A plea on behalf of the semicolon.

So is it then true that in theory you could put a semicolon in front of every word (although this would look ridiculous)PostScript: ...in theory? (just asking questions to store away info to help my learning progress)
 
Oh, goodness, no. You only put a semicolon between two independent clauses -- which of necessity require at least two words, since they need both a subject and a verb -- and in certain circumstances in place of a serial comma (when you have parts of a list that contain internal punctuation).
 
Ooh so it would be like 'subject' Larry 'verb' is here 'semicolon' ; 'subject' Larry 'verb' is there 'semicolon' ; 'subject' Larry 'verb' is square.
Yes________No
 
I might get a little frustrating....if i do just let me know, I learn funny but when I finally get it, it is there forever.
 
I didnt pay much attention in English class (teachers ended up putting me to sleep with there voice) so I am stuck trying to teach myself everything.
 
Ooh so it would be like 'subject' Larry 'verb' is here 'semicolon' ; 'subject' Larry 'verb' is there 'semicolon' ; 'subject' Larry 'verb' is square.
Yes________No

Well, except that those three things probably don't all belong together in one sentence. Better examples would be:

Larry is here; however, he will be leaving tomorrow.
Larry is here; Larry is there; Larry is everywhere at once.
Larry is square; he has never quite managed to be circular.

And for the second way of using them, for separating parts of a list where there is already some internal punctuation:

These are the people who were at the party: my two cousins, Larry and Joe; my sixth-grade teacher, Mrs. Jones; my mother, father, and grandfather; my next-door neighbors, Sam and Mary; the old woman with the cat; the butcher, the baker, and the candlestick maker.

Without being able to use semicolons in this way, it would be impossible, for instance, to tell whether Larry and Joe are the names of your cousins, or Larry, Joe, and your cousins are four different people. (The same confusion would apply to Mrs. Jones: she might be your mother, your teacher, or a separate person altogether.)

But if you didn't have any of the internal commas ("my cousins, Larry and Joe"), you would not need the semicolons, and the list might read like this:

These are the people who were at the party: Larry, Joe, Mrs. Jones, Sam, Mary, my parents, my grandfather, the old woman with the cat, the butcher, the baker, and the candlestick maker.

(This has probably only managed to confuse you more, but that's the way it often is in the world of punctuation.)
 
Wow. I thought I was the only person using semi-colons these days. Thank goodness!

Long live the semi-colon! ;-)
 
And for the second way of using them, for separating parts of a list where there is already some internal punctuation:

These are the people who were at the party: my two cousins, Larry and Joe; my sixth-grade teacher, Mrs. Jones; my mother, father, and grandfather; my next-door neighbors, Sam and Mary; the old woman with the cat; the butcher, the baker, and the candlestick maker.

Before I saw this thread, I worried that I was overusing the delightful semi; unaware of the various rules, I implemented it by 'sound' (I'm hoping that makes sense).

I was the first year of GCSE students (1986 <sniff>) and the Leadership staff - Gods bless it - decided to combine Eng Lit and Eng Lang into one exam meaning I have one less GCSE. What has always troubled me more is that my parents - for example - were trained relentlessly in grammar and have an understanding of grammar that I do not. Hell, foreign students have a better grasp of our grammar because they are still drilled on it. How ironic that my school was called Bournemouth Grammar School.

Anyway, I wanted to thank Teresa above for showing me a new way to use semi-colons! I am delighted, and off to devise (cough... contrive) a way to get a punctuated list into one of my WIP.

(on a separate note, would works in progress be WIPs, WsIP or just WIP?)

Thank you again
 
...unaware of the various rules, I implemented it by 'sound' (I'm hoping that makes sense).
As has been said above, a semicolon can be seen to add a slightly longer pause than you'd get with a comma, so thinking of their effect in terms of how they make a sentence 'sound' is understandable.



(on a separate note, would works in progress be WIPs, WsIP or just WIP?)
I use WIPs or WiPs for workd in progress.
 
I use them! I think they're great, though perhaps I overuse them. I try to avoid more than one every two or three pages.
 
I use them! I think they're great, though perhaps I overuse them. I try to avoid more than one every two or three pages.



Use them as often as they're grammatically correct; there's nothing wrong with it. Sure, they tend to stick out like sore thumbs because they ARE so underused, but I feel they shouldn't be.


Quick-stops usually are underused, I feel. There's not many times I can recall hyphens being used either, to be honest.
 
Like Pyan, I am a great fan of ellipses and em-dashes, but I do consciously try to substitute semi-colons for some of those when it's appropriate; we must propagate the species.
 
In my opinion, if you don't know exactly how to use semicolons, don't use semicolons. Full stops get the job done without all the "am i doing it wrong?" worry.
 
Writers everythere!

Please do not forget the humble semicolon, it is such a useful punctuation mark; I have read whole books where not one was to be found. If this continues we may well see it disappear from English literature from sheer neglect!


I am a big fan of the colon and semicolon; I often use many of them in a sentence: makes life a lot bloody easier.
 
One thing I've noticed about myself after understanding how to use the semicolon is that I now tend to use it too often. I mean I get to the point where Rudyard Kipling would be mildly annoyed.
But that's what drafting's for, I suppose; half the semicolons I throw in get thrown back out in the end.
 
I do use semicolons, maybe sometimes more than I probably should, although half the time it is because Word is telling me to, which leaves me to wonder whether it is just trying to deceive me with its evil plan to mess up my manuscript :mad:
 
I use them a lot; in fact I suspect I use them not only when appropriate, but when I should be using a colon.
 
Unless you're introducing a list or an explanation/definition, I don't think there are many instances where you should use a colon rather than a semi. I use semi-colons a lot; I think I picked it up from Lord of the Rings as a child.
 

Similar threads


Back
Top