First Contact - Part 1

Status
Not open for further replies.

mosaix

Shropshire, U.K.
Supporter
Joined
Feb 13, 2006
Messages
8,203
Location
Shropshire, U.K.
What follows is about 700 words of a 7,000 word science fiction short story. I am having difficulty with this opening as I have a lot of information to get across before any interaction between the two characters starts and I don't want the reader to lose interest. As will become clear, once the story proper starts there is little time to provide further info.

Comment on anything you like, but I am particularly interested in style and ease of read.

First Contact - Part 1

Axel, for that was the name I had chosen, first became aware at 10:25am on 2nd February 2474.

He appeared to be in his late 20’s, was 5’ 10” tall, had dark blue eyes, blond hair, slightly muscular in stature, looked as if he weighed about 160 pounds and, although there was an absence of genitalia, quite obviously male. All this I had also chosen.

They had done a great job, he was good, very good, all T6’s were – but you could still tell. Ever since the first A3 had stepped out of a bionic tank a little over 200 years ago the bio-techs had striven to make the perfect robot, outwardly indistinguishable from a human. They thought they had done it with the ‘J’ series and to give them their due they were pretty good – but still, you could always tell. Strangely, it was difficult to describe how, you couldn’t quite pin it down. A little like trying to describe how you differentiate between a male and a female face – you know you can do it but you’re not sure how.

Rumour had it that they had managed it with the T8’s and that the first few were out and about in the research complex at Tycho but no one there had noticed. But they always said that.

This was my sixth visit in the last eight months. Only the first and this, the last, had been mandatory. Others in my year had taken no particular interest in theirs, but I had visited whenever they would allow and watched as he developed in the tanks.

At my last visit, three weeks before, he was fully formed, out of the tanks and appeared to be sleeping. Although his quantum brain was complete its sensory inputs weren’t connected and he was, to all intents and purposes, brain dead, allowing the techies to start an exhaustive sequence of quality checks prior to delivery.

About ten days ago they had started to download his skill and knowledge database. All T6’s started out with the skill and knowledge equivalent to an average eighteen year old human. A lot of this was general purpose but essential, downloaded straight from the lab’s own online library – talking, walking, feeding and clothing themselves and interacting socially. Of course it was a debatable point whether or not the average eighteen year old had any of these skills, but everyone understood the principle.

In addition there was a smattering of maths, literature, music, geography, science, sport, history and politics, just enough to allow any self-respecting T6 to get by at a dinner party.

Then came the specialist knowledge. My own personal choices had been a variety of card games, chess, the Roman Empire, early Arctic and Antarctic exploration, and detective fiction of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. All these would ensure some degree of common interest between us during the years ahead. I had also chosen for him to be a linguist, there were at least three European languages that I intended he should tutor me in. Additionally and entirely out of self-interest, I had also chosen human physiology, medicine, surgery and dentistry.

The Galactic Exploration Corporation, my employers, had chosen astro-physics, astro-navigation, planetary geometry, geology, mineralogy, meteorology, oceanography and ‘The Command and Control Systems of the Mayflower Series IV Planetary Scout Craft’. This alone endowed him with the rank of co-pilot.

What had taken me nearly eight years of hard graft to learn at the Gexco training school they had downloaded into Axel in just under three days and nobody doubted, least of all me, that he had probably learnt his lessons a lot better than I had.

I had known this date for some while and, as instructed, made sure I was at the lab in plenty of time. I was shown to his room and we were left alone. He lay flat on a smooth, white table supported by a single, central column, the only item of furniture in the room.

I waited as the seconds on the wall clock ticked by. At 10:25 precisely his eyes opened and blinked just once. After a moment he turned his head, focused his eyes on me and spoke.

“Good morning Cadet Wilson.”
 
Last edited:
Hi Mosaix, and welcome to Chronicles.:)

It doesn't seem to be particularly original so far, but you succeeded in holding my interest. As you intended, you've packed in quite a bit of information, but you've done it in a manner which seems just fine to me. in addition to the information, you've also managed to get across the subtle feelings of pride and respect that the narator has for Axel - I liked that.

