Ser Loras (spoiler)

Joined
Nov 28, 2005
Messages
20
Location
New York, New York
Does anyone else not give a @#%$ whether he lives or dies?

He used to be one of my favorite characters. But lately he definitely takes after the male side of his family (i.e. dumb).
 
It depends on how GRRM plays it - if he lives, he'll almost certainly be hideous to look upon and it may even seriously impair his fighting ability.
Personally I hope he survives and, like Jamie before him, is profoundly altered by his humbling. He loved himself too much that lad - "too green, with the smell of summer on him" to paraphrase... :)

Who knows - he could become the new 'Hound' ;)
 
I'm wondering if Loras is even the one who was maimed. It's pretty easy to horribly disfigure someone and then claim he is someone else. Knowing Cersei, she's got Loras in a dungeon somewhere, and another slender young man is suffering from horrible burns.
 
Cersei seemed pretty sure that Loras would do something stupid if he went to Dragonstone, so I don't think that she would bother to imprison him. If anyonw were to hide Loras away, I think it would be the Tyrells. He volunteered himself quite impulsively. The Tyrells are quite tricksy (see Joffrey), and they are really just Lannisters with flowers.
 
I don't like him either. Arogant little ****. Hopefully his wounding will leave him changed for the better, as i doubt very much he's dead.
 
YOSSARIAN said:
The Tyrells are quite tricksy (see Joffrey), and they are really just Lannisters with flowers.
Well, their ambition rivals the Lannsiters, but Olenna is not Tywin and none of the rest of them are as good as Tyrion. But with Tywin and Tyrion out of King's Landing, then the Queen of Thorns, Margaery, Mace, Garlen, and Loras are the match of Cersei, Jaime and Kevan.
 
AryaUnderfoot said:
I'm wondering if Loras is even the one who was maimed. It's pretty easy to horribly disfigure someone and then claim he is someone else. Knowing Cersei, she's got Loras in a dungeon somewhere, and another slender young man is suffering from horrible burns.

Well, I thought the same thing, but with the Tyrells having a ulterior plan, spiriting Loras unharmed from Dragonstone, perhaps to lead Redwyne's fleet around to take on the Ironborn on the Mander, joining his brothers and then marching (again) on King's Landing. It all really comes down to working out what game the Tyrells are actually playing...

But either way, I don't think he'll die, and I think the reports of his maiming are greatly exagerrated.
 
Loras will hang around and fall in love with one of Robert's bastards...

Gendry or Edric.
 
...and wasnt it curious that Cersei had to listen to all the details of the battle twice; too bad she wasnt paying attention, the knight who was maimed was wielding morningstars, not the jeweled sword presented to Loras when he left Kings Landing...

"Dancing With Dragons" is going to show just how stupid, blind, arrogant and incompetant that Cersei was as a ruler. She alienated her entire power base and with Highgarden just a step away from the Iron throne...
 
temuchin said:
"Dancing With Dragons" is going to show just how stupid, blind, arrogant and incompetant that Cersei was as a ruler. She alienated her entire power base and with Highgarden just a step away from the Iron throne...

Didn't this happen in AFFC?

Good piont about the morningstars, I need to reread... I'm as dumb as Cersei.
 
I missed that point as well, maybe becuase the 50 Cersei chapters were wearing thin on me... NEWMAN!! I hate missing critical pieces of the story.

Cersei has proven herself the posterchild for imbeciles in power.

And unless Loras is going to shave his head like he is from Thoros and start kickin arse and taking names...good riddance. When I am reading about him I get the image of Prince Charming from Shrek 2!
 
Last edited:
temuchin said:
...and wasnt it curious that Cersei had to listen to all the details of the battle twice; too bad she wasnt paying attention, the knight who was maimed was wielding morningstars, not the jeweled sword presented to Loras when he left Kings Landing...

An interesting point but not one I feel proves the knight wasn't Loras. Throughout the books we've seen knights weild a variety of weapons - usually they seem to have a melee-style weapon - a morningstar, an axe, a mace - as well as their swords. I'm not entirely sure but I also seem to recall Loras fighting with a morningstar at the melee at Bitterbridge, against Brienne.
 
