Good Science and Bad Science And Lack Thereof In Science Fiction Films and TV Series

What with various military sites around the world, defended by anti-aircraft missiles.
I wonder if Santa's sleigh comes fitted anti-radar chaff and heat flares?
 
What with various military sites around the world, defended by anti-aircraft missiles.
I wonder if Santa's sleigh comes fitted anti-radar chaff and heat flares?

Well, considering that to do all the deliveries he has to do, Santa's sleigh has to travel at 650 miles per second and his sleigh (with cargo) has a mass of approximately 350,000 tons. I suggest that any SAM currently in deployment can't hit it, and if it does the sleigh (over 3 times as massive as USS Nimitz) is unlikely to be affected much. :)
 
Everyone knows Santa lives in South America now, all gifts come from the Amazon these days.
 
Missile to the Moon 1958 . The implausibilities in this one are the stuff of legend . Astronauts from earth land on the moon and find a civilization of women living in aired Caverns below the ground, giant spiders, and Rock creatures. :D
 
Missile to the Moon 1958 . The implausibilities in this one are the stuff of legend . Astronauts from earth land on the moon and find a civilization of women living in aired Caverns below the ground, giant spiders, and Rock creatures. :D

I was particularly struck, while watching that one, by the number of flaming torches in sconces around the place. For a society running out of breathable air it seemed a bit of interior decoration that was short-sighted to say the least.
 
I was particularly struck, while watching that one, by the number of flaming torches in sconces around the place. For a society running out of breathable air it seemed a bit of interior decoration that was short-sighted to say the least.

I forgot about that.:D
 
Missile to the Moon 1958 . The implausibilities in this one are the stuff of legend . Astronauts from earth land on the moon and find a civilization of women living in aired Caverns below the ground, giant spiders, and Rock creatures. :D

On the other hand, there is a certain charm in some of these old, completely ridiculous scenarios. I've long toyed with the idea of doing a steampunk novel where the characters travel to the moon on a steam train. Part of the joy of such works is the humour of old notions versus reality. Exaggerating the madness of the old is a great source of humour.
 
On the other hand, there is a certain charm in some of these old, completely ridiculous scenarios. I've long toyed with the idea of doing a steampunk novel where the characters travel to the moon on a steam train. Part of the joy of such works is the humour of old notions versus reality. Exaggerating the madness of the old is a great source of humour.

Please, write that story.:D:cool:
 
Star Wars uses the term light speed to designate Hyperspace.:unsure:
 
As much as I like Robinson Crusoe on Mars , even in 1964 when the tim was made , Science already knew the air was too thin for life and protection from ultraviolet radiation. :)
 
Yes It's the same with the term light year.
People hear the year part and think it's a unit of time not distance.
 
Hours and minutes are a unit of time but I regularly hear people talk about such and such a place being X hours or Y minutes away. The need to go on to then tell the listener that the speaker assumes the distance will be travelled in a vehicle being driven safely and in accordance with the roads' speed limits isn't needed in most conversation. It is assumed from context. We all speak in a vernacular and idiomatically. We're not walking text books written by grammarians.

It's not too difficult to assume that people in SF don't spend time burdening each other with pettifogging details that would be, in context, bloody obvious to each other. (Well they do, often, but it really stands out when characters infodump at each other.)

In everyday life I wouldn't say to someone on foot asking me how far it is to the nearest post office - "It is 1.25 Km in a north easterly direction and, assuming you are travelling by foot, are reasonably fit, and don't suffer from any kind of mobility impairment not obvious to the naked eye, it should take you (at an average walking speed of 5 Km P H) a quarter of an hour to reach it if you don't stop to talk to anyone on the way."

No. I just say, "It's about 15 minutes down the road. Opposite the pub."

Similarly if they were in a car I would say ""It's a couple of minutes that way. Opposite the pub."

I wouldn't go on to give the driver detailed instructions about which side of the road to drive on and how to negotiate the pedestrian crossing he will encounter on the way.

Maybe, given the hand waviness of so much of the science in Star Wars (the variable speed of light in The Farce Awakens being one such example), ships have to get to light speed before they can enter hyperspace and, while in hyperspace, the measurement of time is best expressed in units of distance. Luke and Obi Wan would have known this without having it explained to them.
 
I missed that one. :unsure:

I've seen a justification of that particular line, and it amkes some kind of sense. Simply that hyperspace is distinctly different from realspace, and one of the differences is that there are many routes between two points; one can assume that the shorter ones are more difficult and dangerous, needing a good pilot and really good navigational equipment. Han Solo took a shorter route than just about anyone else.
 
What annoys me is when people use misuse the word "Galaxy", as in "He comes from another galaxy" when star would be more accurate.
As if our own weren't big enough, as if it's just a stroll around the corner.
Most people have no idea just how mind bogglelingly vast our universe is.
It's about 2.5 million light years to the nearest galaxy, the light that we see it by started on it's journey well before the first humans looked up at the night sky, and wondered what all the points of light were!
The nearest star is a mere 4.2 light years away.
But even this is roughly something like 25,000,000,000,000 miles away!
Even I have a job getting my head around that!
 
Last edited:

Similar threads


Back
Top