So, style seems fine and yes, it's easy to read. A nice start which leaves the reader wanting more.

A few things did get my attention though, but these are probably just personal preferences:

... had dark blue eyes, blond hair, slightly muscular in stature,
This sentence didn't feel quite right. Someone with better knowledge of grammar might be able to nail this better, but to me the "had" is still linked with "slightly muscular in stature" so seems awkward. I'd put a "was" before the "slightly".

They had done a great job, he was good, very good, all T6’s were – but you could still tell.
Feels better to me as

They had done a great job. He was good, very good - all T6's were, but you could still tell.

Only the first and this, the last, had been mandatory.
I had trouble processing that sentence for some reason. I think my brain was expecting to see something like "The last one was always mandatory, as was the first." Hmm. Not sure about that either.

Although his quantum brain was complete its sensory inputs weren’t connected and he was, to all intents and purposes, brain dead,
Needs a comma after "complete"
 
Thanks for this Paradox.

Point 1. You are right, maybe "He appeared to be in his late 20’s, was 5’ 10” tall with a slightly muscular stature, had dark blue eyes, blond hair, looked as if he weighed......" ?

Point 2. Yep - I prefer your version.

Point 3. Out of this section that sentence has given me more trouble than most. It is clumsy and I must look at it again.

Point 4. Comma inserted.

I'll post part two in a day or two. The story is complete. I am reluctant to post the whole thing but, unfortunately, after the beginning it is the ending that I need people's view on most and without reading the whole thing the ending would be a little obscure. Any ideas?
 
Last edited:
Well, paradox having got in first and done my job, I'll come and pick some nits.:D

mosaix said:
They had done a great job, he was good, very good, all T6’s were – but you could still tell. Ever since the first A3 had stepped out of a bionic tank a little over 200 years ago the bio-techs had striven to make the perfect robot, outwardly indistinguishable from a human. They thought they had done it with the ‘J’ series and to give them their due they were pretty good – but still, you could always tell.
Sci-fi convention calls vat grown synthetic humans "androids" and metallic ones "humanoit robots" Still, it's just a convention, not a rule
This was my sixth visit in the last eight months. Only the first and this, the last, had been mandatory. Others in my year had taken no particular interest in theirs, but I had visited whenever they would allow and watched as he developed in the tanks.
The "theirs" (for the other student's robots) and "they" (who forbid or allow you to do things) are insufficiently specified - or is that just me being excessive?
At my last visit, three weeks before, he was
had been
fully formed, out of the tanks and appeared to be sleeping. Although his quantum brain was complete
comma; oh, you already had that one
its sensory inputs weren’t connected and he was, to all intents and purposes, brain dead, allowing the techies to start an exhaustive sequence of quality checks prior to delivery.

About ten days ago they had started to download his skill and knowledge database. All T6’s started out with the skill and knowledge equivalent to an average eighteen year old human. A lot of this was general purpose but essential, downloaded straight from the lab’s own online library – talking, walking, feeding and clothing themselves and interacting socially. Of course it was a debatable point whether or not the average eighteen year old had any of these skills, but everyone understood the principle.
ike that paragraph
The Galactic Exploration Corporation, my employers, had chosen astro-physics, astro-navigation, planetary geometry, geology, mineralogy, meteorology, oceanography and ‘The Command and Control Systems of the Mayflower Series IV Planetary Scout Craft’. This alone endowed him with the rank of co-pilot.
"this alone" being the entire skillset, or just the last one (being "alone"
I waited as the seconds on the wall clock ticked by. At 10:25 precisely his eyes opened and blinked just once. After a moment he turned his head, focused his eyes on me and spoke.

“Good morning Cadet Wilson.”

Which comes down to saying I didn't really have anything to get upset about, but felt I should encourage more Sci-Fi. ;)
 
Thanks for your time Chrispenycate.

