Fearful Odds (Re-Write, 1294 words)

Deke

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2021
Messages
82
Having been most displeased with the slow pacing of my book, I went back and did a re-write, a complete thrash and trash, tossed out everything I had and started over. I'm happy with this opening now and have slowly worked my way up to 15k words (hurray 1/10th of the way there). I feel on track, and thought I would submit for review to see what my fellow Chrons think of it.

Let me know what you think, not looking for any particular things this time just a general critique. Sorry it ran a little long, I didn't feel like I could cut it anywhere shorter and still be coherent, but it reads pretty quick and I don't write in an overly complicated manner.



Elizabeth tapped her nails on the polished armrest of her command chair. The seven members of her bridge crew were staring at her, anticipating her next move but she merely sat and watched the main bridge display showing the large, ungainly freighter plodding slowly through the asteroid field off frigates bow. Three times the freighter had refused to open a comm channel, three times the frigate had demanded they heave to and open communications. Elizabeth was growing impatient, and patience had never been her strong suit.

"Request they open a video channel, again, in the clear this time Miss Ying," Elizabeth said.

The raven haired communication officer merely nodded, tapping at her console and speaking into her headset. "Captain of the Astregen Star, this is the Terran Navy Frigate Horatius, you are ordered to heave to and open a communication channel at once, or risk being fired upon."

Silence was the only response, the freighter continued to plow on, heedless of the warship trailing her stern. Elizabeth ground her teeth. These merchant freighter crews could be insufferable at the best of times, and given this one’s location, deep inside Sol's Kuiper Belt, it was likely they were up to something nefarious. The freighters were often afraid to venture this deep into the asteroid belt for very long, for the belt was home to all manner of pirate crews and other unscrupulous characters looking for any chance to pillage and steal whatever they could get their grimy hands on.

Sighing, Elizabeth tapped the console on the arm of her command chair, opening up a video channel to her executive officer in the ship’s combat information center, or CIC. The impassive face of Commander Rashid Falana filled the screen. He had probably guessed her intentions, as he always seemed keenly capable of doing, but he waited for orders anyway. "Rashid, fire one ship to ship missile at him, maybe that will get his attention since he is clearly too distracted to speak to us at the moment. Disable the warhead if you will, I don't want to give him any reason to bill the Republic for free repairs," she said.

Falana merely nodded, looking over to his weapons officer and seeing the man was already opening one of the Hortius's missile doors and queuing up a missile. Elizabeth watched as the nimble little weapon streaked away from the top of the frigate on the main display, closing rapidly with the uncaring freighter. Point defense cannon fire erupted from multiple points on the freighters hull, the cannons swatting the missile away like a horse brushing off a fly, but the message was clear.

Ying cleared her throat and Elizabeth glanced over, idly twirling a finger through her curly brown hair. "Seems that got their attention Captain, they have sent a comm request. "Main screen please Miss Ying," Elizabeth said, a slight trace of her English accent seeping through as she spoke.

The red face of an obese, balding man flooded the screen, he let loose with a torrent of profanity-laden insults the moment the channel stabilized, spittle flying from his mouth.

Elizabeth glanced over to Ying and drew a finger across her throat. She cut the channel without further prompting. "Rude," Elizabeth spat, looking over to the still open side monitor showing Falana waiting patiently. "Two more missiles, lest this freighter jockey think we are in a mood to be abused in such a manner. And swing the railgun around to track him, that should get our point across," she said, checking her nails as she spoke. She sucked her teeth when she found her nail polish chipped and scrubbed at it, tsking all the while.

Two more missiles arced up and away from the Horatius, once again getting intercepted by the exploding point defense cannon fire, although the second missile exploded close enough to rattle the armored hull of the freighter with shrapnel. Elizabeth nodded as the last missile exploded, and looked over to the helmsman. "Mr. Klein, bring us up alongside that rat *******’s ship, close enough that he will have a hard time shooting any more missiles before they hit him," Elizabeth said.

Klein merely nodded, pushing forward on the frigates yoke and accelerating the nimble warship to overtake the freighter. Once they had closed to a suitable distance, Elizabeth looked over to Ying and raised an eyebrow. The bridge crew had been with the captain long enough to read her body language, and Ying opened the video channel back up. He wasn't so redfaced this time, in fact, the color had drained almost completely drained from his face as the gravity of his situation sunk in.

