Lonewolf89
Fear is the mind killer.
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2002
- Messages
- 1,527
It's amazing that someone who's supposedly shy around women could have so many girlfriends.
1.16 : Shuttlepod One.
- Thread starter Neo
- Start date
Good episode.
I guess it had to be a dream, but it didn't cross my mind for some reason.
My only problem would be Trip and Reed believing the Enterprise was destroyed after seeing the bay door with NX01 on it (use freeze-frame) Trip went around and around the ship in space dock, surely he can correctly identify that the other parts were from another alien vessel?
I'm not going to post the usual nits on this this week's episode, I've done my usual tour of the online reviews and frankly, I think the people who knock the show are getting desperate.
There were elements of Voyager that I didn't like, and Braga was responsible for those, but Enterprise seems to be pitched just right. It has the makings of a great series.
I guess it had to be a dream, but it didn't cross my mind for some reason.
My only problem would be Trip and Reed believing the Enterprise was destroyed after seeing the bay door with NX01 on it (use freeze-frame) Trip went around and around the ship in space dock, surely he can correctly identify that the other parts were from another alien vessel?
I'm not going to post the usual nits on this this week's episode, I've done my usual tour of the online reviews and frankly, I think the people who knock the show are getting desperate.
There were elements of Voyager that I didn't like, and Braga was responsible for those, but Enterprise seems to be pitched just right. It has the makings of a great series.
This is a really good episode. Showed two very different human characteristics:- Reed's calm fatalistic acceptance and Trip's desperate optimisism
I once saw a Hawker Hunter go down on landing. If I hadn't seen it prang then the wreckage could have been anything from a Jet Provost to a Jumbo. There were too few parts left, over the square mile, that could be identified at anything more than arms length.
In this case as far as they knew Enterprise was the only ship in the vicinity. The assumption was obvious
Actually I think this was quite reasonable.
I once saw a Hawker Hunter go down on landing. If I hadn't seen it prang then the wreckage could have been anything from a Jet Provost to a Jumbo. There were too few parts left, over the square mile, that could be identified at anything more than arms length.
In this case as far as they knew Enterprise was the only ship in the vicinity. The assumption was obvious
OK I'll accept that! They didn't, and they couldn't go any closer, so on balance it would be the only assumption they could reasonably make.
That leaves me with nothing left to criticise then!
That leaves me with nothing left to criticise then!
little smaug
Fire and Brimstone
- Joined
- May 30, 2002
- Messages
- 1,320
This episode was really funny, i loved the interaction between Trip and Malcolm (particularly because they are my favourite characters).
I was surprised that Malcolm had so many girlfriends, he seems so shy. I guess he has hidden depths.
And Malcolm likes T'Pol - how cute is that?!
It would be interesting if they got together, but i can't see that happening.
I was surprised that Malcolm had so many girlfriends, he seems so shy. I guess he has hidden depths.
And Malcolm likes T'Pol - how cute is that?!
It would be interesting if they got together, but i can't see that happening.