I was really disappointed with the third of Pullman's trilogy. A complete mess as far as I was concerned.
Ditto. Book one was brilliant, book two was fine, and then it completely nose-dived.I was really disappointed with the third of Pullman's trilogy. A complete mess as far as I was concerned.
A problem with the alliterative titles -- which I also thought were great fun -- is that newbies to the site didn't always realise what the threads were about. Not only does that potentially exclude newcomers to the Chrons, which is the opposite of what we should be doing, it also led to some newbies opening threads of the-what-are-reading kind that then had to be dealt with. Which meant some mods had to break off eating the chocolate hob-nobs to do some work. Faced with that terrible option, there was no contest. Alliteration altogether and absolutely annihiliated.
The intestines aren't worrying me, oddly enough since I'm terribly squeamish. I don't know if you saw my replies to ratsy about it last month@TJ I tried to read The Briar King a few months ago, but it had too many intestines and I gave up. I'll be interested to hear what you thought of it.
andI got off to a bad start with it, I have to say, with the rather boring and repetitious "Prelude" which is set hundreds of years in the past, so has nothing to do with the characters of the main story but seems shoved in there simply to start the book with lots of fighting, then the "Prologue" with the young girls which could be omitted without any loss at all, then the first five chapters with four different POV characters, none of whom are connected, and which includes a dream sequence, of all things, solely designed to get in fighting which isn't otherwise there. And don't get me started on rebellious, feisty, teenage Princesses...
As I'm nearing the end I'm looking a little more favourably on it, as the plot has come together, and not all the characters are still completely one-note ciphers even if they started out like that. But for my money if he'd written the book just about Aspar and Stephen and dumped everyone else it would have been a lot stronger and less throw-it-across-the-room-ish. As to his writing, it's not awful but again it's not good enough to bring everything alive for me.To be fair to him, I can see (now I've got further into the book) that he is reaching past the cliché to show character development which will presumably take place in the next book. And Aspar is better drawn, and I am enjoying Stephen's storyline. There's just not quite enough there for me, though.
Thread starter | Similar threads | Forum | Replies | Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
October Reading Thread | Book Discussion | 196 | ||
October Reading Thread | Book Discussion | 203 | ||
October 2022 Reading Thread | Book Discussion | 191 | ||
October 2021 Reading Discussion | Book Discussion | 332 | ||
October Reading Thread | Book Discussion | 181 |