Elizabeth took a moment to study the man. He was stuffed into a ripped and torn captain’s chair, his bald head gleamed with sweat and two beady eyes shifted back and forth, no doubt to take in the sensor data coming in on the freighter’s various bridge monitors. Behind him, trash littered the floor and various unmanned crew stations. She thought he looked like some great wharf rat trying to flee a sinking ship with nowhere to go.

The freighter’s captain cleared his throat to speak, but Elizabeth cut him off, holding up a single finger and looking away from the main display to tap at her console once more, opening a channel and that she shared with the sweating freighter captain. The grey eyes, close-cropped hair, and chiseled jawline of a man in the green and black fatigues of the Terran Marine Corps filled the split display, and the captain’s eyes went wide.

"Major Hadrian, if you would be so kind as to assemble a boarding party for our guests here, I think it's time some of Terra's representatives and the crew of the Astragen Star had a little chat," Elizabeth said, her blue eyes twinkling with amusement. The Major said nothing, merely nodding and cutting the feed from his end. He would have a dropship out into the vacuum in minutes, and the Star's captain gulped nervously, a wolf smile creeping slowly onto his face as he dabbed at his sweating forehead with a dirty rag.

"Captain," he began, a nervous smile showing several black, rotting teeth. "There is no need for this, I would be happy to show you my manifest and comply with a full scan of my ship. We have nothing to hide after all," he said, spreading his hands wide.

"You, captain-" she paused, looking down at her console. "What was your name again?"

"Captain Gonthra, Flavious Gonthra. And who do I have the pleasure of speaking with today?"

"I am Elizabeth Alexander, Captain of the TRS Horatius, and I am done playing your little games, captain." she spat the rank contemptuously, as if it were some bitter fruit she had just tasted. "You will heave to, shut off your engines and your main reactor, safe your point defense guns and whatever missile batteries you have hidden away on that sorry excuse for a ship. If you so much as blink at my dropship or point anything larger than your little rat fingers at them, I will fill your ship full of holes and leave you for the pirates. You lurking around out here in the Kuiper Belt is more than enough probable cause for me to search your ship, and no I'm not giving you the chance to test out any of the little tricks you have in that freighter to fool customs agents." she said, her sickly sweet smile contrasting with the harsh tone she spoke in. "I haven't zeroed my railgun in three days, and I would dearly love a chance to calibrate it, so please, do something stupid."
 
I thought I'd be the first although that makes me a touch nervous

The Good

I think you have built a great world here- a skill I know you are good at from the pervious incarnation of this story. This time your captain is far less wooden and far more relatable, you have given her some personality, we the reader have been given a bit more exposition of her internal working. As usual again you are an effortless world builder who can create a scene with atmosphere.

Nitpicking

nefarious- I never think the word suits a scifi, that is personal preference although I might be off base there.
the warheads couldn't you just make them zero yield? Instead of disabled war heads- I think it would read cleaner. Again I might just be off base.

The Needs Working On...

The Earth navy seem like trigger happy jerks, unless you are opening on the villain. They read as self righteous bullies in my opinion. Also why is the freighter captain surprised at all ? He has been hailed and a few warning volleys no one is so thick as to take that long to figure out the gravity of the situation, that didn't read properly at all to me. His grin wouldn't be at all wolfish- that implies that he has some trick or he might win this situation, which does not seem to be your thrust unless you want me routing for the freighter?

I found the last paragraph I read led me to lose any affection I might have had for the captain at all she just seemed to be relishing her over powering advantage against under gunned ship way too much. It comes off as arrogant and self righteous.

Otherwise some other first draft issues that are common, I found a lot of the phrasing clunky, easily fixed in later edits.

Sigh and the most damning thing I have to say and please please forgive me, I liked you're previous opening better, even if this was more exciting.

Those are my observations respectfully yours Bedyak.
 
