even if by some miracle I have escaped, how I could possibly have been reconstituted after such unequivocal dissection. Recasting a man from his own ashes would be witchcraft of the highest order – witchcraft or the perverse whim of the ultimate power.

It is a conundrum; feeling free of that chaotic vortex, and yet still sensing the soul motion of being spirited around its service pipes. It is as if I am anchored to two places at once – spiritually rooted in one, physically detained in another. But still the question persists: where is here?
 
I don't know if our tastes in the 300s will coincide as I've not voted yet in this quarter's Challenge, nor seen how you've voted, but I rather suspect you have a greater degree of patience than do I when it comes to reading.

I did read through to the end of this, but to be honest without any degree of concentration after the first paragraphs, and it became something of a skim read that got faster towards the end. The opening is intriguing, though to my mind unnecessarily verbose by the third paragraph, but after that you lose yourself in all the reflection/memory/questioning and the verbosity just takes off into another dimension -- for me it's not adding atmosphere, only wordage. I don't need action from the get-go of a novel, and I'm happier than most to read description and exposition in the first few pages, and I'm quite able to take my time and savour good writing, but I do want to feel that something is happening or is about to happen, so I can see there's a point to what is written, and for me that's wholly lacking here. It reads to me more like an extended exercise in fine writing than the opening of a novel. But then, I had much the same reaction to Cloud Atlas, so what do I know?

I note you say that it's perhaps not indicative of the rest of the novel, but that might actually be a double-edged sword. Those readers who want something very different such as you're writing later might well baulk at pages of this kind of writing -- and I'm pretty sure most trad publishers are going to be wary -- while those who are happy with this cerebral stuff might object if in later chapters your writing changes to something more SFFish.

Anyhow, nit-picking wise nothing leapt out at me on my skimmy-read save that to my mind your semi-colon usage needs to be restrained, and I'm pretty sure not all of the little devils are used correctly. I'd also suggest you go easy on the repeated bolding.

Sorry I can't be more enthusiastic, but good luck with it.
 
I think the writing is fine, but I find this sort of passage - where a character tries to make sense of their surroundings - very hard to read. There's nothing for my imagination to lock on to, just the floating thoughts of a character that I have no idea about. There are too many questions, and that pushes me away more than it draws me in. It starts to feel like prose poetry, or a description of a hallucination, and I find myself just wanting the story to start.

If that sounds hostile, I should add that this kind of writing does work for some people. It's quite heavy prose, but it's not bad writing at all. I'm not sure on the bolding too. I think I'd just not italicise it.
 
I think it's extremely well-written, but I found myself skimming as well. This kind of situation doesn't remain interesting forever.
 
I thought the voice of the narrator was very well-defined, and a lot of the individual sentences and phrases were beautiful. However, it felt a bit circular. For me, there wasn't as much of a sense of advancement as I generally like from the books I read. There were too many similar descriptions; it felt too long for what it was. I also had trouble picturing some of the things you described and I wasn't very grounded within the world of the story.
 
I had the same problems as the commenters above. I also thought it was basically overwritten with too many repeated ways of describing the same thing by mining the contents of a thesaurus. Metaphors like this didn't work for me I'm afraid -
To witness such an edifice is to define the remainder of your existence by it. The sight of it is a tattoo, etched across the eyes in fire.
This does sound a bit harsh I know, but it wasn't possible to envisage what was meant by such descriptions. I'm afraid I rather glazed over after a while.
 
So, the 1500 vs the 4500 thing, it’s not about time or patience it’s about the fact that a short piece can often tell us enough for you to be going along with. In this case I wouldn‘t have critiqued on because I’d have been worried there was nothing more going on.
instead of critting, let me ask a couple of questions:

why have you included the scene? I get the feeling it’s to give us info and that’s rarely engaging enough to keep someone hooked.
on that, what do you feel is the hook in this scene?
in terms of the challenge entry we voted for, go back and see if you can work out what made it work for so many of us. You know it’s an effective piece of writing, can you tell why?
sadly for me this piece doesn’t work to engage me. :(
 
Thanks to uni, I've had a year of wallowing in a lot of meta fiction. For me the best of which focuses on the character but also nudges the story forward as it's going. For example Will Self's Phone has mentions of a house and a guy called Maurice.

We need a reason to understand and care for the character, and I think the story looks backwards too much. My advice if you keep the style would be to consider the effect of not recalling things - just describing what the character is currently going through. Just put in odd comments about flashbacks.

Also shortening the sentences, and reducing the words a little (I know wordy helps with the confusion) might help to increase the tension. For example in the first sentences the important information is that they are whole again and how did that happen. The rest can be reduced or cut completely without any loss in meaning.
 
