SG 4.0 Switched Character and Timeline opening (900 words)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Phyrebrat

www.beanwriting.com
Supporter
Joined
Feb 13, 2011
Messages
6,163
Location
In your bedroom wardrobe...
I'm having a bit of a crisis of faith here. Willie Weekes is my MC, and this is his opening. It is softer than the original which finds him waking in the middle of the night to find himself covered in feathers. This one is more mundane and voicey whereas his initial introduction was more actiony.

The previous 1030 words have introduced the second-main character, Kate, his best friend. She's just found a skinned man hanging upside down, naked, from the chandelier in the dining room of her well-appointed home in Lowe.

In draft 3, the story opened in 1178 and now I won't introduce that timeline till chapter 2 or 3. I want it to come out of the blue, and I didn't want the story to open up in the Middle Ages in case it suggests to the reader that the main story will be set in that period. The story's main arc is set in present day.

The crisis of faith I'm having is whether it is a bad idea to start with Kate instead of Willie, but her chapter opening is just more hooky (and his feathers-in-the-bed scene happens much later now) and forms a nice psychopomp element. Not to mention her house sits on the eponymous sour ground.

I'll paste Willie's scene here but I'm not really looking for a line edit etc, but just some general comments on whether it should be the opener. I hope that makes sense.

Thanks. (oh, and there's some slight language...)

So...

The thundercloud over Willie’s head was nowhere near as black as the one in his soul. Three-hour workshops trying to engage abhorrent year 11 students in art (a subject those idiot creatures chose themselves) was as tricky as catching eels with chopsticks - much better to use a chainsaw or rivet gun. He’d left the college as soon as the workshop ended instead of chatting with the faculty, and the remaining students who hadn’t been kicked out (just how many crudely drawn dick pics could one class produce? They weren’t even anatomically correct).

To Willie the issue was clear: Pretty much everywhere you looked today someone - whatever age - was taking something that didn’t belong to them. With the students, it was a simple case of turning up to class with an ‘okay, what have you got for me’ attitude. Maybe school was where we cut our teeth and learnt to take from others. The image of his oil canvas Entitled Appropriation flickered across his mind.

He stomped through the light but annoying rain - it’s f****** July - with his toes curled up inside his shoes to avoid the wetness coming in from the worn soles. On the pavement, as if the flagstones were impressionist canvases, a slick veneer flickered with orange and blue reflections. He looked up to see police and utility vans clustered ahead. That’s the gallery!

He picked up his pace; please not a fire. He’d no contents insurance - he’d given up trying to sort that out when explaining that his studio and gallery were his home and his workplace. He’d had a strong sense of being misled, to pay a higher premium, so he’d put the issue aside, and not thought about it since. That was six years ago.

Gas, electric, water and police. All those agencies were represented outside the parade of shops that included his gallery. And two fire engines.
No ambulances; no one hurt, then.
Even as he walked into the area it was being cordoned off. Two curmudgeonly looking men - the kind you’d see on the side of a Toby Jug, minus the smile - were coiling bumblebee hazard tape around lampposts and wooden A-frames. Whatever had happened, had just happened.
The pavement was blocked by a tall red and white panel that seemed to defy gravity until he saw a corned-beef skinned policeman behind was propping it up. He was about to ask the man, who looked of similar age to him what had happened.
‘Not this way, son,’ the policeman said, shaking his head. He had a drip on the end of his nose that Willie hoped was rain.
‘Son?’ Willie aimed for good-natured breeziness. ‘There’s a compliment!’
‘The road’s closed,’
‘So how will I get home, officer?’
‘Go round.’ It was an impatient bark.
This muppet’s a policeman? God help us. ‘I live there!’ Willie said, peevishly, more disappointed with himself for wasting time trying to make pleasantries with such a thankless functionary. He jabbed a finger at the area behind the clutter of vans and fire engines.
The policeman’s manner switched. ‘Oh, Mr Weekes?’
‘Yes.’
The officer stepped away from the flimsy barrier, catching it as it dropped, and gestured for him to pass.
Willie thanked him with a cursory nod and scooted through, weaving between the muddle of municipal personnel.
Now he was at a better angle, and the nearest fire engine was out the way, he saw the gallery building - all three storeys were draped in a dirty white tarpaulin that appeared to breathe languidly in the light breeze.
‘Hey!’ Willie shouted, hurrying towards his home. ‘HEY! Can someone tell me what’s going on?’
Two insectoid men in white coveralls and odd breathing apparatus turned to see him. Why were they in isolation if everyone else milling around wasn’t?
‘What’s going on?’
The pair of them looked at each other idiotically and just as Willie was deciding whether to rip their hooded masks off, or push past them, PC Charisma showed up.
‘Sorry, Mr Weekes, please come with me,’ he said and tried to usher Willie aside to what looked like a country fayre tea and cake tent. Inside a short woman with a long face was berating another jobsworth about something. She looked familiar.
‘Why are you fumigating my gallery?’ Willie asked, too aggressively, trying to ignore the water drop which still hung from Charisma’s nose. As he said it he noticed the short woman’s argument peter out and her eyes bearing on him.
‘Your....er, the property is not being fumigated...’
‘What are you doing, then?’
‘It’s not the Met who—’
The short woman interrupted him. ‘Mr Weekes? I’m Nancy Cooke from Look! London. I wonder if you’d have time for a quick interview?’
Ah, yes, it was that angry journalist from TV. He knew she’d looked familiar, and judging by the argument she’d been having with the jobsworth, she was just as pugnacious offscreen as on.
‘I don’t even know what’s going on - you’re far more on the ball than me,’ Willie said.
She didn’t dance around; ‘A sinkhole has swallowed your property,’ she said.
Reeling, he was only vaguely aware of her being forcefully escorted away.
What’s a sinkhole, again? he thought, then passed out.

