Correct.
Full List is
Brian Rusk: an autographed 1956
Topps Sandy Koufax baseball card. (actually a card of a fictional, unremarkable player named Sammy Koberg). Changed to a
Mickey Mantle card for the film version.
Nettie Cobb: a
carnival glass lampshade.
Hugh Priest: a
foxtail (actually moth-eaten and half-rotten), meant to be displayed on a car's radio antenna.
Myra Evans: a framed picture of
Elvis Presley. (actually a picture frame with no picture inside).
Cora Rusk: aviator sunglasses that once belonged to Elvis (actually a battered and taped-up pair of glasses).
Danforth "Buster" Keeton: a mechanical and prophetic horserace game called "Winning Ticket". (The game appears to have always been broken)
Sally Ratcliffe: a petrified splinter from
Noah's Ark (actually "black with age and spongy with rot," and infected with
woodlice).
Sonny Jackett: double-measure adjustable
socket wrenches. (actually a box containing rusty iron pieces)
Polly Chalmers: an azka, an
Egyptian amulet with the ability to ward off pain (in this case, chronic
arthritis) (actually contains a spider-like monster inside the azka).
"Slopey" Dodd: a pewter teapot.
Lucille Dunham: black pearls.
Myrtle Keeton: a doll.
Everett Frankel: an ornate pipe carved by a master craftsman (once owned by
Hermann Goring).
Ricky Bissonette: pornographic photos of a young Hollywood actress/model.
Babs Miller: a (locked)
music box without a key.
Ace Merrill: cocaine and a book, "Lost and Buried Treasures of New England" by Reginald Merrill (actually a copy of
Treasure Island by
Robert Louis Stevenson).
Deputy Norris Ridgewick: a Bazun
fishing rod (actually a "dirty, splintery bamboo pole, really no more than a stick with a kid’s Zebco reel attached to it by one rusty screw").
Sheriff Alan Pangborn: a videotape revealing the circumstances surrounding the death of his wife and younger son -- although he never "pays" for the item.