Openings

1. Some years ago there was in the city of York a society of magicians. Nice. They met upon the third Wednesday Lost! Wednesdays are the most boring of days, as everyone knows. Anyone who chooses Wednesdays for anything of "importance" doesnt think they are that important after all. But not to seem Dayist, I"ll keep reading. of every month and read each other long, dull papers upon the history of English magic. ug, See!

They were gentleman-magicians, which is to say they had never harmed any one by magic -- nor ever done the slightest good. Ok well, that could be something. In fact, to own the truth, not one of these magicians had ever cast the smallest spell, nope. nor by magic caused one leaf to tremble upon a tree, made one mote of dust to alter its course or changed a single hair upon any one's head. Nice imagery but not enough to pull me back in. But, with this minor reservation, they enjoyed a reputation as some of the wisest and most magical gentlemen in Yorkshire.



2. I have never been what you'd call a crying man. out. who ever heard of a "crying man"?

My ex-wife said that my 'nonexistent emotional gradient' hey! nonexistant emotional gradient. pretty rare to find someone who admits to it. was the main reason she was leaving me probably not a lie,(as if the guy she met in her AA meetings was beside the point, probably still a factor. But she mightn't have noticed him at all if you had any more feeling than a dead fish. Do you have more feeling than a dead fish? you seem upset she's gone.). Christy said she supposed she could forgive me not crying at her father's funeral; she sounds like a sarcastic ***** are you sure your hurt she left you? I had only known him for six years and couldn't understand what a wonderful, giving man he had been (a Mustang convertible as a high school graduation present, for instance). Yeah sarcastic... But then, when I didn't cry at my own parents' funerals -- they died just two years apart, Dad of stomach cancer and Mom of a thunderclap heart attack while walking on a Florida beach -- she began to understand the nonexistent gradient thing. I 'was unable to feel my feelings' in AA-speak.
meh. bitter man is bitter. I'll give it a pass.


3. It's nothing. I hate nothing. Pass.



4. Nyx sold her womb who hasnt?



1. Jonathon Strange and Mr Norrell, Susanna Clarke

2. 11.22.63, Stephen King.

3. Moxyland, Lauren Buerkes.

4. God's War, Kameron Hurley.

5. The Warrior's Apprentice, Lois McMaster Bujold.

6. The Prisoner of Heaven, Carlos Ruiz Zafon

7. Before I Die, Jenny Downham

8. Among Others, Jo Walton.

9.The Holy Machine, Chris Beckett.

That's as far as I got before my brain rebelled and had me skim down to the answers.
blue where I checked out purple where I felt pulled in.

and yes. I frequently talk to characters while I read. Even more then while I write. I figure writting requires better listening skills from me than reading does. The words will be there after my rant when I'm reading, not so much when I'm writing.

Fun game. Will there be a round two?
 
Why did the first opening catch my interest? The York magicians sound so complacent that I just know that something has to shatter their smugness. I want to read about it.

The opening is written in an insider's slyly satirical voice, as if someone who knows that world from the inside out is letting me in on the joke. The mundane and overly detailed description adds to the effect (and to the suspense).

My questions are: Do these paragraphs appeal to other people for the same reasons, or for different reasons? Do those people who hated it enjoy genuine 18th or 19th century writing? Or is it simply not their sort of thing?
 
Last edited:
I think Mouse wrote all my comments for me.
Not spot on for the same reasons, but pretty darned close.
 
Only #1 and #7 hooked me. The rest I didn't care about or stumbled over clunky sentence structures.

I liked #1 because the author shows a controlled use of language. I felt like I could trust her.

Number 7 made me laugh out loud. I'm not the intended audience (this smacks of YA romance) but the voice is imaginative, modest, and very endearing. Probably wouldn't read it myself, but recognize the appeal of the character.
 

Similar threads


Back
Top