Super September - What literary offering are you currently reading?

A WINTER HAUNTING - Dan Simmons

Dan Simmons' work has so far been a mixed bag to me. I loved the first book of his that I read, 'Song of Kali', which could be described as a Western tourist's nghtmare in a Calcutta of zombie poets and occult thuggeries. His 'Hollow Man', atleast what I read of it, left me rather bored and this is the third book of his that I've read.

For a very long period of its length, AWH gave me the sinking feeling that it was going to be a very disappointing experience. Nearly up to halfways it wallows in explicit details of the doomed affair of the middle-aged white man protagonist writer/professor Dale Stewart with his young half-Injun student. Apart from this there are a few out-takes to the aspect of Dale driving out to the house of his long-dead childhood friend as a getaway sabbatical and some of the disjointed and derivative ghost sightings he has there.

At this point I was nearly ready to drop the book, but persistance paid off and the narrative took on a more interesting route with the connections being drawn between the events that took place. Among the points of interest there are explorations of the association of the canine (dog/wolf) species with death rituals across various myhtologies. Also at this point Simmons more skilfully guides us through a seamless route of past and present events in Dale's life and hints slyly that his sense of time and place may not be in sync with the rest of the world.

Nothing especially ambitious comes off but the rest of the book is atleast well-paced and on the whole a pretty decent read. Simmons could have done much better, because there is a good story at the core that someone like Stephen King (on a good day) would have taken to a significantly higher level. Besides the loose rambling of the first half, Simmons' talent for writing empathizable characters is far outstripped by his enthusiasm for the same. In that way Song of Kali probably succeeds the most because he doesn't feed us huge tasteless gobs of his lead characters' individual make-up. Also what rings false here is how Simmons expects us to ultimately sympathize with his lead character despite the latter coming off as a self-obsessed asshole with few redeeming characteristics.
 
Karsa Orlong said:
And, I promised I'd give my thoughts on Russell's The One Kingdom - I think it gets rather more stick than it deserves:
Wait untill you've read Isle Of Battles and this POV may change somewhat...:D

Seriously though Russell does have some interesting ideas and his quite a skillful writer wirth some beautiful prose on occasion. Unfortunately Book 2 Isle Of Battles tends to suffer from a somewhat meandering plot and is overly descriptive, the classic "middle book blues", that doesn't really help to progress the story all that much. Thankfully the final book Shadow Roads picks up the pace again but overall this was a dissapointing series for me. Why? Because I felt with the skill Sean has as a writer and the ideas he had for the series things could've been much more tightly edited into a single novel, perhaps 1.5 times the length of The One Knigdom and I think then he would've received a lot more positive reviews.

I know some members are loathe to "rank" books or series but if asked I'd give it about 6.5 stars out of 10, maybe 7 tops. If he had a single tome, I could quite easily seeing this rating 8 and over.

@Ravenus: Interesting comments, I've not read this offering yet. Whilst I didn't mind Simmon's Song Of Kali, it probably wouldn't have got into my Masterwork series. Overall I've not found Simmons to be anything special.
 
@Gollum:
To fully appreciate SoK I think you need to have a certain perspective on what it means to be in an utterly strange and exotic but also intimidating new country/region you've landed in.
 
ravenus said:
@Gollum:
To fully appreciate SoK I think you need to have a certain perspective on what it means to be in an utterly strange and exotic but also intimidating new country/region you've landed in.
Well as I've never been in that situation before you may well have a point there. I was probably a little harsh in saying that Simmons is nothing special. Song Of Kali is definitely an above average read I have no arguments there but it just didn't push my particular buttons. Then again it's always possible I may have missed the point....:rolleyes:
 
I just finished The Thousandfold Thought by R.Scott Bakker & The Lies of Locke Lamora by Scott Lynch both excellent reads and I just started Dead Beat by Jim Butcher gotta love the dresden files.
 
Finally! I'm on to The Day of the Dissonance (3rd in the Spellsinger series) which isn't to say I haven't enjoyed my previous books (I'm totally addicted to the Dresden files) but man I've had them for so long.
 
I can't remember if I posted in here or not...

I'm currently working on:

"The Prestige" by Christopher Priest - for the 2nd time, btw, trust me, it's one you have to read twice to 'get' everything *g*

"Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince" - which, so far, has bored me to tears - and I'm only about 2 chapters in. It'd better get better quick or I'm gonna stop.
 
The Fifth Elephant by Terry Pratchett although I have a sneaking suspicion i've read it before...
 
philoSCIFI said:
A quick read... Noam Chomsky's "Media Control"
Let us know if it's any good. I tried to read Chomsky several years ago, but he was too heavy. It might work better now, though.
 
I've stalled at the beginning of Sinner (Sara Douglass). Not sure if it's just too many other things on the go or a true lack of desire to continue, but I'm not ready to give up on it just yet.
 
elvet said:
I've stalled at the beginning of Sinner (Sara Douglass). Not sure if it's just too many other things on the go or a true lack of desire to continue, but I'm not ready to give up on it just yet.
Well, I do hope it's because you have too many other things to do. Please don't give up... :)
 
Just finished reading Stephen Baxter's Time Ships, an imagined sequel to HG Wells The Time Machine, commemorating 100 years since the original.

Granted it's not written by Wells but the way the book reads it could as easily have been. Having read both books I have no hesitation in stating that Baxter's "sequel" is better than the original. A large-scale visionary mind-bender dealing with the concept of multiple and divergent histories from the basis of Quantam Mechanics and the ways in which our orginal Time Traveller has apparently inadvertently altered the course of history or rather tranfigured it into a nonlinear state.

Baxter has an obvious understanding of scientific principles coupled with, for this somewhat lighlty read SF reader at least, an ability to explain these concepts in layman's terms whilst skillfully writing a yarn of time travel on a very grand and IMO ambitious scale indeed.

For those who like ratings, 8.5 stars out of 10. Recommended.

Now onto Vintage's Edition of Umberto Ecco's The Island Of The Day Before.
 
GOLLUM said:
Now onto Vintage's Edition of Umberto Ecco's The Island Of The Day Before.
What's this one like? I read The Name of the Rose and loved it, but I couldn't get into Fouchault's Pendulum (sp?), so I'm not sure what to think about Eco.
 
Now I've finished Matthew Stover's Blade of Tyshalle I'm starting on Adam Roberts' Salt.
 

Similar threads


Back
Top