Thoughts on story opening

Status
Not open for further replies.
Can I just interject that it's "lying" not "laying". "To lay" is a different verb from "to lie", and it's the latter which has to be used here. (Confusingly "lay" just happens to be the past simple of "to lie", so "He lay" in the text is correct. ie present tense = he lies there, or he is lying there; past simple = he lay there; past continuous = he was lying there).

"He lay, still, hoping not to be noticed" puts enormous emphasis onto the "still" ie you're stressing that he's lying immobile instead of lying while thrashing about, but it does read as a bit stilted. "He lay still, hoping..." does the job just as well without the stop-go effect of too many commas and does, indeed, indicate he's doing it on purpose. (He lay, still hoping..." means he's lying there -- with no indication of how he's lying -- but he remains hopeful.)

And while I'm here, in case it causes any confusion, the text might be obscure but it isn't obtuse. Obtuse means blunt when it comes to objects and angles, or mentally slow, wilfully or otherwise, in connection with people; obscure means difficult to understand.
 
Can I just interject that it's "lying" not "laying". "To lay" is a different verb from "to lie", and it's the latter which has to be used here. (Confusingly "lay" just happens to be the past simple of "to lie", so "He lay" in the text is correct. ie present tense = he lies there, or he is lying there; past simple = he lay there; past continuous = he was lying there).

"He lay, still, hoping not to be noticed" puts enormous emphasis onto the "still" ie you're stressing that he's lying immobile instead of lying while thrashing about, but it does read as a bit stilted. "He lay still, hoping..." does the job just as well without the stop-go effect of too many commas and does, indeed, indicate he's doing it on purpose. (He lay, still hoping..." means he's lying there -- with no indication of how he's lying -- but he remains hopeful.)

And while I'm here, in case it causes any confusion, the text might be obscure but it isn't obtuse. Obtuse means blunt when it comes to objects and angles, or mentally slow, wilfully or otherwise, in connection with people; obscure means difficult to understand.

:ROFLMAO:

OK, so, I was correct. I wanted to instil the knowledge that he wasn't moving. but he wouldn't let it lie.< :0)

Thanks TJ
 
I was just joking with me lie TJ nothing more.

Look I'm starting to upset people so I'll just back off.

I have been blessed by some good advice here and some, well, less so. All balanced, I'm better off as usual so thank you all. Honestly, I'm v grateful.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top