The Witch's Mirror (El espejo de la bruja, 1962)
Directed by Chano Urueta; written by Alfredo Ruanova and Carlos Enrique Taboada.
Those of us whose exposure to Mexican horror films of the late 1950's and early 1960's is limited to what we've seen on television, in poorly dubbed and edited versions, expect them to be silly and childish. Whether it be a masked wrestler, a clunky robot, a vampire with absurdly long fangs, or the outrageous monster in The Brainiac, there always seems to be some laughable element. It was with some surprise, then, that I found The Witch's Mirror to be an effective Gothic shocker.
The unexpected plot twists which make this film so interesting mean that any full discussion of it is inevitably going to be full of
****MAJOR SPOILERS****
After an irrelevant prologue, with a narrator telling us how evil witches are, while we see some sketches of demonic practices (possibly by Goya), we are quickly introduced to the witch and her mirror. She's a housekeeper of middle years, and staring into the mirror with her is her goddaughter, wife to the master of the house. The enchanted mirror reveals that her husband, a medical doctor, is going to murder her in order to marry another woman. The scenes of the images in the mirror, like all the special effects in this movie, are obviously simple and inexpensive, but usually work quite well. It seems that not even the witch can prevent the young woman's fate, and she accepts the poisoned glass of milk her husband offers her.
The movie becomes a typical tale of a vengeful ghost, as the murdered woman haunts the new wife. Although this part of the film is slow and familiar, it's also moody and often visually interesting. The story speeds up and goes in unexpected ways when the new wife is badly burned when her husband throws a lantern at the ghost, setting the room on fire. Suddenly we are in Eyes Without a Face territory, as the husband goes into full Mad Scientist mode, using the stolen corpses of young women in an attempt to restore his wife's features. There's a particularly gruesome plot twist when the doctor and his assistant break into a coffin, only to find that the woman inside it isn't dead, but only in a cataleptic state. Since she has beautiful hands, and his wife's hands were damaged in the fire, the doctor decides to take her to his secret lab anyway, and cut off her hands while she's still alive. This sequence gets fairly graphic for its time.
There are many more supernatural events to follow, building to a fast-moving climax. There are strange little details that add a touch of surrealism. (Why does the doctor have an owl in his laboratory? Why, near the end of the film, do we suddenly find out that the witch can change herself into a cat?) Although some of the special effects at the finish aren't very convincing, overall The Witch's Mirror is an intriguing chiller.