As a moderator I explained to you our policy that we discourage those who ask for critiques from arguing with the critiquers. I've been cutting you a certain amount of slack on this up until now -- you are new here and still finding your feet -- but when a critique thread goes veering off in the wrong direction, after a certain point it becomes a moderator's obligation to point that out, and to ask that it stop. This has nothing to do with who is right and who is wrong, because that is quite beside the point.
And please don't define for me what is or is not arguing. It's not your call, and I do not wish to see this thread further derailed by an argument about that.
And please don't define for me what is or is not arguing. It's not your call, and I do not wish to see this thread further derailed by an argument about that.
