New wip: Heart's Desire (400 words)

Status
Not open for further replies.
I upgrade my rating to "please dont stop writing!!" or 4/5
I absolutely have to know more about Davy! He's so dreamy in a completely non-dreamy way. And while I am quick to guess that she would chose Davy as her Hearts Desire, I really REALLY want to know what he would pick.
 
Not much for me to critique, but I would like to point out that in the dialogue you should spell out the numbers, whilst in the narrative you can use just numbers. The reason is that so many people say numbers differently to each other. Some say, "One hundred sixty five," while some other could utter, "One sixty five," or even "one six five," and people would understand them.

I'd also like to say that it was a delight to read your prose and I hope you'll keep plugging the words cos you're so much better than many average writers like me.
 
Now the Heart's Desire is clearer this is better, excellent :) One thing is that as soon as Davy was introduced I had a picture of him as an old man - I think it's the yellow cigarette stains, I associate that with granddad-type smokers. Probably just my brain, but I didn't get that he was her age - I thought she had a weird crush on an old man! (I'm assuming she's relatively young). Very intriguing though!
 
tossed back his pale hair - for a sec I thought a 'pale hair' was a kind of lager.
also, maybe: Everything mine weren't - plump and pale and weak-looking.
whatever, WD.
 
Thanks, amw. What's wrong with skanky er sexy older men...?

And thanks J Riff. I got rid of the pale hair. I don't understand your point about the hands but I'd like to.
 
I imagined him as a lot older too. The way she describes herself and the way she looks at him is quite...Bella/Edwardish, but I trust you, Hex. I know yours will be better than that.

I like it, and look forward to more.
 
I agree with riff about liking the hands. I felt it was a brilliantly concise character development. His hands tell us a lot about him. Chewed nails - nervous or lack of confidence expressed externally. I expect he's quiet most of the time but goes off like a firecracker when his limits are surpassed. Gray around the knuckles - makes me think his health isn't the best because he's over worked and under-hygienated, one more profe he lives a hard life. -yellow stained, obviously a smoker but I pictured it in one place on one hand telling me that he's consitant in his habits and therefore probably really reliable. Or would be if his life was stable. The kind of guy to bring stablilty to his situation no matter what it was.
And it tells us a lot about her.
Everything mine weren't - she doesn't value what she has. Doesn't think she has a lot to offer. Worries about her self worth. Soft -not as calloused so whatever work she is doing its not in harsh environments. Probably a lot of dishes and laundry. Maybe some sewing. Plump- she feels she has waight issues, might be an emotional eater. Pale (was it? I'm posting from my phone and can't look back without loosing what I've typed)- doesn't get out much. Shy or under restrictive parents. As she's drinking with a couple of guys (albeit friends) its more likely to be shy than parents. Someone who only enjoys socializing with people she's already comfortable around.



That's why I liked it anyway.
 
Hee. Sorry, J Riff. I didn't notice the dash wasn't mine. We should start a dash appreciation club maybe.

Thank you, hope. It's good to see what people expect from the characters.

and thank you, RJM. Your comments are always excellent.

alc -- I appreciate your faith. Only time will tell if it is justified (muhahahahaha!).
 
Late arrival to the party, but here's my sixpennyworth:

#

I slipped Davy the Heart's Desire token along with his change from the bar. Going against the trend, I prefer the intrigue of not knowing what the Heart's desire is... On the cover of the book, it will tell us, won't it, because that's the title of the book.... I think. I'd read on to find out, and then the explanation is more satisfying. He shoved the coins into his pocket and leaned back against the saggy old seat, reaching for his pint with grimy fingers.Either way, this reads like the heart's desire token is left on the bar, because he only slipped the coins in his pocket. Did she put it in his hand, or on the bar itself? Maybe 'He shoved it all into his pocket and....etc'

I loved his hands -- chewed nails, grey around the knuckles, yellow cigarette stain between his fingers. Everything mine weren't, all plump and pale and weak-looking. Funnily enough, although correct, I keep reading this as though Davy's hands are all plump and weak-looking. It's only a nitpick, but would: 'I loved his hands -- chewed nails, grey around the knuckles, yellow cigarette stain between his fingers. Everything mine weren't. Plump and pale and weak-looking didn't compare to the strength his hands radiated.' be better? Okay, maybe not 'radiated', but I'm uncertain why she loves his hands, they sound pretty disgusting to me...

"How's school, Stasia?" he asked. Behind him, the vidscreen flashed, casting lights across the skanky tables, briefly coloured us all in something other than brown. Atmospheric, if a little awkward...

"Ah, you know." I pulled out the chair across from him, and sat. "They teach stuff." I wish I was still at school, I'd use that...

Normally I was more articulate.Delete this 'telling'. The idiotic mumbling does it so much better.

Brint laughed at my idiotic mumbling. "So nothing's changed. They did that when we were there." I'd consider deleting 'so nothing's changed'. His laugh said something, and although you've indicated it was at her idiotic mumbling, his reply tells us he heard what she said. Is he trying to be reflective or sarcastic? Or just a put-down? Maybe a 'Hah!' or a 'Yeah' would be better??