Hi,

I did read it carefully to the end, so I hope you don’t mind if I point out a couple of words which might need attention since they stuck out a bit.

You said your eyes were extruded, which to me means that they were pushed through a piece of shaped metal and came out a different shape, as in extruding aluminium window frames. It didn’t work for me.

Also, you used the word assume rather than assuming in ‘always assume that the forge was built’.

I had a couple of other issues, too.

I was thrown by your calling the place purgatory. My limited understanding of Christianity suggests that it was actually hell, since the time spent in purgatory is most definitely not endless. However it might be that you are presenting the theology of a different religion in a fictional universe, so I don’t know what to make of it. If this is a religion which you are inventing it would be helpful to people like me (people who care about that sort of detail) if you could somehow make that clear from the outset.

As for the opening as a whole, despite having thrown a whole load of words at me you gave me no reason to identify with or to like the main character, or even to sympathise with them. 1500 words in and I still knew nothing about them at all.

As I am not a publishing professional I don’t know what they are looking for in a manuscript, so it could be the next Booker prize winner for all I know. All I can tell you is how I reacted to it, and I’m afraid it isn’t good news. By the end of this segment I was tired of wading through the verbiage for so little reward. If I had picked this book up off a library shelf I would have put it back again and looked for something else. But I’ve done that with other Booker prize winners, too!

I think you have something here which could become something great, but you wore my patience out so quickly I would never read on long enough to find out. There is so much other stuff on offer in the market competing with your work that I don’t think you can afford to woo the reader gently. My inclination would be to grab ‘em by the short and curlies first and then show them just how good a writer you are! That’s up to you, however.

If you post any more of this chapter please notify me, I promise to read it. I would like an opportunity to be more positive about something you have spent so much time on, especially if it does fulfill its promise.
 
I think there is a hook - namely "What's going on?" - but for me that's too vague. What it lacks, to me, is a sense of forward movement. It swirls around with the character's thoughts, which might be realistic if they're coming round from unconsciousness, but isn't engaging enough. I could "get" a story that opened with a character waking up in an unknown room, collecting their thoughts and then exploring the location, because that has movement (presumably towards a door and finding a way out) and clear questions to answer (Where am I? Who put me here?). The question "Where is here?", which seems like the right thing to ask, needs to come a lot earlier for me, and the character (whoever they are) needs to be trying something definite to answer it earlier on.
 
Thanks so much @The Judge, @Toby Frost, @Guttersnipe, @sule, @pambaddeley, @Jo Zebedee, @AnyaKimlin, and @Provincial for taking the time to read this excerpt. It was always going to be the hardest part of my work to read so I really appreciate the effort (and I totally understand the skimming).

Of course, one always wants people to love their work. That said, I'm more appreciate of the constructive criticism than I am disappointed.

The wordiness of the piece wasn't remotely (at least wasn't supposed to be) an attempt by me to show off but rather try and capture the mindset of the character and create some dark, foreboding mystery. What follows - and who this character is - a places it in much better context. But, of course, I want people to read on and not put the book back on the shelf, so to speak, so it's clear from all you responses that I need to tone this down and perhaps layer the hellish visions as semi-flashbacks between the actual progression of the character in the real world he is stepping out into.

I will post the next 1,500 words next week. It is more of the same, but it grows gradually more focused as the character gets closer to the figure in the adjoining space. I imagine there won't be any great need to enlarge upon what you all said above other than 'ditto'. But hopefully you will see that there is perhaps more hope in this opening and how it can be better reworked to make it more appealing to more casual readers.

Once again, everyone, thank you so much. I can't tell you how much it means that you all took an interest. I'll tag you all in the next post if that's okay. But, again, no issues if you want to skim or skip it all together. What you've given me already is invaluable.
 
I am resolute that this is the right way to start of the story.
I hope you will reconsider. I sense there may be an interesting plot that may be developing, but for me the introduction style is simply not working. It took me three attempts before I could force myself to complete reading the intro.

I believe the first three paragraphs are sufficient to establish a mood. By the fourth, I was hoping for something more direct than vague imagery. I am not sure that as I reader that I would have missed anything had the text simply skipped from the first three paragraphs to the final line, "Where is here?"
 
Thanks @Wayne Mack... and I should say that I WAS resolute prior to reading the responses!! :LOL:
It has been an invaluable exercise and I have already accepted that a change is required. I agree, perhaps the first 3 paragraphs for mood setting, but then bringing the characters awakening and movement much further forward, and then interspersing it with selected hellish imagery as and where relevant.

Thanks for reading.
 
