It's so infuriating. After years of hard work, he tries to show them just what a great piece it could be but no, Universal execs really have no taste. They would rather make remakes, like that Doom movie, but not take a chance on something spectacular? They even admitted to being impressed with what Del Toro presented to them.
But what I don't understand is why did Del Toro only went to Universal, why doesn't he try any other studio like New Line or Columbia Pictures or any others? Does Universal own movie rights to ATMOM?
One more thing to consider. Supposing if he did agree to PG-13 rating, than he still would have been able to release his preferred version on Blu-ray and DVDs, like many directors release their uncut versions later on. He could have went back and remastered the film.
Ugh! I was really hoping to see it get made. I'm fine with using my imagination and reading the book, but this story really begs for big screen adaption. He can always do Call of Cthulhu, I don't think that movie warrants an R rating, or those suggested by Tinsel and one more Shadow Out of Time.