8000th... last time :)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jo Zebedee

Aliens vs Belfast.
Supporter
Joined
Oct 5, 2011
Messages
19,507
Location
blah - flags. So many flags.
This will be my last request for critique on the thread. Thanks to you guys, I'm in the position where I need to be a little less public in asking for help, although I'll still turn up and give the odd mauling or ten, and I might appear in the writing group.

So, a big thanks to everyone who has commented on my stuff, I think I abused the board terribly from time to time, but I wouldn't be anywhere near the writer I am now without this board which is, in my experience, by far the best crits board for sff around.

Anyway, I'll finish up where I started with a crit from Abendau (and thanks to Gary who's okay with me popping something up) and a little action scene. :) The pov character is having to get onto a planet without being picked up by security, so is being brought in over the desert where he has a rendezvous point. He doesn't like deserts... Have at it with your lovely teeth

Jo.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------


Kare scanned the sky for any pursuit, but there was nothing yet. Already the ship’s engines were whining and the hatch was closing. He darted across the sand, weaving, to the dunes. His feet slipped as he ran. He’d never get used to the desert. He sped up, feeling Farran’s impatience, his need for Kare to go faster and get into the safety zone so the ship could lift off.

He jumped a scrub of grass and dove for the dunes, hitting hard with his shoulder, but it was soft sand beneath. Not clutter-nest territory, thankfully. He was as close to the ship as when his father had left him as a child, hunched against the fence of the old yard. The sky filled with a familiar roar as the ship lifted off, replacing the dry desert air with the burnt smell of the engines. Kare coughed and turned his head away until the roar became distant and his teeth weren’t rattling. He looked up and the Roamer ship was already far in the distance. He watched, scanning, until he made out a volley of distant specks; their pursuers had picked Farran up. Most broke after the ship but one bore down on Kare’s position. Damn. Judging by the scanning equipment flashing along its fuselage it had to be a desert-seeker, designed to pick up movement.

He crouched on the sand, heart pounding, and crabbed his hand to the shield command. The air around him changed, becoming heavier with an artificial tang, but doing little to reduce his sense of being exposed. He told himself to calm down; locating him in his desert-equipment would be luck-defying. The ship approached, low in the sky, following a search trajectory, hazy through his shield’s field. If he stayed quiet and still there was nothing to worry about.

The sand moved in front of him, cracking and breaking, and he barely stopped himself scrambling back. Had he read the sand wrong – if it was a clutter-nest he was in trouble. F**k that; he was dead, either from the ship if he ran or the spider if he stayed. Carefully, he put his hand on the sand, checking. It was soft, not compacted. This shouldn’t be spider territory. Still the sand shifted and he watched, transfixed, as a snake emerged, its tongue flicking from side to side. A baroda, and a big one, too; as deadly as anything in the desert. Its red stripes practically had danger stencilled on them.

He stayed still, his attention shifting from the snake to the noise of the ship, coming closer then fading, closer then fading. The snake approached. Under Kare's hand the sand drummed a little, making his fingers tingle; the shield’s energy was drawing the snake. Kare’s mouth went dry, but he stayed still, telling himself the snake couldn’t get pass the force-field.

No, but it could burrow under the shield and come up within the shield’s parameter. Not good. It whipped across the sand to him.

“Go away, big girl,” he murmured. The ship had come closer again. The snake hissed. Its tongue flicked at the shield, probing. It pulled back and started to burrow.

Oh, s**t. Kare looked around, hoping for any sort of cover, but there was nothing but sand stretching in every direction.

The searching shipmoved away, and he killed his shield. He’d take his chances with the ship before the snake; at least they’d ask questions before they attacked. Maybe. He scrambled back as the sand broke, inches away from his right foot, and the snake emerged, fangs bared, ready to strike.

Kare slipped in the soft sand and went sprawling. The snake sprang forwards, quicker than he’d imagined. He yelled, managed to roll to the side, and fumbled for his blaster. He pulled it from the holster in one move.

The snake lunged for another attack. Kare got a shot off, but it was wild. His boot caught the serpent and its fangs sunk into the heavy material. He took aim, taking his time, even as the snake drew back again. He wouldn’t get another chance, not against its speed. He squeezed off a shot.

The snake flew through the air, tail snapping. Above, the ship had turned back, was coming into his sector. Kare hit the shield and flung himself flat. He didn’t dare breathe, sure they’d had long enough to fix his position. The engines roared closer. A bead of sweat trickled between his shoulder blades and he waited, sure they were above him, circling, ready to take him.