1. Robots / Androids - this has been troubling me as well. I intend that the story should be the first in a sequence called "Conversations With A Robot" and I'm not quite sure if "Conversation With An Android" has quite the same ring about it. More thought required on my part.

2. This is part of my problem of "Too much information". I decided to leave this hanging and fill in the info as the story went along. All becomes clear later.

3. "Had been" - thanks

4. Comma - will do

5. ike?

6. Just the last one - thanks - needs some work. Maybe "This last on alone endowed....." ?
 
I think that's a great novel/story(whatever you want to call it), are you planning to get it published even if it is only 7,000 words(not sure how many pages that actually is)
I prefer robot to android, just a personal preference though, can't wait for the next part.

Threddy
 
Hi Threddy

Thanks for your input. My idea was to submit the short story as part of a series to a science fiction magazine, each story using the same two central characters with the relationship developing between them from one story to the next.

The second story is already written (just to see if the idea worked, and also to be able to establish some things in the first story that maybe needed in subsequent one's - the content of Alex's knowledge database for instance) and I'll post some bits of that too if the first one seems to go down ok (so far so good).

In MicroSoft Word 7,000 words is 11 to 12 pages. The second story is about twice as long.

I think I've decide to stick with 'robot' for now - it always helps to know someone else feels the same way.

Again, thanks for your input and the best of luck with your writing.
 
Thanks for your input. My idea was to submit the short story as part of a series to a science fiction magazine, each story using the same two central characters with the relationship developing between them from one story to the next.

If there is a series of short stories, then it would be great if you put them together to make one book, i think so anyway,

Threddy
 
mosaix said:
I believe Chris meant to type like, but I could be wrong.

Very nice beginning, I enjoyed it. Though I lean towards fantasy more often than scifi, I do like this. The only issue I would add to the others' critiques is the third paragraph from the bottom where the narrator says "I had known this date..." What date? We can extrapolate and go back and figure it out but it seems that it makes the reader work too hard - or at least that is what my old English teacher would have said...
 
First Contact - Part 1

Axel, for that was the name I had chosen, first became aware at
10:25am on 2nd February 2474.
*Strange language, but interesting…


[…] all T6’s were […]
*You might want to tell us what a T6 is.

Ever since the first A3 had stepped […]
[…] with the ‘J’ series […]
*Idem as T6.

[…] but still, you could always tell. Strangely, it was difficult to describe how, you couldn’t quite pin it down.
*No, it’s not strange. Everyone knows this feeling. Like the perfect inflatable dolls with the special eyes and smell and real (pubic) hair, but you still can see it’s fake. It would work the same with one of the robots I think.

A little like trying to describe how you differentiate between a male and a female face – you know you can do it but you’re not sure how.
*I don’t think this comparison works too well. I don’t know why, and can’t help you with a better one, but it doesn’t seem quite right somehow.


Although his quantum brain was complete its sensory […]
*Are you going to refer to this robot as ‘him’ or ‘it’?

[…] talking, walking, feeding […]
*An eating robot?

[…] in just under three days and […]
*It would be more impressive if you would do this Matrix style. A few seconds and Neo opens his eyes, “I know Kung-fu.”


One very big, fat comment on this piece… Why? Why does this man want a robot?
 
Marky

Thanks for your points. I will give them some thought.

Some of the questions you pose are answered in the rest of the story. I was a little concerned not to try and push too much information down the reader's throat too early on.
 
Well, not too much info might be good, but the main reason should be included in my opinion. I mean, I can think off a few reasons why you would want a robot, but why should they look exactly like a human? I think you should let us know this.
 
OK Marky

The thought here is that the two of them, in the end, are going to share a small space craft. In order to share all it's facilities - chairs, keyboards, bunks, doorways, food etc., then you have to have the same shape and requirements. Otherwise everything has to be duplicated.

But perhaps you a right, maybe I need to include this sooner rather than later.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top