 
Last edited:
What I like about this is it moves quickly; and it's over before you want it to be.

Oh and there's a comma missing; but I'm sure someone else will point out where.

I want to read more--Umm--Now!
 
It's brilliant, you swine, you.

There are the odd couple of punctuation errors in there - just typos, watch out for them - and I think you overdo the italicised internal dialogue in the first paragraph. To me, both the line about the rivet gun and the dick pics wouldn't be italicised as we're already in his voice.
 
I haven't seen your prevoius drafts, so I can't compare, but this one works nicely as an opener. Its pace is good, and it's well written.
 
This is really well written and is plenty hooky. Nothing to worry about. I only have a few comments...

1. Why the name Willie Weekes for a main character? It didn't strike me as a name that adorns itself to the reader unless there is some comic reason for it. Then again, I don't know what the story is really about.

2. The first paragraph seems awkward. The use of parentheses seems odd where commas should serve. I find them in technical documents, but rarely or ever see them in literature. Yet, here they are twice in the same paragraph.

The internal dialog is mixed with the narration and seems choppy. The last internal dialog might be expanded to include the narration in the parentheses as a stand-alone sentence.

Grammar issue:

Second paragraph - "To Willie the issue was clear: Pretty..." Never capitalize the word after a colon. I'd probably consider changing the two hyphens to commas, too, but someone else can weigh in on that.
 
I won't do a nitpick as you're just wanting an overall impression, though there are some punctuation issues, but I agree you've rather gone overboard with all the internal italicised thoughts, which perversely acted to distance me from the writing and the story. I'd suggest putting a speedy end to the pandemic, which would help improve the flow of the extract.

Anyway, I think you're right to start SG in the present day, and then jump back to the historical episodes as you go along -- that's a good call. This scene could certainly work as an opening, though I have to confess I'm not personally a fan of books which start with a man whingeing about modern life (and though I got the theme of "taking" I'm not convinced a child's sense of entitlement is of the same kind and degree, so I'd want something a little stronger in relevance). Plus although you've not greatly dawdled, for my taste the scene could do with moving a tad quicker, so I'd be at it with pruning shears. For instance to my mind some of the imagery, while as interesting as ever, isn't helping the pace, especially not when it should be moving up a gear with the sight of the coppers milling around where his gallery should be, for example the toby jugs and corned beef bits. As to which these may be very much his voice, but they also sound faintly ludicrous and suggest this is going to be a comical book, not a horror one. I'm not sure whether that's something you want or not.

Anyway, without seeing the alternative of Kate's body-in-the-dining-room (how déclassé...) we're a little hamstrung in knowing which is the better of the two scenes as a really grabby opener. Leave it a day or two, perhaps, but I'd suggest you put up the Kate scene and see what reaction you get to that. For myself, if Willie** is the main human character then I can understand your wanting to start the novel with him, but if the book is actually about the cursed ground which is what I thought, I'd want to start with the house/land, even if that meant starting the novel with someone else. Obviously, the best bet may well be to start with the house and the main character, but if that isn't possible, then you need to choose who/what is the most important, place or person.