Thanks for posting that @Deke , I'm just writing to more or less second @bedyak -I liked the original beginning better, it seemed to have a nicer pace to me and the descriptions did a good job of setting the scene. As above, I found Lizzie un-likeable and was rooting for the freighter -was hoping fate would somehow equip him with an ability to give the bullying frigate and it's crew a comeuppance. I don't know if she is being set up as an anti-hero, she felt like a protagonist; I'm going to chance advice and suggest that if she is an anti-hero then it'd be good for her to have some sort of quirky flaw or display an act of kindness right from the gun (am far from an expert so def don't take that as a great idea!).
Silence was the only response, the freighter continued to plow on, heedless of the warship trailing her stern. Elizabeth ground her teeth. These merchant freighter crews could be insufferable at the best of times, and given this one’s location, deep inside Sol's Kuiper Belt, it was likely they were up to something nefarious. The freighters were often afraid to venture this deep into the asteroid belt for very long, for the belt was home to all manner of pirate crews and other unscrupulous characters looking for any chance to pillage and steal whatever they could get their grimy hands on.

There seemed to be a lot of background info for an opening too, possibly if the freighter captain said something nasty it could show some of this. I could tell there was definitely a cool story in the making and it read well. I thought there was some great description coming through, and would continue to read if it was published.

Fair play, best of luck
 
Thanks guys, I appreciate the honesty. I think I was trying to give Liz a really rough exterior too fast maybe? I don’t want her to come of as weak, but she certainly isn’t a bully, and I had not seen that at all. Needs some tweaking for sure. But the thoughtful/compassionate/playful sides of her do come out later, however first impressions matter.

I agree that the whole expression of Gonthra being surprised is flimsy at best, it was a weak spot I felt going in. And as far as the exposition, I felt it necessary to explain why they were harassing this particular freighter.

On the earth navy being a bunch of trigger happy jerks, there is a bit of truth to that. I don’t want them coming off as the rebel alliance from Star Wars you know? All good guys no flaws etc. They are the dominant power in the system, and behave as you would expect. I also don’t want them to come off as purely evil however, I want a lot of nuance in the book.

I’m interested to hear that you both preferred the first opening. Thank you for taking the time to read both by the way. Ive also gotten the same feedback from my critique partner lol, so I’m 0 for 3. I think once I finish up the rough draft, I’ll come back and try to figure out a way to use the first post as the opening chapter and just speed up what was a long slow drag towards the inciting incident and initial action. I’ve gotten so much good advice here, I have come to realize that the first draft does not need to be perfect, and it’s helped me relax and just write.

Thanks again for the feedback y’all.
 
Thanks guys, I appreciate the honesty. I think I was trying to give Liz a really rough exterior too fast maybe? I don’t want her to come of as weak, but she certainly isn’t a bully, and I had not seen that at all. Needs some tweaking for sure. But the thoughtful/compassionate/playful sides of her do come out later, however first impressions matter.

I agree that the whole expression of Gonthra being surprised is flimsy at best, it was a weak spot I felt going in. And as far as the exposition, I felt it necessary to explain why they were harassing this particular freighter.

On the earth navy being a bunch of trigger happy jerks, there is a bit of truth to that. I don’t want them coming off as the rebel alliance from Star Wars you know? All good guys no flaws etc. They are the dominant power in the system, and behave as you would expect. I also don’t want them to come off as purely evil however, I want a lot of nuance in the book.

I’m interested to hear that you both preferred the first opening. Thank you for taking the time to read both by the way. Ive also gotten the same feedback from my critique partner lol, so I’m 0 for 3. I think once I finish up the rough draft, I’ll come back and try to figure out a way to use the first post as the opening chapter and just speed up what was a long slow drag towards the inciting incident and initial action. I’ve gotten so much good advice here, I have come to realize that the first draft does not need to be perfect, and it’s helped me relax and just write.

Thanks again for the feedback y’all.
If you are trying to give her a tough exterior first give us (the reader) a sense of her internal working "she regretted her tone but earth regulations didn't allow her..yada yada" Maybe quoting the regulations? Also per maritime tradition you might have the captain doing her best to not have to launch at all (might come off Picard ish though) Alternately if she is in a new ship maybe have the freighter try something not realizing it is a new class of Frigate? Just suggestions...
 
If you are trying to give her a tough exterior first give us (the reader) a sense of her internal working "she regretted her tone but earth regulations didn't allow her..yada yada" Maybe quoting the regulations? Also per maritime tradition you might have the captain doing her best to not have to launch at all (might come off Picard ish though) Alternately if she is in a new ship maybe have the freighter try something not realizing it is a new class of Frigate? Just suggestions...

Hmm, maybe make her seem more annoyed than angry, like “ugh I have to waste my time dicking around with these annoying civilians instead of being out there hunting Martian warships”?
 
