Horcruxes. The remaining.

Neville couldn't be the chosen one anyway because Dumbledore already told Harry that he was the chosen one. He said Voldie had a choice between Harry and Neville and he chose Harry. The theory about Neville is proposterous. Although I don't totally agree with the theory of Harry himself being a horcux, I could see it happening. And I totally, with no doubt think RAB is R. Black.
 
I don't see it at all possible that Neville could be the chosen one unless hes chosen to carry out a different task. But all the evidence of the prophecy points to Harry. Really Majimaune do u want Neville to be the chosen one? , or is it just out of spite to Harry or pity for Neville. A mean the guy can't even mutter a spell without doing it wrong. Whilst harry would need some guts and hope to defeat Voldie, Neville would need divine intervention and the help of Merlin himself.

*And Snarf if i remember correctly J.K Rowling said that R.A.B - Regulus Black is a good guess but its not him.
 
HBP said:
I don't see it at all possible that Neville could be the chosen one unless hes chosen to carry out a different task. But all the evidence of the prophecy points to Harry. Really Majimaune do u want Neville to be the chosen one? , or is it just out of spite to Harry or pity for Neville. A mean the guy can't even mutter a spell without doing it wrong. Whilst harry would need some guts and hope to defeat Voldie, Neville would need divine intervention and the help of Merlin himself.

*And Snarf if i remember correctly J.K Rowling said that R.A.B - Regulus Black is a good guess but its not him.
Click to expand...

The last I heard, she'd said it was "um, a fine guess".

I disagree about Neville. I think he's just lacking confidence -- and his own wand for most of the series. Perhaps in the next book he'll be stronger now he's gaining his self-assurance and he's gained a new wand. He's still not "The Chosen One" though.
 
Snarf said:
Neville couldn't be the chosen one anyway because Dumbledore already told Harry that he was the chosen one. He said Voldie had a choice between Harry and Neville and he chose Harry.
Click to expand...
Dumbledore has been known to be wrong. Not often but yes he has been wrong.

HBP said:
Really Majimaune do u want Neville to be the chosen one?
Click to expand...
Yes I do. He needs to be. It is his destiny. That and I think Harry it a bit of a prick now.

Leisha said:
I disagree about Neville. I think he's just lacking confidence -- and his own wand for most of the series. Perhaps in the next book he'll be stronger now he's gaining his self-assurance and he's gained a new wand. He's still not "The Chosen One" though.
Click to expand...
I was liking that post until I read the last sentence.
 
Yes Majimaune we all now that Dumbledore have made mistakes before. But u are over looking the two solid points that contradicts your belief. The prophecy states that "Voldemort will mark him as his equal" thats definitely Harry's scar , unless Neville has a mark yet to be publicized. And "He will have power that the dark lord knows not of" Thats the lingering protection that Harry mother's sacrifice activated. So unless thats not the true prophecy, you need to come with some strong evidence to support ur "theory".
 
Yeah i agree Leisha, i was just being evil. I think Neville has potential down in him somewhere just waiting to burst free. Starting with him owning his own wand and his grandmother stop pressuring him and allow him to carve a different path for himself and stop stumbling in his father's.
 
Neville will probably turn out to be one of Harry's strongest allies. He can be an important character without being the chosen one.
I would love it if the whole horcrux situation was explained in detail, there's just not enough information for us to predict anything. 7 horcruxes = 8 pieces of soul. Would voldie count himself as one, or have 7 seperate external ones? And who knows him well enough to be certain?
 
HBP said:
Yes Majimaune we all now that Dumbledore have made mistakes before. But u are over looking the two solid points that contradicts your belief. The prophecy states that "Voldemort will mark him as his equal" thats definitely Harry's scar , unless Neville has a mark yet to be publicized. And "He will have power that the dark lord knows not of" Thats the lingering protection that Harry mother's sacrifice activated. So unless thats not the true prophecy, you need to come with some strong evidence to support ur "theory".
Click to expand...
Well you see Voldy marked Neville as an equal by not going for him but going for who he thinks would kill him but really he made a mistake. Neville has power we are yet to hear of, possibly the near death of his parents pushed it down in him and it can only come up when he fights who did the torture of his parents, Belatrix. I seriously don't believe a word I have said but it would be cool if it happened.

Joel007 said:
I would love it if the whole horcrux situation was explained in detail, there's just not enough information for us to predict anything. 7 horcruxes = 8 pieces of soul. Would voldie count himself as one, or have 7 seperate external ones? And who knows him well enough to be certain?
Click to expand...
I think there are only 7 pieces of soul. The one in Voldy counts as one of the seven. He believes that 7 is the most magical number so why would he tear into 8 parts?
 
I had to bring these two posts over to here.

mirinda said:
Dumbledor explains in book six what he knows about the horcruxes and i'm inclined to believe him. As i have just recently re-read book 6 i an comfortable in saying there are 6 horcruxes and 7 parts of his soul. The book and ring were destroyed. We assume whoever R.A.B is destryed the horcrux in the locket, but that wasn't confirmed, in the letter is R said he was going to try do destroy it. I think it is destroyed, but then who knows. So we have the ring, book, locket, also the cup of hufflepuff, nagini and something of ravenclaws or gryffindors. Dumbledore believed it was somthing of ravenclaws and i'm inclined to believe him. If we take all the information Dumbledor gave Harry the only horcrux we don't know is the thing of Ravenclaws, so 6 parts of Voldemort's soul are horcruxes and the 7th is inside voldemort himself. Anyone have any idea's what ravenclaws horcrux could be?
Click to expand...
I am with you with almost everything said in that post. I think that the first thing Harry should do is track down a bloodline from Ravenclaw and then find the right person. I am inclined to think it might be that chick who Percy Weasley went out with in book 4 (was that it or was it book 3?). She was from Ravenclaw and apart from Cho Chang, the only one who has had a, you could say part, in the stories.

Joel007 said:
And for another thing, Nagini isn't a horcrux.
In fact I suspect that nothing alive can be a horcrux.
Click to expand...
I am with you Joel because in book 1 Voldy says that he possesses animals and they never lived long. Also that two souls in the same body would be a bit strange and Voldy wouldn't like to place his soul in something that died. For all we know There might only be 5 horcruxes because Voldy didn't get time to do the 6th one with anything special.
 
the way nagini is a horcrux is that he shares a closer bond with her via her milk (venom) same way harry has a bond with him (bloood)

and jk was just on jonathon ross wheyhey the last word aint scar anymore and she isnt writing another book, she sed the advenyures of harry definately ends in this book
 
Yeah I know. You know what. I think that the Rowling section should be locked off a little after the book so there are no theory proving and horcrux saying before most people have had a chance to read it.
 
for at least a week...give the slow readers a chance to absorb the "shock" of harry dying
 
I'm away for a week so I don't get to read it until I'm back. Two weeks.
 
no a week is fine, u cn come home to spoilers mwahahahaaaa

lets make it 2 weeks as by that time we will alll be itching to discuss the fact that she ended it miserbaly again
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
F Human colony secretly develops interstellar travel and hides in another star system while the remaining humans try to develop it and find them Book Search 4
Extollager Remaining Unpublished Tolkien Works; Rare Poem Link JRR Tolkien 1
P Not all the remaining passengers on the Titanic were afraid of dying Book Discussion 20

Similar threads


Back
Top