This comes from a person more knowledgeable in movie language rather than book language.

The text itself is beautiful, you have a good way with words.
I know you probably have heard already that the text is a bit too abstract and hard to follow for a longer time.
It is painful but I've been taught that if something does not push the story forward it is not necessary. This is of course not always the case as you can have a text that builds a atmosphere and mood without pushing the story forward but if you linger too long on the building of atmosphere the reader will be bored and lose focus. In general it is a good tip to have in the back of your head.
The text as said is beautiful and is not necessarily wrong by itself but without a proper introduced context the reader is more confused and disorientated than the person you read about. Given the text is written with the main characters point of view it is vital that the reader has a anchor point in some aspect such as a proper introduction to our main character or the world. If you want to make a abstract start, that is fine but keep it much shorter and progress the story faster so your reader can get a hold of the story and become invested.
 
Thanks for the tag! I like your writing style - adjectival, rich, and ponderous. However, as others have suggested, something ~needs to happen~ rather than only this disconnected voice floating about in some hellish place wondering about their fate. I mean, keep it in your story notes as it clearly feeds into a character and an event, but for us readers, give us more of that character and event in that wonderfully dense style. Otherwise, it's like the 4th guitar solo of a prog-metal opus; technically it may be brilliant, and you may enjoy executing it, but the audience needs drama, we feed off drama! :)
You've given us the doomed POV char with the troubled destiny; now by all the powers in all the realms, make that char rise up from the slime pit as they defy the gods in their obsessive quest for greatness! Because ~that~ I would read the heck out of. Good luck :) Hope this helps
 
I loved the first sentence.
I loved the next paragraph.
I have weight.
I am of body, of dimension. I can feel the distance to my limbs, even if I cannot yet move. I am whole again, reconstituted... but how? And, where am I?

Then things fell apart.
I'm going to be a little harsh.

The next paragraph begins the confusion.
Oh it's a good paragraph; however...
I see only darkness. What is this place? How long have I been here? Where was I before? I recall disembodiment, an untethered sensation. I was detached, floating. The memory feels proximal and I reach for it, but with every inch further I mentally extend, so too does an invisible spit lancing my soul. It is a sudden ominousness, like irons slung across my shoulders.
I say this is good, because it holds key elements and it's one of the few in the remaining paragraphs that, as a reader, I feel is justified and helps me understand the story.
One thing though. The reader is left to assume or imagine too much. I took the darkness to mean that it was so dark that there was no hint of light nor shadow; meaning that the only way to really know that he has weight and a full body is that he can feel himself with his hands. He then recalls being somewhere else. Then its unclear but I think he goes back to the dark place. But there is a sense that he might be suspended--possibly feels gravity but the last sentence is confusing.

Before that he indicates a lance through his soul. But seems to describe it as ominous iron slung across the shoulders, Now if he were a tailor I'd suspect he sews and presses garments and is carrying two irons one on each shoulder. However it seems that possibly it should say...It' is an ominous yoke of iron. However I can't discount that he might be pierced like a butterfly from shoulder to shoulder--except that it's the soul that is pierced and that image assumes that the writer means to include the body into what defines a soul.

There is a possibility that he can't really feel himself because his arms might be affected, there is only an illusion that he has a full body..

One problem that sticks out here is that there are too many images stacked one on the other and this continues through the rest of the piece. It needs cleaned up and perhaps some clarity such as if you mean a yoke of iron you might say a yoke of iron--however at this point I really don't know what it means it could be a lance like a pin in a butterfly collection..

What is important here is...I recall disembodiment, an untethered sensation. I was detached, floating.
I missed this on the first read--rather I conflated it with the darkness which I think was all wrong.
It's important because it helps understand that besides where he came from first he was once in one place and is now in another.

The next paragraph begins the world building and mood tweaking.

I grasp for the particulars of the memory and a picture forms in my mind: a room of grey-green stone, meticulously carved from ancient metamorphic rock, coated in a dark blanket of dust like rusting frost. There is a pale-yellow light filtering down from above through some indeterminable aperture.
Nothing here helps the story or moves it forward--in fact this goes backwards and the scene description might be worked too much or more than necessary; however the key is that I don't think this paragraph matters--though I could be wrong.

The rest of the piece is a description of what might have happened to him until we reach the last line.

But still the question persists: where is here?
As it is this goes on too long for what it appears not to contain.

So for this reader what is important here is...

Hello darkness with your illusion that I have weight and all my appendages; a reprieve from that Purgatory of disembodied floating, but a mystery since last I recall I was sliced and diced by something that might have been a blender with a mode called 'atomize'. But now I am here all back together in some miracle or magic because, god forbid, this certainly can't be heaven. But where is here?