Hmm, maybe make her seem more annoyed than angry, like “ugh I have to waste my time dicking around with these annoying civilians instead of being out there hunting Martian warships”? that would communicate the intent better!
I think that's the right track yeah!
 
Hi Deke,

I can be really picky.

However, draw comfort from the fact I'm less able than yourself and have no right to be critical of my betters. These are just the opinions of an idiot and you must feel free to ignore them.

Remove
Comment
Suggest.

Having been most displeased with the slow pacing of my book, I went back and did a re-write, a complete thrash and trash, tossed out everything I had and started over. I'm happy with this opening now and have slowly worked my way up to 15k words (hurray 1/10th of the way there). I feel on track, and thought I would submit for review to see what my fellow Chrons think of it.

Let me know what you think, not looking for any particular things this time just a general critique. Sorry it ran a little long, I didn't feel like I could cut it anywhere shorter and still be coherent, but it reads pretty quick and I don't write in an overly complicated manner.


Elizabeth tapped her nails on the polished armrest of her command chair. The seven members of her bridge crew were staring at her, anticipating her next move but she merely sat and watched the main bridge display showing the large, ungainly freighter plodding moving slowly through the asteroid field off frigates bow. Three times the freighter had refused to open a comm channel, three times the frigate had demanded they heave to and open communications. Elizabeth was growing impatient, and patience had never been her strong suit.
Polished isn't needed and it too easily associates with the nails which I know is nonsense but for me it jars and led me down the wrong track.
Heave to is taking the sailing analogy too far for me. It's not the what is done to stop a space ship (push the tiler over etc.) and distracts from what it is - Not to mention would the five eyed beasts of planet Glodwand understand the phrase.

Elizabeth was getting pissed: patience had never been her strong suit.

"Request they open a video channel, again, in the clear(?) this time Miss Ying," Elizabeth said.

The raven haired communication officer merely nodded, tapping at her console and speaking into her headset. "Captain of the Astregen Star, this is the Terran Navy Frigate Horatius, you are ordered to heave to and open a communication channel at once, or risk being fired upon."
we will open fire.

Surely it wouldn't be a risk it would be factual. They need to realise this isn't a friendly chat anymore. Obviously a warning shot, but you wouldn't say that.

Silence was the only response, the freighter continued to plow on, heedless of the warship trailing her stern. Elizabeth ground her teeth. These merchant freighter crews could be insufferable at the best of times, and given this one’s location, deep inside Sol's Kuiper Belt, it was likely they were up to something nefarious. The freighters were often afraid to venture this deep into the asteroid belt for very long, for the belt was home to all manner of pirate crews and other unscrupulous characters looking for any chance to pillage and steal whatever they could get their grimy hands on.

and other unscrupulous characters - so basically more pirates then.
Sighing, Elizabeth tapped the console (again?) on the arm of her command chair, opening up a video channel to her executive officer in the ship’s combat information control center, or CIC. The impassive face of Commander Rashid Falana filled the screen. He had probably guessed her intentions, as he always seemed keenly capable of doing, but he waited for orders anyway. "Rashid, fire one ship to ship missile at him, maybe that will get his attention since he is clearly too distracted to speak to us at the moment. Disable the warhead if you will, I don't want to give him any reason to bill the Republic for free repairs," she said.
Control ccc C3 or whatever - its just that information is not what a gun gives out.
Falana merely nodded, looking over to his weapons officer and seeing the man was already opening one of the Hortius's missile doors and queuing up a missile. Elizabeth watched as the nimble little weapon streaked away from the top of the frigate on the main display, closing rapidly with the uncaring freighter. Point defense cannon fire erupted from multiple points on the freighters hull, the cannons swatting the missile away like a horse brushing off a fly, but the message was clear.

Ying cleared her throat and Elizabeth glanced over, idly twirling a finger through her curly brown hair. "Seems that got their attention Captain, they have sent a comm request. "Main screen please Miss Ying," Elizabeth said, a slight trace of her English accent seeping through as she spoke.
idly twirling a finger through her curly brown hair creates the wrong impression of a hard nailed (no pun) kick you in the groin battle hardened bitch.
The red face of an obese, balding man flooded the screen, he let loose with a torrent of profanity-laden insults the moment the channel stabilized, spittle flying from his mouth.

