I rented it out yesterday and watched it last night.
*************Possible spoilers??**************
For the most part I actually enjoyed it - though the first half hour or so seemed very sloppy in terms of scripting. How on earth did no one even mention "Law"??
But once the Enterprise actually reached Romulus everything much improved. I actually found myself feeling tense, enjoying the various levels of conflict (not to mention the actual conflict
), and liking small scripting touches that showed that the Enterprise crew were not dumb bimbos (the android switch when Picard is first on the Scimitar, for example).
But, having said that, "Star Trek: Nemesis" is really just a rehash of a number of features from earlier films - not to mention some LOTR thrown in for silver screen measure.
The whole story was essentially Khan revisited - especially the personal struggle and Spock elements in that - not to mention a little of Undiscovered Country and First Contact.
And the spearing scene was seen earlier in Fellowship of the Ring, with the Uruk-Hai leader that Aragorn decapitated after the death of Boromir - not to mention the whole ethos of the Romulans having terrible twins in the form of the Remans (this is the old chestnut of Sauron twisting Elves into Orcs - more so an imitation because of the Romulan appearance).
Another (little) thing was the lighting - although they obviously wanted moody and dark, we've grown up seeing good bright lighting on the Enterprise in general (certainly after the first season). Although that version was destroyed in "Generations", the contrast between the bridge on film and in the series is still a little disorientating - making them seem like two separate universes, rather than simply different ships.
I'm also expecting to see a special "extended release" - there were a couple of scenes that can only have been cut - the omission of all mention of Law for a start.
But, despite those niggles, so far it's possibly my favourite Next Gen film - so far, at least. I need to see "Generations" again, though.