After an age, the sound of the ship grew more distant. He forced himself to wait a little longer, alert for movement in the sand, or the sound of ships. After several minutes he sat up. The ship was gone from the sky and the snake lay dead a few feet away. His breaths were jerky and small, making him dizzy, but they were there. He was alive.

He deactivated the shield and got to his feet, shaky as hell. Snakes were only one of the creatures to watch for. There were lizards, big and lumbering, so well camouflaged he’d be on them before he’d see them; the spiders with their buried nests, crusted and invisible, but thin as an egg. The number one cause of death in the desert, he remembered unhelpfully. He’d lost a fair number of soldiers over the years, drawn into traps by the tribes until the sand gave way and spilled them into a nest, to be taken and feasted on for months, before the remains of their body was used to line the pearl-pouch for the mother-spider.

Stop thinking about it and get going. He unclipped his direction-finder from his belt, activated it, and set out for the team waiting for him, taking his time to check the sand-cover; better late than dead.
 
He jumped a scrub of grass and dove for the dunes

NOOOO!! You're not American, and according to my sources it's a colloquialism even there. I'm not reading further until you agree to change it.

Congrats, by the way! :)
 
Already the ship’s engines were whining and the hatch was closing. <--two ings, if intentional then leave as is.

He sped up, feeling Farran’s impatience, his need for Kare to go faster and get into the safety zone so the ship could lift off. ,-- something felt off about this line but it could just be a style choice.

He scrambled back as the sand broke, inches away from his right foot, and the snake emerged, fangs bared, ready to strike.
I'm at this line and my poor exposed feet under my desk are itching now. A sign of good writing.

His breaths were jerky and small, making him dizzy, <-- slight snag on this line. is it too passive? hmmn. Could just be a style thing.

There were lizards, big and lumbering, so well camouflaged he’d be on them before he’d see them; <-- I'd rewrite this, the first bits good but after camouflaged the sentence loses something

he remembered unhelpfully. <-- delete this i think. Keeps the spiders line a lot stronger.

He’d lost a fair number of soldiers over the years, drawn into traps by the tribes until the sand gave way and spilled them into a nest, to be taken and feasted on for months, before the remains of their body was used to line the pearl-pouch for the mother-spider. <-- this is great until the before the remains line...I think it needs a fresh line instead of a comma/

-----------

I flew through that, very well writing, most of my quibbles are just style and prolly wrong anyways. Good job.
 
Great excerpt Springs! Now I'm looking forward to reading your books even more :)

I'm sure you can use the critiques for something else next mandatory time...you will probably write about 100 books in the next ten years, right?

Congrats on your success and 8000 posts
 
OK, I read on anyway. Very good, I thought. I caught "shipmoved" (how didn't the spell-checker pick that up?) and I wasn't sure about "hit the shield" towards the end -- I assume you mean he activated it, but it gives the feeling of it being already there (as in "hit the deck"). That's all I got, though -- otherwise it was clean and tense, very professional.
 
Dove is lovely and rhythmic... But might annoy me enough to change now. And shipmoved has, I think, been caused by the chrons software (but have made a note to check!) thankyou for the crit, I'll take clean, tense anf professional. The hit the shield was a change so I didn't repeat a word as I recall, so I'll look at tidying that up.

Ratsy, many thanks. I'm excited about them becoming real and can't wait to share my little world with people.

Barrett, sorry I got your feet tingling (well, sort of sorry) and thank you for the crit. Some of my sentences do ramble on so it's good to see which don't work.
 
Last edited:
I found this excerpt fast paced and exciting with lots to keep me engaged. Even on re-reading a couple of times I'd be hard pressed to find anything to criticise.

I particularly liked the strong identity of your POV character and the way he reacted to the dual challenge of enemy craft and lethal snake. It came across as a well-built world in which you and your character both move round confidently.

Itching to get my hands on the first book when it comes out. I want to be your very first sale!
 
I found this excerpt fast paced and exciting with lots to keep me engaged. Even on re-reading a couple of times I'd be hard pressed to find anything to criticise.

I particularly liked the strong identity of your POV character and the way he reacted to the dual challenge of enemy craft and lethal snake. It came across as a well-built world in which you and your character both move round confidently.

Itching to get my hands on the first book when it comes out. I want to be your very first sale!

You might have to beat my mum to the side... ;) thank you, I'm glad the pov character works - he's my older and still my favourite to write. :)

Well polished as usual. I 'dived' right into it.

Good luck with all your stuff.

Be sure to announce all titles and all release dates.

