Question on Janny Wurts' Curse of the Mistwraith (War of Light and Shadow)

I just read Curse of the Mistwraith. While I also found her writing style unusual, I didn't mind it and in fact enjoyed it. I really did want to enjoy the book, but I don't think I'll be reading any more. I just couldn't get past the basic notion that sticking a foreign king into a world ruled by councils (albeit corrupt ones) is a good thing, end of discussion. I know I should just accept it (aren't there great benovelent kings in all fantasy?) but something just never sat right and I couldn't quite buy it. Plus, it felt like the development and conflict of the two brothers was coming along well until the curse, then it just sort of left it to be: watch these two fight it out for 500 years. Maybe someday I'll pick up the next book and try it.

The whole king v. councils thing is a minor theme in the series. One of the Fellowship of Seven, Davien (also known as The Betrayer, for inciting the revolt that deposed the five Kings and the human nobility of Athera), opposed the idea of the Compact at its inception thousands of years before, as using "gifted" humans to protect the free wilds, interceding with the Paravians (regular humans couldn't or would lose their minds) and governing other humans would lead to resentment and class conflict (which of course it did). One of the themes that Wurts explores is that the councils (actually, it is the mayors) govern for only the benefit of themselves, and not the humanity under their control generally, and they spare no thought for the free wilds whatsoever, seeing them as "unused lands". Standing behind all of this is the fact that if humanity's presence on Athera threatens the survival of the Paravians or Athera itself, then the Fellowship of Seven is duty bound to destroy humanity (Davien didn't want to let humanity onto the planet in the first place).

As the series proceeds, you see very few kings (only one in fact) replaced to govern in accordance with the Compact, so the issue you cite is not one that need concern you. Having read all of the books, I strongly suspect that the final resolution of Athera's governance will not involve either high kings or councils. The mayors and councils remain in place, but one of the burgeoning means of governance is a theocracy based on a false religion, which gladly adopts all of the corruptness of the councils and oppresses humanity even more effectively.

The concerns you raise will not survive your reading of the next volume, Ships of Merior.
 
The concerns you raise will not survive your reading of the next volume, Ships of Merior.

Without meaning to pile on, rol, even money has it that you'll have forgotten ALL ABOUT the foreign kings vs. Councils concern by the end of Ships....I know I did!
 
Without meaning to pile on, rol, even money has it that you'll have forgotten ALL ABOUT the foreign kings vs. Councils concern by the end of Ships....I know I did!

That's a sucker bet, Grim! Ma Clansman didn't raise no suckers.
 
*Takes Clanny aside*

Er, the bet was directed toward rol, Clanny. I quoted you for reference, my good sir, kind of like establishing precedent....;)
 
*Takes Clanny aside*

Er, the bet was directed toward rol, Clanny. I quoted you for reference, my good sir, kind of like establishing precedent....;)

An aside? Aside of what? Beef? Pork? a house?

I'm hungry now. Should go check the fridge in the Asylum...
 
So would reading "Curse of the Mistwraith" be worth my time? I tried a few months ago but couldn't get past the first ten pages.

Also; the Recluce series is quite good.
 
Haven't read Recluce (Recluse? And by whom?), but would recommend sticking with Janny, Yuoa....things do speed up and stay that way.....
 
Ah yes, I'm with the program now. Modesitt is one of many in my "to be explored" list. At this rate, though, they may have to clone me (much to Clanny's chagrin!) in order for me to get thru it all.....

Give Janmy quite a few pages to set up her world, as there are literally thousands of pages that follow which build on this infrastructure. More direction/suggestion than that would be spoiling it.....
 
Yuoaman:

Ten pages ain't enough, Y. I heard one reviewer struggled with Wurts' writing style until she stopped trying to read it here and there in 15 minute chunks. Once she devoted some serious reading time (like the hour or two before bed), she really, really got into it. At first, she thought Wurts' style had improved, and then she flipped back to the beginning, and changed her mind about that. The style was the same, but the reviewer had adapted and changed, and grown to love it. It is not a light bite of fantasy, but rather a full, seven-course meal.

You have to give Wurts a real chance, because she has created something (to use Boaz's expression) "big and shiny", and it will change your perceptions as a reader, instead of merely entertain. Only the very best stuff does that. Once you give it a chance, and "get it", you will be hooked, well and good. Give yourself some decent blocks of time to get started.

FantasyLiteratur.net (Fantasy book reviews for lovers of excellent fantasy fiction) is a great site for reviews of fantasy books prepared by reviewers who actually read the books and appreciate literature (unlike a lot of the junk on Amazon), if I do say so myself. Here's a link to some reviews of Wurts' stuff, like Curse of the Mistwraith, To Ride Hell's Chasm (a one-shot novel, and a good read), and other books of the Wars and Light and Shadow series:

Janny Wurts | Fantasy Literature

Although I am one of the reviewers (A.B.), the rest who have read her stuff have agreed that it is virtually all 5-star, except one of my colleagues who gave her a 3-star for TRHC. The review of Curse of the Mistwraith by Greg Hersom is very, very recent, and he is a huge fan of big meaty fantasy, liking Martin, Gemmell, J.V. Jones, Abercrombie and the like.

I read the Magic of Recluce ages and ages ago (early 1990's), and quite enjoyed it, but never went further than that. Like Grim, it is in the "to be explored" category. I remember it having a fair bit of humour.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
D Grammar & Spelling 20
D Science & Nature 12
Dave Technology 6
J Stephen King 11
dgackst Writing Discussion 23

Similar threads


Back
Top