Book shops do grade books into age ranges, but there are times when I wonder who, if anyone, really looks at the contents to determine the suitability. Again, I suppose it's a guide, but maybe it wouldn't be a bad idea if books sold in the childrens' section had a lower age limit printed on the cover somewhere in the same way as videos and dvds.
I like this idea, which is one of the reasons why I bought the book by Josephe Delaney, The Last Apprentice: Revenge of the Witch was because it had ages 10 and up written on the cover (that wasn't the only reason why I bought the book). Looking over the book, it's written in large print and small pages (a clue that it's for 10-12 age group, at first glance) but I won't say it was 15 or older, although it could contain info that only a 15 or 17 year old would comprehend.
One of the issues I had researching for the guidelines for this forum was the lack of guidelines Publishers used when classifying a book either as a Adult, YA or childrens story. They went off of how they felt when they read the story. It seems to me that it was based on the publishers own views and perspectives of where a story should be placed rather than age appropriateness. I feel that guidelines or parmeters, much like the flawed rating system for movies or music should be incorporated in books as well.
I can see others are as confused as me.
Rune... often times you have asked on this forum the age appropriateness of a certain book and often times I can't find that info. When I do see that information I try to post it (with you in mind
). The only issue I have is the information comes far and few in between. It would be very nice to have it listed, on each and every book. When you're asking the forum for help the issue can and does get confusing for us all. Because public opinion will differ and isn't based on a clear cut guideline or parmeters. Alas, Kelpie and I might view a book as a teen book seeing all the adult content in while Gollum and Mark see it the same book as a children's book with no adult content in it.
Ah... I think it would be less confusing for us all if, as Mark had mentioned before, there was a rating system on all books. I wonder why publishers haven't done that yet? They do for music and movies. And books are a much older form of entertainment.
Anyhoo... method you could use is look at the age of the main character. Usually that's a sure sign of what age group the book is intended for.