Anyway, good work. Crack on with the rest.



** I share Loren's view that his name is inherently comic, and in view of the dick pics in the first para, it gives an unfortunate impression of a fixation which you might want to dispel by changing one or the other.
 
TJ makes a good point about putting up the Kate scene so we can make a more informed judgment about what works better as an opener. Plus it means we get to read it :)

The imagery is a bit full-on, but to be honest for me it didn't affect the pace. In fact, I definitely think that not everything has to be pacy and urgent, even at the beginning. Something well-written and thoughtful and witty does the job for me at least as well as something that's just, well, quick.

Having said that, and I say this slightly apologetically, because I really enjoy your off-the-wall imagery (Toby Jug faces, corned beef skin, cauliflower faces etc), that constant use of such techniques throughout the book could get slightly irritating. Depends on whether every character does it, I suppose. If it's just wee Willie Weekie's way of making sense of the world, then it's no biggie and actually becomes his way of seeing things. If other characters do the same thing, then it could get problematic and dilute the character voices.

Talking of Willie... I've no problem with the slightly schoolboy-sniggering-behind-the-bike-shed name. Knowing your writing as I do (limited familiarity, I'd call it) I'd hazard as guess that this book is actually going to be comic, albeit comedy of the very blackest, Guinnessy, treacly, pantherish, lights-off-in-the-cellar sort. Black comedy is an acquired taste, but those who like it will gobble it up, I'm sure.

As everyone always says - write what you want to write. But I know you'll do that anyway, so carry on, squire ;)
 
Did you give me advice? I don't think anyone's seen any present-day SG excerpts have they? Did I send you the feathers bit? That's been totally relocated as I need to suggest Willie's need for a holiday and set up some other stuff.

This - and Kate's stuff - is all new.

I could let people see Kate's stuff in a few days as TJ and DG suggest but I think that would really throw a spanner in the works as there's a lot of scene-setting and atmosphere that I know people are going to object to.

I should be working so I'll reply properly later.

Thanks as always for the support

pH
 
Hello, sorry for the double post, but I am back home now and I wanted to reply via keyboard instead of smartphone, and also let some things that have been said percolate.

I've also been disabused of the notion that I've not had anyone look at this before. HareBrain's right, I did send him a version of Kate and Willie's openings and he did advise Kate's as the starter. *aims Organon's cloudbuster*

So, thank you as always for the feedback. Loren's, TJ and DG's latest points have given me a lot to absorb today. These are my thoughts.

On Willie Weekes' name
- The choice of Willie is deliberately schoolboy-sniggery and the reason the year 11 students had doodled the pics was as a result of his name. This is a little self-indulgent because my surname is Bean. I have struggled with other people's 'wit' ranging from the students I teach, to dentist receptionists thinking they're original or the first person to make a certain joke. As a teen I worked in the fruit and veg dept of Waitrose; "Will Mr Bean come to the Fruit and Veg Department" on the PA system = cue general bedlam and laughter across the shop. I was cross country captain at school so was named Runner Bean. I was sunburnt and called Baked Bean. I am skinny; String Bean. I teach Jamaican Dancehall so nowadays I'm called Beenieman in most of my schools. So, the year 11's are deliberately taking the pee from Willie (hee hee - okay, sorry). However, I think the name works on it's own merits. His brother is called Emory and I also think the two of them work.

On Yr 11's - I don't really see Yr 11s as kids as they are 16 and can sometimes have a horrible sense of entitlement. I could happily drop it, or make the art workshop he teaches to be to adults without much worry, though.

The humour - The archness of some phrases, and humour is intentional. My biggest influences are Michael McDowell and Stephen King. Their prose is saturated with twisted jokes and black humour. Also, the relationship between the contemporary characters is a group of 7 best friends. There is lots of alcohol and smoking involved, so humour is kind of unavoidable. If I have overdone it, though, I'll be more than happy to prune it with some ruthless shears. In other words, I'm not particularly precious about it, even though it's in there by design, and as said upthread, if it was something that was happening with every character and overused, it'd be a problem.

Italics - Thanks. Noted. I think I may try and remove the use of italics completely in this story. It is a very bad habit I am developing along with semicolon overuse.

I'm wondering how important genre is, here. I read so much (admittedly modern) horror, and little sci fi or fantasy.