As a reader this is all I could find that I need to know.

So I guess the task is--go back through and find anything else you want the reader to know and find a shorter more concise way of handing it across to the reader--unless you are looking for a rather narrow audience. In that case if you leave it as it is, that will filter out the readers who you don't care to have read this.

Just my opinion.
 
Thanks @Wayne Mack... and I should say that I WAS resolute prior to reading the responses!! :LOL:
It has been an invaluable exercise and I have already accepted that a change is required. I agree, perhaps the first 3 paragraphs for mood setting, but then bringing the characters awakening and movement much further forward, and then interspersing it with selected hellish imagery as and where relevant.

Thanks for reading.

I think with a rewrite you can possibly keep the beginning but keep it forward moving and give us more reason to care about the character.
 
Thanks for the tag! I like your writing style - adjectival, rich, and ponderous. However, as others have suggested, something ~needs to happen~ rather than only this disconnected voice floating about in some hellish place wondering about their fate. I mean, keep it in your story notes as it clearly feeds into a character and an event, but for us readers, give us more of that character and event in that wonderfully dense style. Otherwise, it's like the 4th guitar solo of a prog-metal opus; technically it may be brilliant, and you may enjoy executing it, but the audience needs drama, we feed off drama! :)
You've given us the doomed POV char with the troubled destiny; now by all the powers in all the realms, make that char rise up from the slime pit as they defy the gods in their obsessive quest for greatness! Because ~that~ I would read the heck out of. Good luck :) Hope this helps

No, @jd73, thank you; for the gushing praise and the hilarious reference to prog metal (a genre after my own heart). Hopefully you will enjoy the 2nd & 3rd posts more as the character does indeed rise up (in a way) to defy omnipotent fury. All criticism helps (though I prefer the gushing praise :ROFLMAO:).

I loved the first sentence.
I loved the next paragraph.


Then things fell apart.
I'm going to be a little harsh.

The next paragraph begins the confusion.
Oh it's a good paragraph; however...

I say this is good, because it holds key elements and it's one of the few in the remaining paragraphs that, as a reader, I feel is justified and helps me understand the story.
One thing though. The reader is left to assume or imagine too much. I took the darkness to mean that it was so dark that there was no hint of light nor shadow; meaning that the only way to really know that he has weight and a full body is that he can feel himself with his hands. He then recalls being somewhere else. Then its unclear but I think he goes back to the dark place. But there is a sense that he might be suspended--possibly feels gravity but the last sentence is confusing.

Before that he indicates a lance through his soul. But seems to describe it as ominous iron slung across the shoulders, Now if he were a tailor I'd suspect he sews and presses garments and is carrying two irons one on each shoulder. However it seems that possibly it should say...It' is an ominous yoke of iron. However I can't discount that he might be pierced like a butterfly from shoulder to shoulder--except that it's the soul that is pierced and that image assumes that the writer means to include the body into what defines a soul.

There is a possibility that he can't really feel himself because his arms might be affected, there is only an illusion that he has a full body..

One problem that sticks out here is that there are too many images stacked one on the other and this continues through the rest of the piece. It needs cleaned up and perhaps some clarity such as if you mean a yoke of iron you might say a yoke of iron--however at this point I really don't know what it means it could be a lance like a pin in a butterfly collection..

What is important here is...I recall disembodiment, an untethered sensation. I was detached, floating.
I missed this on the first read--rather I conflated it with the darkness which I think was all wrong.
It's important because it helps understand that besides where he came from first he was once in one place and is now in another.

The next paragraph begins the world building and mood tweaking.


Nothing here helps the story or moves it forward--in fact this goes backwards and the scene description might be worked too much or more than necessary; however the key is that I don't think this paragraph matters--though I could be wrong.

The rest of the piece is a description of what might have happened to him until we reach the last line.


As it is this goes on too long for what it appears not to contain.

So for this reader what is important here is...

Hello darkness with your illusion that I have weight and all my appendages; a reprieve from that Purgatory of disembodied floating, but a mystery since last I recall I was sliced and diced by something that might have been a blender with a mode called 'atomize'. But now I am here all back together in some miracle or magic because, god forbid, this certainly can't be heaven. But where is here?

As a reader this is all I could find that I need to know.

So I guess the task is--go back through and find anything else you want the reader to know and find a shorter more concise way of handing it across to the reader--unless you are looking for a rather narrow audience. In that case if you leave it as it is, that will filter out the readers who you don't care to have read this.

Just my opinion.

