OHB
Crazed Writer
Just finished The Complete Fairy Tales by the Brothers Grimm. I have three takeaways:
1. Quite a few of the stories were very antisemitic, even going so far as to use the words "thief" and "Jew" interchangeably. That was... unexpected.
2. Too many stories end with an ignorant, snotty brat getting everything he wanted and suffering no consequences for being an ignorant, snotty brat.
3. Most of the stories are nothing like the commercialized versions. The frog does not turn back into a prince with a kiss. Instead, the princess hurls him against a wall, and that turns him back into a prince (which I like much better). Cinderella doesn't have a fairy godmother. She has a tree growing out of her mother's grave that gives her things, which I find far more poignant than some random old woman with a wand showing up out of the blue. Neither Sleeping Beauty nor Snow White is awakened by a kiss. In Sleeping Beauty's case, the spell that made everyone sleep was designed to wear off after 100 years. The prince does nothing other than walk into the castle as everyone's waking up. No fighting dragons or slicing through briars. He just traipses on in. He could be the wimpiest guy on the planet for all we know. And Snow White was only asleep because a piece of the enchanted apple was still in her mouth. As they're carrying her away in a coffin, she gets jostled around and the bit of apple falls out, allowing her to wake up. It seems that, in the battle of whose versions of fairy tales get popularized through movies and whose don't, the Grimms lost out big.
1. Quite a few of the stories were very antisemitic, even going so far as to use the words "thief" and "Jew" interchangeably. That was... unexpected.
2. Too many stories end with an ignorant, snotty brat getting everything he wanted and suffering no consequences for being an ignorant, snotty brat.
3. Most of the stories are nothing like the commercialized versions. The frog does not turn back into a prince with a kiss. Instead, the princess hurls him against a wall, and that turns him back into a prince (which I like much better). Cinderella doesn't have a fairy godmother. She has a tree growing out of her mother's grave that gives her things, which I find far more poignant than some random old woman with a wand showing up out of the blue. Neither Sleeping Beauty nor Snow White is awakened by a kiss. In Sleeping Beauty's case, the spell that made everyone sleep was designed to wear off after 100 years. The prince does nothing other than walk into the castle as everyone's waking up. No fighting dragons or slicing through briars. He just traipses on in. He could be the wimpiest guy on the planet for all we know. And Snow White was only asleep because a piece of the enchanted apple was still in her mouth. As they're carrying her away in a coffin, she gets jostled around and the bit of apple falls out, allowing her to wake up. It seems that, in the battle of whose versions of fairy tales get popularized through movies and whose don't, the Grimms lost out big.