I'll tell you one thing I could really use advice on is the house itself. It has a brooding presence as if it is organic itself (fuelled by my own recurring nightmare of a house that is part-demon, part-growing organism, that I've had for at least the last two decades.) and so in Kate's section, where she is walking through the house to investigate a noise, there is quite a heavy amount of description. Not in terms of its layout, but in terms of it's character at night.

Nice feedback, all, thank you!

pH
 
I'll tell you one thing I could really use advice on is the house itself. It has a brooding presence as if it is organic itself (fuelled by my own recurring nightmare of a house that is part-demon, part-growing organism, that I've had for at least the last two decades.) and so in Kate's section, where she is walking through the house to investigate a noise, there is quite a heavy amount of description. Not in terms of its layout, but in terms of it's character at night.

I'd like to see this. I'm the original sceptic, but I once had WTF experience in a house that had me and my other half scarpering quicker than you shout 'Ghost!'
 
This was really cool.

I must admit I really stopped and looked again about four times when the PC Charisma name came up. Is that a name? A title? A player character?
In the end I decided it must be a name of some sort, but it really stopped me in my tracks :)

Other than that it read really well for me, didn't stop any other times during the entire read which is always a good sign.

/Temaran
 
Apologies for the late reply - busy busy day.

@prizzley - nice! We could swap a few family ghost stories; I've had a number of odd experiences over the years!

@Temaran - what a nice thing to get as feedback from a new member. Thanks and welcome to Chrons.

PC Charisma is a cynical/sarcastic name for the copper (PC = policeman in the UK). Willie's a bit broken and cynical and the copper was so standoffish, Willie gave him the nickname in his head. Maybe I should make it clearer. Thanks a lot for your feedback.

pH
 
Just glad I could help in any way, still trying to get a feel for the forum. Seems pretty awesome so far :)

/Temaran
 
PC Charisma is a cynical/sarcastic name for the copper (PC = policeman in the UK). Willie's a bit broken and cynical and the copper was so standoffish, Willie gave him the nickname in his head. Maybe I should make it clearer. Thanks a lot for your feedback.pH

That was clear to me. Maybe 'Charisma' would help.
 
It might be worth to clarify that I'm Swedish, so English is not my native language.
So maybe my input here has to be taken with a grain of salt :)

/Temaran
 
I agree with The Judge that 'cynical, world-worn teacher raging on Gen Y' is a bit of a cliche start that could be off-putting, particularly to younger readers (have no idea what your target audience is or if this is even important to you, but just a thought). As a highschool teacher myself I'm actually in full agreement with your assessment, but I wonder if it might suit the comedic tone a little more if his students were younger, say kindergartners or year 1s? That way he could be striding along the pavement shaking confetti out of his hair, or rubbing furiously at his chin where an exuberant critter had attacked him with finger paint - it just seems more in keeping with the somewhat absurd scenario about to unfold. Added bonus if PC Charisma makes a snide comment about the confetti, just to cement Willie's irritation a little more.

Either way I would definitely look to condense the first 2 paras into 1, moving more quickly to the central discovery. Other than that I thought it read immensely well - love the way the news was delivered, and I really like your voice. I'd take this as a potential story opening depending on where it went next :)
 
I'll tell you one thing I could really use advice on is the house itself. It has a brooding presence as if it is organic itself (fuelled by my own recurring nightmare of a house that is part-demon, part-growing organism, that I've had for at least the last two decades.) and so in Kate's section, where she is walking through the house to investigate a noise, there is quite a heavy amount of description. Not in terms of its layout, but in terms of it's character at night.
Put it up here and see what reaction you get, then. I'd offer to help, but I'm up to my eyes trying to clean out a hovercraft some idiot has crammed full of eels... :p (Seriously, if you want help off-Chrons, you know where I am.)

I do think you're right as to knowing about genre. I don't read horror, had no idea there was a lot of warped comedic stuff in eg Stephen King (only read two of his books, and didn't find either of them funny...) and I hadn't picked up from your other Critiques threads or Challenge entries about your apparent penchant for black humour. So yes, press ahead as it's intentional, and part of the style and voice of the book. Were you thinking of having the same vein run through the historical chapters, or are they going to be played more straight?

NB I can never get the hang of modern school years, so when I saw Year 11, I was thinking they were 11! (So it's Year number plus 5, is it?) I like the idea of school being where they are taught to take, but I still think I'd like a bigger, more unpleasant aspect of taking-ness in there if possible, not simply the entitlement aspect. Could they have "borrowed" something of his, which causes a problem for him when seeing the coppers?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top