Rhigt.
I remeber Tommen saying that he was going to learn how to fight with lance swoard and MORNINGSTAR from Loras.
It would be interesting if it was Loras who was wounded sice the events surely would change him. And I really liked how Jaimie changed...
 
a knight does need be proficient in all forms of martial contest but a sword is a knight's privilege: outside of melee's have any of the king's guard gone into battle wielding other than a sword? certainly not proof it wasn't Lorus but more than a damnsite curious...

and just to play devils' advocate, who knows if Dragonstone was even taken? 1 little fib gets the fleet gets the entire fleet sent away...
 
ras'matroi said:
Rhigt.
I remeber Tommen saying that he was going to learn how to fight with lance swoard and MORNINGSTAR from Loras.
It would be interesting if it was Loras who was wounded sice the events surely would change him. And I really liked how Jaimie changed...


In the Brienne / Loras fight in ACOK, Brienne, not Loras, fights with the morningstar (Loras fights with a longaxe).

Howevr, it's true that Tommen wants to learn with Loras "to fight with lance and sword and morningstar, the same way he does" in AFFC
 
Does anyone remember who reported back to Cersei that Dragonstone was taken? How much proof does she have that this actually occurred? Reputable source?
Brain on overload - can't think....need more coffee.
-g-
 
So you're saying the ******* of Driftmark is actually loyal to Stannis? And that Stannis finally achieved a political victory through intrigue over the Lannisters (something he's been notoriously unable to do so far)?

On the other hand, Loras really wants revenge for Renly (Loras loved Renly even more than Brienne). He unjustly slew Emmon Cuy and Robar Royce (iirc) over Renly's death and he would have killed Brienne out of hand if Jaime had not intervened. But after talking with Brienne, Loras now doubts who killed Renly... It seems that Jaime and Brienne have persuaded him that Stannis is responsible for Renly's murder... so perhaps Loras stormed Storm's End in hopes of killing Stannis. Did he know that Stannis was now in the north and not at Dragonstone?

Who is doing the planning and thinking for the Tyrells? Lady Olenna? Does Mace actually include her, or are many powerful players in the Tyrell camp actually loyal to her and not Mace? Is Mace really a blustering windbag or is that just a cover? Loras has shown some base cunning, but I doubt he's the brains. Willas and Garlen are more likely to be the brains. Willas is limited in movement because of his injury, but he's the eldest son.

Garlen has gotten himself some real lands and is now a powerful lord in his own right. Renly might have been a poof, but would he really have initiated a relationship with the fourteen year old son of one of the most powerful men in the realm? Perhaps one of the Tyrells, Garlan or Olenna set it up. If they had provided secure locations, then the relationship could easily have blossomed. Renly admitted to scheming to make Margaery Robert's new queen... and I doubt Loras could have done that by himself.

But as Queen, with a firm hold on Tommen, and with the Regent on the outs, Margaery is not just a Tyrell pawn... she is a major player in the Game of Thrones.

What if Loras swings both ways? What if he and Margaery were as close as Jaime and Cersei? Could the moontea have been for their relationship?

Lots of questions, no real answers.
 
Sorry for the double post, but my edit time period must have expired.

I don't remember this verbatim, but Stannis and Renly had a conversation that went like this:

Stannis: A year ago you were scheming to make her Robert's bride.
Renly: Things change. You'll be happy to know that she came to me a virgin.
Stannis: In your bed, she's likely to die that way.
Renly: Oh, I'll get a child on her before the year's out, don't worry.

The main thing I'd like to focus on in this conversation is that Renly was confident of getting Margaery pregnant. Why? Did Renly have bastards? We don't know that he did and he seems to be well known as a homosexual. Was Renly going to sleep with Margaery and impregnate her? Again, he seemed to be well known to Stannis for his preference for the same sex. The other solution was to have someone impregnate Margaery for him. Who? Someone close to him, a trusted confidant, someone with black or brown hair, someone who's looks would not be completely contrary to Baratheon or Tyrell looks, someone who could insure that the child looked just like Margaery.

IOW, Loras... perhaps Garlan.

Why was Renly so confident of Margaery conceiving within the year? Had she proven to have been fertile in the past?

How long has she been drinking moontea?
 
Last edited:

Similar threads


Back
Top