Neo
Red Pixie Boot Wearer
- Joined
- Mar 12, 2001
- Messages
- 4,277
Let's see here. In JUST films we have seen Picard save Earth from the Borg. He did this with just his one starship. Plus time travel was involved, so the odds were against him all the way.
Next we see Picard and part of his crew save a civilization called the Baku using text book Federation standards. Picard follows the Prime Directive so closely that HE has to tell the Federation when THERE wrong. Talk about a true leader. Picard tells Admirals there wrong, plain and simple. And he's right.
Then there is Janeway. This lady gets promoted to Admiral before Picard for doing what? She got her crew home. Nice job lady, but I think episodes like "The Hunt" prove that if certain people hadn't taken matters into there own hands, that nice little ship would never had made it back.
So this lady makes questionable decisions. In some cases she is true to the Prime Directive like Picard, other times she is not. Really not. Most episodes of VOY had to do with her basically sticking her nose where it didn't belong. Her persistance to follow a man accused of guilt ended up getting him killed. If she had just backed off, he woul have lived.
How about Unimatrix Zero? Is it any of her damn concern if the Borg have there "dream world" taken away? No it's not, but let's get involved with other species and put the whole crew at risk to save a bunch of people already assimilated.
So who is Admiral first? Looks like in Nemesis Janeway will be. Not only will this crazy woman who uses Federation standardsonly when it suits her become admiral, she will also be giving ADVICE to our Captain Picard!
Sorry but when Jean Luc Picard calls up Catherine Janeway asking for advice, I'll personally hurl.
I sure wish Jeri Ryan would have been available for the guest spot in the upcoming movie. Some action between her and the newly widowed Worf would have been cool.
Next we see Picard and part of his crew save a civilization called the Baku using text book Federation standards. Picard follows the Prime Directive so closely that HE has to tell the Federation when THERE wrong. Talk about a true leader. Picard tells Admirals there wrong, plain and simple. And he's right.
Then there is Janeway. This lady gets promoted to Admiral before Picard for doing what? She got her crew home. Nice job lady, but I think episodes like "The Hunt" prove that if certain people hadn't taken matters into there own hands, that nice little ship would never had made it back.
So this lady makes questionable decisions. In some cases she is true to the Prime Directive like Picard, other times she is not. Really not. Most episodes of VOY had to do with her basically sticking her nose where it didn't belong. Her persistance to follow a man accused of guilt ended up getting him killed. If she had just backed off, he woul have lived.
How about Unimatrix Zero? Is it any of her damn concern if the Borg have there "dream world" taken away? No it's not, but let's get involved with other species and put the whole crew at risk to save a bunch of people already assimilated.
So who is Admiral first? Looks like in Nemesis Janeway will be. Not only will this crazy woman who uses Federation standardsonly when it suits her become admiral, she will also be giving ADVICE to our Captain Picard!
Sorry but when Jean Luc Picard calls up Catherine Janeway asking for advice, I'll personally hurl.
I sure wish Jeri Ryan would have been available for the guest spot in the upcoming movie. Some action between her and the newly widowed Worf would have been cool.
