Discussion Thread -- OCTOBER 2020 -- 300 Word Writing Challenge (#39)

Ok, top 3 for me and, without giving away any spoilers, the votes :)

@Provincial - a verse it appears, can work wonders in your ears, without moving you to tears, even whilst buying souvenirs.
@Danny McG - Now, I must admit to; a soft spot for a haiku; I'm funny that way
@jd73 - Reminds me a certain dying replicant's monologue
 
Crikey! Unable to believe that a second person had voted for Bo-T, I checked the poll and found that it had three votes! This isn’t going to happen again, so I’m going to revel in it. Yay! Woop-woop-woop! Aroooooooooba!!!:ROFLMAO:

@The Big Peat, thank you for your stealth vote. Brilliant! :love:
 
My short list with votes marked by *.

* @Ashleyne - CAP’N PATCHBEARD’S NON-EXISTANT SHIP
@paranoid marvin - A Sailor's Story
@Victoria Silverwolf - Storm Warnings
@Marvin - Post Apocalyptic Wonderland
@mosaix - Just Beneath The Surface…
* @Peter V - Fruits de Mer
* @The Judge - A Djinn’s Lament

I liked Peter V Fruits de Mer story the most, hard to say why, because the rest of the stories they all were great, stirrup emotions or put the brain wheels in motion.
I liked Ashleyene CAP’N PATCHBEARD’S NON-EXISTANT SHIP story for the plot twist, i was expecting some sort of ghosts.
I was very surprised by The Judge A Djinn’s Lament story, not only by the end plot twist, but by the whole text construction, the build of expectation and the ending with a perfectly acceptable explanation.
 
Ouch. That was a good picture - lots and lots of choice. Far too many really good stories, that shouldn't have been left without votes. I managed to cut my short list down to: Cat's Cradle, mosaix, Peter V, The Judge, Ursa major, and Victoria Silverwolf, with votes for Capricorn42,Perpetual Man & The Judge, . Hm, good selection of non participants in the writing segments have already voted in that part of the process thank you, ,JadeW, nixie, sule and wagtail, but I'm surprised at the three who've produced one vote of the three they were allowed.

Many thanks Victoria for the vote.
 
For the moment, I really dislike the internet. Anyway.....

I voted

Thank you for the reviews

Thank you for the mentions
 
Hello,

Been reading and re-reading the stories. Here're my shortlists, faves* and votes*

Wayne Mack
Astro pen *
BT Jones
Danny*
Cat's Cradle*
Capricorn 42
Victoria
Luiglin
Elck
Johnnyjet*
Mosaix
Perp*
Jd74*
Peter V
Jade W
Ursa
Peat*
Jo
M Robert Gibson
Judge*

I knew Peat would have one of my votes, and the last two kept changing. In the end I went for the ones that created the strongest emotional response in me on the second read.

I prefer to thank anyone who has voted or shortlisted me at the end of the cycle, but in this case, I feel rude not acknowledging, so I'd like to thank for the shortlists, and the votes from nixie, Marvin, Peat, BT Jones, Sule, Provincial, Wayne Mack, Wagtail and jd73.
 
nixie said:
Close, wonder who will get the bridesmaid dress @Phyrebrat or @The Judge ?
Click to expand...
Hold on! I still think I could be a factor here!! (Joking - zero votes, how depressing, *sigh*. Back to the drawing board.)

Any-who, so many entries I could have voted for in this Challenge. I think we did a great job with @Mister_Oy's fine photo.

After several read-throughs, here are my lists:

Honorables:
paranoid marvin, Perpetual Man, jd73, chrispenycate, Ursa major

Shortlist:
Wayne Mack, Phyrebrat, The Big Peat, Jo Zebedee

Votes:
Victoria Silverwolf, PeterV, The Judge

These are ones I would love to have written. Amazing stories, all three.

Huge thanks to the following for the lovely listings: @BT Jones, @chrispenycate, @Phyrebrat.

Finally, and as always, thanks very much, Victoria Silverwolf and Parson for the fine reviews. :)

edit to add: I voted several days ago, so the rankings will not be changed today because of me.
 
My Long List, Short List, and *** Favorites ***:

*** My Mommy's Mermaid - Wayne Mack ***
CAP’N PATCHBEARD’S NON - EXISTANT SHIP – Ashleyne
And Not a Drop to Drink – Guttersnipe
10 Degress - BT Jones
Boaty McBoatface and the Legend of the Blue Lagoon (or, why villains shouldn’t monologue) – Provincial
First Contact - Bren G
The Panacea or the Grey - Cat's Cradle
*** Storm Warnings - Victoria Silverwolf ***
Post Apocalyptic Wonderland – Marvin
Mr Blue – Daysman
“Thy name was writ in water—it shall stand,” (Oscar Wild) – Eickerlyc
Just Beneath the Surface… - mosaix
Vigil for a Mother – Phyrebrat
Blue Water - jd73
Fruits de Mer - Peter V
Untitled – JadeW
*** An Editorial Change - Ursa major ***
Around the Galaxy in Eighty Years - M. Robert Gibson

Thanks for the listings, BT Jones and Phyrebrat. And a special thanks for the vote, Ian Fortytwo!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
Daysman DISCUSSION THREAD -- October 2024 -- 75 Word Writing Challenge Writing Challenges 161
The Judge DISCUSSION THREAD -- 300 Word Writing Challenge #55 (October 2024) Writing Challenges 135
The Judge DISCUSSION THREAD -- 300 Word Writing Challenge #51 (October 2023) Writing Challenges 117
HareBrain DISCUSSION THREAD -- October 2023 -- 75 Word Writing Challenge Writing Challenges 165
Jo Zebedee DISCUSSION THREAD -- OCTOBER 2022 -- 75 Word Writing Challenge Writing Challenges 184

Similar threads


Back
Top