Wonderful, @tinkerdan. I really appreciate the detail you have put into this reponse. I especially love your condensed paragraph beginning 'hello darkness... (my old friend?)'. Yes, that essentially captures it in a nutshell and shows what I still need to do whittle this down to something both coherent and lean. But it's a technique I am getting better at. Just this morning, I cut about 300 words out of a 2000 word chapter section that I only wrote last week. Re-reading it, it was just too fatty and pedestrian.

My issue seems to be impressionist beginnings, and actually conveying what I see to the reader. A week ago, I wouldn't have been keen to try and rehash 1.1.1. Now I am looking forward to doing so!

Hi,

I did read it carefully to the end, so I hope you don’t mind if I point out a couple of words which might need attention since they stuck out a bit.

You said your eyes were extruded, which to me means that they were pushed through a piece of shaped metal and came out a different shape, as in extruding aluminium window frames. It didn’t work for me.

Also, you used the word assume rather than assuming in ‘always assume that the forge was built’.

I had a couple of other issues, too.

I was thrown by your calling the place purgatory. My limited understanding of Christianity suggests that it was actually hell, since the time spent in purgatory is most definitely not endless. However it might be that you are presenting the theology of a different religion in a fictional universe, so I don’t know what to make of it. If this is a religion which you are inventing it would be helpful to people like me (people who care about that sort of detail) if you could somehow make that clear from the outset.

As for the opening as a whole, despite having thrown a whole load of words at me you gave me no reason to identify with or to like the main character, or even to sympathise with them. 1500 words in and I still knew nothing about them at all.

As I am not a publishing professional I don’t know what they are looking for in a manuscript, so it could be the next Booker prize winner for all I know. All I can tell you is how I reacted to it, and I’m afraid it isn’t good news. By the end of this segment I was tired of wading through the verbiage for so little reward. If I had picked this book up off a library shelf I would have put it back again and looked for something else. But I’ve done that with other Booker prize winners, too!

I think you have something here which could become something great, but you wore my patience out so quickly I would never read on long enough to find out. There is so much other stuff on offer in the market competing with your work that I don’t think you can afford to woo the reader gently. My inclination would be to grab ‘em by the short and curlies first and then show them just how good a writer you are! That’s up to you, however.

If you post any more of this chapter please notify me, I promise to read it. I would like an opportunity to be more positive about something you have spent so much time on, especially if it does fulfill its promise.

Sorry @Provincial that I didn't respond to your specific points previously. You clearly put a great deal of time into your analysis. I will consider an alternative to 'extruded', even though this is essentially what I was actually trying to convey.

This entire scene actually stemmed from a rather ghastly dream I had about some hellish old stone room and subsequent disembodied travails around some kind of complex. My use of the term 'purgatory' was intended to try and avoid the specificity of 'hell'. There is an underlying theme throughout this story about identity and origin and my intention is for it to be left vague at this point, so I am avoiding as many real-world references as I can.

A lot of the questions you have would ultimately be answered later in the story so the key for me, as you point out with your reaction, is to try and make it compelling enough for you, and others, to hang around to find out! It's a fine line.

This comes from a person more knowledgeable in movie language rather than book language.

The text itself is beautiful, you have a good way with words.
I know you probably have heard already that the text is a bit too abstract and hard to follow for a longer time.
It is painful but I've been taught that if something does not push the story forward it is not necessary. This is of course not always the case as you can have a text that builds a atmosphere and mood without pushing the story forward but if you linger too long on the building of atmosphere the reader will be bored and lose focus. In general it is a good tip to have in the back of your head.
The text as said is beautiful and is not necessarily wrong by itself but without a proper introduced context the reader is more confused and disorientated than the person you read about. Given the text is written with the main characters point of view it is vital that the reader has a anchor point in some aspect such as a proper introduction to our main character or the world. If you want to make a abstract start, that is fine but keep it much shorter and progress the story faster so your reader can get a hold of the story and become invested.

And thank you @IronTaurus (and welcome!). Like you, I am more familiar with film than book, based on my struggles to find something I want to read. I appreciate both the praise and the underlining of my need to inject focus, clarity and momentum into this opening chapter. I posted Chapter 1 of Act 2 previously (a different set of characters awakening) and had the same problem: too abstract, too airy and too hard to follow what was actually happening.
 
Sorry @Provincial that I didn't respond to your specific points previously. You clearly put a great deal of time into your analysis. I will consider an alternative to 'extruded', even though this is essentially what I was actually trying to convey.

For me, "extruded" actually works. Sure, it might not be the exact technical term, but that's what imagery is. As a metaphor, for me, it flies and lands, so to speak.
 

Similar threads


Back
Top