Thank you, I'm sure Gary will post lots but I'll also keep things up to date. :)
 
I didn't mind dove and to me it sounds a little better
 
On the cusp of a (nearly) life-long dream, springs, how exciting! Congratulations!!!

I have arranged my tbr e-book files so your premier book will be first in line, as soon as it is Kindle ready. This must be one of the most exciting times of your life, again congrats! (And of course, the excerpt above is wonderful!:)) CC
 
You're amazing, thank you. It feels very exciting. As some of the guys here know (as Alc put it they were the group supporting me through the birth), Abendau is very special to me, and, whilst I love all my books, this one means a lot. :eek:
 
Congrats and it's good stuff ;) The fact I read through it as shattered and frazzled as I am tonight is testament to how good it is.
 
Thanks, Anya, you're fab reading it so late.

Do you find him a different character in these later excerpts or is there still something of the younger character in him?
 
Nice and well up to the mark, with cool tension. Hard to do when a character is alone with only their thoughts for company, but done here. You're getting your well deserved agent attention and I might well be sniffing around for a signed copy too, if you ever make it to the shelves, which I think you will. You worked real hard to get up to scratch, good luck with it.
 
I've got deadlines. Writing at night when it is quiet is proving easier with the scripts. Novels I can write accompanied by screams. I think Kare is more chilled in some ways. He's less intense. His sense of humour is more developed. None of them are bad things. It would take a bigger snippet to tell just how different he is.
 
This will be my last request for critique on the thread. Thanks to you guys, I'm in the position where I need to be a little less public in asking for help, although I'll still turn up and give the odd mauling or ten, and I might appear in the writing group.

So, a big thanks to everyone who has commented on my stuff, I think I abused the board terribly from time to time, but I wouldn't be anywhere near the writer I am now without this board which is, in my experience, by far the best crits board for sff around.

Anyway, I'll finish up where I started with a crit from Abendau (and thanks to Gary who's okay with me popping something up) and a little action scene. :) The pov character is having to get onto a planet without being picked up by security, so is being brought in over the desert where he has a rendezvous point. He doesn't like deserts... Have at it with your lovely teeth

Jo.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

I'll miss reading your in-progress work, it's such a delight to watch you shape and reshape your characters. (Or how they shape and reshape you, which ever it is) But I'm more than delighted that we have caused you THIS kind of "grief" ;) it's all been your hard work of course, but it's nice to have been able to shout from the sidelines along the way.

He jumped a scrub of grass and dove for the dunes, hitting hard with his shoulder, but it was soft sand beneath. Not clutter-nest territory, thankfully. He was as close to the ship as when his father had left him as a child,
I like the nostalgia you sneak in here. Takes less than a heartbeat to read and really helps to shape the emotional context of the scene.
hunched against the fence of the old yard. The sky filled with a familiar roar as the ship lifted off, replacing the dry desert air with the burnt smell of the engines.
being a (Oh Thank God Former) Desert Dweller, I would prefer that you say the burnt engine smell was added to the deadly dry (God how I hate it) air. Standing next to a BBQ (yes I know that's not quite anything like an engine except that it billows heat and has a distinct smell) in the height of summer heat making hamburgers and hot dogs for birthday throngs, I can attest that Hot and Smell are only added to summer air, and not much "replaces" them for any length of time.
luck-defying.
LOVE IT!!
better late than dead.

Well written (as expected) over all, the action is tight and well paced (To hell with Kare, I can breath normal now that I'm writing and not reading ;) ) keeping One locked into the story and enabling character bonding. I super love that he chides himself for his negative line of thought, (so me) and pushes himself to move on. Shows the kind of tenacity and strength he has. The snake bit is brill, because it's never just one thing IRL and you manage the two tensions perfectly, the writing doesnt feel overwhelmed at all; as a fellow writer I'm impressed, as a reader I just gobble that stuff up without thinking.

The way in which he keeps his cool, makes it believable that he passes both tests, so it doesnt feel like he only made it by the skin of his teeth because he needs to go on; it really feels like he had to push himself to get through the situation and earned every little ragged gasp. I always love these things in your writings, the honest way you deal with your characters, never giving them a brake just because you want to see them through to the next chapter.
I've seen you do this for yourself as well, and I admire it even more there.
Keep on with being you, because its Your tenacity, Your drive, and Your relentless, tireless, give-up-less work that has brought you this far. We've just been in the stands screaming advice and cheering you on.
Good luck with everything!!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
Toby Frost Game of Thrones 26
AnRoinnUltra Promotions 0
The Judge Promotions 0
HareBrain Critiques 13
Mouse Critiques 23

Similar threads


Back
Top