I was about to squash him -- I didn't have any difficulties with Brint -- when Davy looked up. His eyes were dark and brilliant. The lashes were absurdly long. Wasted on a boy, Mum said, but I didn't think so.

"Sure," he said. "But what are you learning?"

The way he said it made heat rush all over my skin, up across my face, over my cheeks. I'd leave it at skin...I couldn't find an answer quickly enough to hold his attention and he looked away he'd have to turn, you said it was behind him...from me to the vidscreen on the wall. It was showing the same old crap -- Councillor Corbus just before they guillotined him. The smooth grey walls of the execution chamber; his strange, hunched shoulder. The merciless light. I like the short sentences...

I didn't like seeing Corbus die. I watched, though. I always did. Davy and Brint looked as well, and -- like everyone else in the pub -- they were smiling.

Right after the blade came flashing down, the screens switched to the latest Heart's Desire winner -- some fat old guy who'd swapped the token for a massive car. Hah! Much better we find out here, what it is, doncha think? Now we know it's a token, and instantly see the value of what she slipped him. Almost all the winners were predictable and idiotic but at least the ones who chose cars were better than the sad old men who chose a beautiful girl. They ended up with some long-legged cliché three times as tall as they were and it always seemed like the girls were laughing at them.

After we'd heard about horsepower and leather seats for a predictable age, the stats came rolling up the screen:

Totals for the year so far
7 Fear
62 Fire
but only one Heart's Desire!

The vidscreen switched back to the old guy going on about his car.

"Do you think they have a script?" I said.

Brint tore his eyes away from the car. "What?"

"They always say the same thing. Blah blah horsepower, blah blah shiny paint -- it's as if they're all reading from a script."

"What are you talking about, Stas? The guy last year picked a 79 horsepower. This one's 165."I agree: I think you need to spell the numbers. It was okay on the screen, because you were reporting what was seen

I groaned. "Why is that interesting?"

Davy laughed and, infuriatingly, my brain shut down. Brint was still talking but I didn't hear him. Warm and aching with the long curve of Davy's mouth, I turned back to my drink and to watching him covertly. Not sure about the infuriatingly... she doesn't want to hear Brint, she just wants to soak up Davy... It's a small 'telling', so consider 'Davy Laughed. Brint was still talking etc'. She turned back. From where? I kinda thought Davy was in front of her, ergo she looks over his shoulder at the vid. No? And with the loss of verbs to define the warm and aching, we understand it, but it does stand out a little, as 'unusual'. I'm not sure that's a bad thing, but consider: 'The long curve of Davy's mouth made me warm and achey at the same time. I picked up my drink and went back to my favorite occupation: watching him covertly.'

He was thinner than he used to be, dirtier too since his mum had gone. The real change was his expression, the tightening of his jaw. It made him look sharp-edged, like you could cut yourself on him.

"What would you choose?" Brint asked me.

"What?"

"If you got a Heart's Desire."

I suppressed a moment of excitement -- or panic. Giving the Heart's Desire to Davy had been a gamble and I badly wanted it to pay off. Erm, bit of telling, removing some of the mystery about her. Does she think for a split-second that he saw her do it? No, she'd relax as soon as she thought it, because he'd have said something. We get that it's a gamble, really, because she did it surreptitiously, and now we're interested to see what happens when Davy does find it...

"Girls never get them."That's a great line - says so much by saying so little.

"How about that one -- Blanche, er... something a couple of years ago."

"Sutton," Davy said.

"Yeah. Blanche Sutton. She picked-" If she's interrupting him, it should be: She picked--" but I know you've used those before when perhaps a single das would be better. I'm never sure about these things, and I read all the stuff about N dashes and M dashes...

"Bet it wasn't a car."

"'course not. That would have been sensible. She picked a washing machine."

"Where did she put it?"

"I don't know, Stas. Maybe they gave her an extra room. But whose heart's desire is a washing machine?" All the time before, you've capitalised Heart's Desire, but here you've dropped it. I understand why, but if you want to emphasise the token, the competition and what she's given away, I'd think about capitalising it again...

I thought of Tuesdays when I heaved the washing down to the machine in the basement and then dragged the wet clothes up again, to hang on the line between our kitchen window and the Roberts's over the close. If, of course, the machine was working and I didn't have to take everything back up again unwashed for another week.

I shrugged. It wasn't a brilliant use of a Heart's Desire but I'd just given mine away, so who was I to judge?

"Maybe she had lots of kids," Davy said.

We both stared at him. Since his mum had gone, he'd been sleeping in the basement of his old block. The warden, Serg, was a nice enough guy and didn't throw him out much. Davy probably knew everything about washing machines now.

And that's it. As usual with your writing it's more nitpicking than anything. I was going to say something about capitalising Tuesdays, but I didn't. Someone more knowledgable will do that - I've no idea which is correct. Good writing as always. You bring over a 'reduced' state of affairs in so few words - I'm seeing 1984 here, without the totalitarian control. Well done.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top