Elizabeth glanced over to Ying and drew a finger across her throat. She cut the channel without further prompting. "Rude," Elizabeth spat, looking over to the still open side monitor showing Falana waiting patiently. "Two more missiles, lest this freighter jockey think we are in a mood to be abused in such a manner. And swing the railgun around to track him, that should get our point across," she said, checking her nails as she spoke. She sucked her teeth when she found her nail polish chipped and scrubbed at it, tsking all the while. (see above)

Two more missiles arced up and away from the Horatius, once again getting intercepted by the exploding point defense cannon fire, although the second missile exploded close enough to rattle the armored hull of the freighter with shrapnel. Elizabeth nodded as the last missile exploded, and looked over to the helmsman. "Mr. Klein, bring us up alongside that rat *******’s ship, close enough that he will have a hard time shooting any more missiles before they hit him," Elizabeth said.

Klein merely nodded, pushing forward on the frigates yoke and accelerating the nimble warship to overtake the freighter. Once they had closed to a suitable distance, Elizabeth looked over to Ying and raised an eyebrow. The bridge crew had been with the captain long enough to read her body language, and Ying opened the video channel back up. He wasn't so redfaced this time, in fact, the color had drained almost completely drained from his face as the gravity of his situation sunk in.

Elizabeth took a moment to study the man. He was stuffed into a ripped and torn captain’s chair, his bald head gleamed with sweat and two beady eyes shifted back and forth, no doubt to take in the sensor data coming in on the freighter’s various bridge monitors. Behind him, trash littered the floor and various unmanned crew stations. She thought he looked like some great wharf rat trying to flee a sinking ship with nowhere to go.

The freighter’s captain cleared his throat to speak, but Elizabeth cut him off, holding up a single finger and looking away from the main display to tap at her console once more, opening a channel and that she shared with the sweating freighter captain (she wasn't in control previously when she Ying cut himoff - inconsistant). The grey eyes, close-cropped hair, and chiseled jawline of a man in the green and black fatigues of the Terran Marine Corps filled the split display, and the captain’s eyes went wide.
opening a channel and that she shared with : confusing
"Major Hadrian, if you would be so kind as to assemble a boarding party for our guests (they're not guests friends maybe) here, I think it's time some of Terra's representatives and the crew of the Astragen Star had a little chat," Elizabeth said, her blue eyes twinkling with amusement. The Major said nothing, merely nodding and cutting the feed from his end. He would have a dropship out into the vacuum in minutes, and the Star's captain gulped nervously, a wolf smile creeping slowly onto his face as he dabbed at his sweating forehead with a dirty rag.

"Captain," he began, a nervous smile showing several black, rotting teeth. "There is no need for this, I would be happy to show you my manifest and comply with a full scan of my ship. We have nothing to hide after all," he said, spreading his hands wide.

"You, captain-" she paused, looking down at her console. "What was your name again?"

"Captain Gonthra, Flavious Gonthra. And who do I have the pleasure of speaking with today?"

"I am Elizabeth Alexander, Captain of the TRS Horatius, and I am done playing your little games, captain." she spat the rank contemptuously, as if it were some bitter fruit she had just tasted. "You will heave to, shut off your engines and your main reactor, safe your point defense guns and whatever missile batteries you have hidden away on that sorry excuse for a ship. If you so much as blink at my dropship or point anything larger than your little rat fingers at them, I will fill your ship full of holes and leave you for the pirates. You lurking around out here in the Kuiper Belt is more than enough probable cause for me to search your ship, and no I'm not giving you the chance to test out any of the little tricks you have in that freighter to fool customs agents." she said, her sickly sweet smile contrasting with the harsh tone she spoke in. "I haven't zeroed my railgun in three days, and I would dearly love a chance to calibrate it, so please, do something stupid."
OK,

Apart from the nail filing and hair twirling I actually liked this. I'm reasoning she didn't get to be where she is by doing the sweet fluttering eyelash thing (Unless that is the case. In which case we need to have it spelt out).

So, she's a no messing, hard arsed, no nonesense, look at me the wrong way again you'll be needing a dentist type.
She can do the hair twirling in the bar after shift if that's required.

I don't think references to tall ships will be relavent to this type of story - but I could be wrong obviously - see openng remarks.

I'm interested and as I said I quite liked (the cut of your jib :sneaky:) it.

Hope I helped

Tein
 

Similar threads


Back
Top