I have that trouble having been in the military and having worked as a medical professional. I can hardly sit through a war movie or action movie without calling out the numerous issues. What’s one more thing to add to that. Lol
Same. I was good friends with one of the VPs at the bank. We shared a lot of interests, particularly European history and he would call my office and tell me he had 'business' he needed to discuss. I'd go down, he'd shut the door and we'd talk about stuff for an hour or so.
One time he was telling me about going to a Chiefs game with a friend who was a retired Chief's qtr. His friend would tell him what was about to happen by how they lined up, shifted, where the qtrback looked and such. He was torn between being fascinated his friend could do that and being irritated.
He fell silent for a few and then said he thought going to see a sword and armor movie with me would be a whole 'nother experience.
He was right. One of the guys in my troop took me to see Time Cop and when that insipid scene where von Dammme had a knife fight I cracked up - loudly and prolonged. The two were
fencing with 6" buck knives. You know, left hand back, right forward and the thrusts, cuts and slashes were short and blocked saber style by the other. Friggin' hilarious in an unmeant way.
Overall there are a scant few fight scenes, especially bladed, that I find at all satisfactory. This of course includes one-ten pound women kicking a two-twenty-five pound man's butt, throwing them across the room, etc.
Two I can recommend for authenticity are:
"The Duelists" for some realistic sword work of various types. The duel with cavalry sabers is quite nice.
"Atomic Blonde" where the lead Charlize Theron shows what it would
really look like for a highly trained woman to fight much larger men. Unlike Johansson, she gets and looks beat the crap out of and has a hard time of it and, of course, never jumps up and grabs them by the neck with her thighs.
Aside, the fight scene starting at 1:10:50 (I just rewatched) is a single, uncut shot ala Ron Howard of her fighting up and down stairwells followed by a car chase and it's TEN DAMN MINUTES LONG and was done with ONE FRIGGIN' TAKE. It's amazing to watch. Theron did her stunt work.