Harry Potter or Lord of the Rings?

[Neo]

Gt to be Lord of the RIngs

 

[Jessa]

yey! neo is a LOTR man!

 

[Hermione]

I liked Harry Potter!:rolly2:

 

[Legolas]

yaaa go Neo! Hermione - Duh your username is a bit of a clue! Did you not like LOTR at all? I liked HP to a certain degree...
:flash:

 

[LI_Tam]

How can you compare them...one is a childs movie...a highly excellent child movie, kinda like Toy Story, designed for children but adults can enjoy it. LOTR was intended for older audiences but they made the orcs blood black instead of read so it could be a PG and get more people into the cinema. They;re completely different...ok they're both about dealing with an evil Lord but ones set in a boarding school the other is a journey where danger is fought at every...step.

In shallow mode I might be able to say that Orlando Bloom almost tipped the scale towards LOTR...BUT HP had Sean Biggerstaff (Oliver Wood) who not only looked good had one knee-melting accent...

So all in all they're both excellent. Accept for the fact that the actor who played HP really wasn't that good, Ron and Hermione were excellent. And LOTR did have its moments where u were more concerned with ur bum ache than the plot...tho those moments were rare and far between.

CONCLUSION: THEY WERE BOTH EXCELLENT. THEY'RE TOO DIFFERENT TO SAY WHICH WAS BEST AS THE PLOTS WERE TOO DIFFERENT.

In my opinion anyway...


:rain:

 

[sidewinder]

lord of the rings

nuff said

 

[lisasg1]

I loved them Both, I preferred the LOTR movie, but I like the Harry Potter book better.
I have just started reading Lord of the Rings, and I'm almost positive that it will be my total fave by the end!

 

[sidewinder]

i am reading the LOTR books should be done in a few days.
(i have an unsually high rate of reading) i read the first LOTR book in about half a day

 

[lisasg1]

I would read mine faster, but it's huge and heavy, I have one massive book with all the parts, indexes, etc. all in one!

It is too heavy to lug around at school and stuff, so I can only read at home.

 

[Sinistra]

We have exactly the same poll in Harry Potter! LOL

 

[LI_Tam]

Sinistra: We have exactly the same poll in Harry Potter! LOL

Shaun: Well if its in the Harry Potter section its going to be biased towards Harry Potter so here it might be more unbiased. But merging them here might be good.

 

[lisasg1]

It would be good to merge the polls!

 

[LI_Tam]

The whole bias thing tho...

 

[lisasg1]

Yeah, I guess.