Implications on Jon being LC

Koopa

Old KiwiBird
Joined
Jun 17, 2006
Messages
1,959
I was thinking on what would be the direct implications on jon being the LCotNW.

- Tormund Giantsbane seems to like Jon, paving the way (especially since Stannis new policy) for some sort of future alliance.
- The North has seen lots of death, destruction and chaos (though not so much as the riverlands). Wich means there are several people around with broken lives. There are the smallfolk, but also men-at-arms, knights (or the north's equivalent), would they upon hearing Ned stak ******* becoming LC seek shelter with him. Thus raising the number of men in the NW.
- Will Stannis (if one-sided- feel a sort of bond with Jon, like he feels with Davos, seeing as like Davos, Jon tells him the truth, wich Stannis seems to like.
- ....
 
I'm not sure about the last one...Stannis will bond with who Melisandre wants him to bond with at this point.
 
Jon's frankness with Stannis reminded me of Davos, too. However, I do not believe that Stannis values that character trait anymore. He values Melisandre's visions and their delusions.
 
Time and time again we see how Stannis values Davos, even in the chapters after Stannis has gone to the Wall we hear Stannis talk repectively of davis against Jon, so what makes you think he doesn't value those threats, as well as Davos anymore.

Melisandre has control over Stannis, but not total control.
 
I see a time when Stannis will stop valuing Mel's opinion so highly, especially since it has not brought him any closer to the Iron Throne but rather much further to the edge of the kingdom. This will be when Mel will kill Stannis and claim Jon to be Azor Ahai reborn.
 
TK, that's interesting. Melisandre's got to be growing tired of Stannis. Jon does seem a much better candidate, doesn't he? I mean, of course, a much better candidate for all of Melisandre's weird and twisted devotions. We can see that in Jon's ADwD chapter. It's probably pretty easy to have the hots for Jon... I can only imagine.
 
Melisandre is a woman grown though, whilst Jon is no more than 16 or so.
Most women dont fall for younger guys do they? She might be one of those i guess.
 
So, Drogo can like 14-year old girls, but Melisandre can't like young men? You were so eager to remind us that Jon is a man in his society.

Also, most women don't fall for their own brother, but some do. No matter how you justify things, we are still dealing with a rather twisted cast of characters here. Sure, you can aruge the context of the society and the times, but ultimately, most of these are some pretty effed up people.
 
I never said it wasnt possible, just that i think most women dont fall for younger guys, and that i therefore find it not that likely to happen, though as i said it is offc. possible. I did say that she might be one of those.
 
Hmm. True. I think Melisandre is attracted to herself. And her piousness. But I think she may use her sexuality to try to manipulate Jon.
 
I guess Kiwi was never attacked by a cougar.

By the preview chapter, I think Mel is starting to like Jon alot. I don't Mel would associate piousness with sex. Something tells me she's no bishop.
 
I guess Kiwi was never attacked by a cougar.

Lately, i find myself more often not understanding posts.
In any case, i have indeed never been attacked by a cougar.
Lots of dogs seem to have it out for me though... perhaps that helps.
 
Yeah, I'm with Kiwi, that's why I own cats.

But I agree with TK, I don't think anyone can deny that there is a very heavily built in characteristic of female sexuality when it comes to Mel.

But the relationship between Stannis and Mel has always seemed a particularily odd thing in the books to me.
 
Kiwi, Cougar is current American slang for an older woman, more specifically one who is interested in younger men and actively pursues them. Dog can be slang for an ugly woman. Dog can also be slang for a sneaky or unfaithful man. Dog is also used as contemporary slang between male friends to identify each other. Fox is seventies slang for a beautiful woman... even though it's archaic, people will know what you mean if you say it. Wolf is older slang for a man always looking for a woman. Cat was slang from the jazz and big band eras to describe an unflappable guy.

Soooo... Melisandre is a cougar. Brienne is a dog. Tom O'Sevens is a dog. Osmund might say to Osney, "What up, dog?" Cersei is a fox. Robert was a wolf. Littlefinger is one cool cat.
 
Last edited:
HAAAA! The Kettleblacks talking street talk. Too funny!

Boaz to the rescue!! Sorry, I couldn't stop laughing I just had to let the joke going for a little bit.

Kiwi: My favourite cougar (and one I would not mind getting attacked by) is that good old Canadian girl Kim Cattrall. Demi Moore is another good example.

But is Mel really a cougar? How old is she really?
 
I like where this thread is going.

Let's not forget "pig," "tigress," "snake," "worm," "kitten," "dove," um... "bunny," etc.
 
and thats the perfect cue to get back on topic. What will you guys think might become direct results on Jon becoming LC.
 
Kiwi, Cougar is current American slang for an older woman, more specifically one who is interested in younger men and actively pursues them. Dog can be slang for an ugly woman. Dog can also be slang for a sneaky or unfaithful man. Dog is also used as contemporary slang between male friends to identify each other. Fox is seventies slang for a beautiful woman... even though it's archaic, people will know what you mean if you say it. Wolf is older slang for a man always looking for a woman. Cat was slang from the jazz and big band eras to describe an unflappable guy.

Soooo... Melisandre is a cougar. Brienne is a dog. Tom O'Sevens is a dog. Osmund might say to Osney, "What up, dog?" Cersei is a fox. Robert was a wolf. Littlefinger is one cool cat.

Littlefinger!? Oh, Boaz, Boaz. Did you really have to go there?! Anyhow, your slang interpretation is quite correct, no matter what part of the US you're from or speaking of. You left out the weasel though. And the rat.
 
and thats the perfect cue to get back on topic. What will you guys think might become direct results on Jon becoming LC.

Hard to say, Kiwi. I want him to be a fantastic success... however, does it seem coincidental to anyone else that Jon is the 998th Lord Commander? Does that not lead to a perfect succession to 1000 before the series is through?

I've routed for Jon the entire time. Especially after a second read of the series. In all truth, I want Jon to be one of the ones that stands tall at the end, but in order to have a 999th or 1000th LC, Jon has to die, or somehow manage to leave the wall whilst holding his honor intact.

I wholeheartedly believe Jon will be in the Seventh Book, but to what extent, I cannot say...
 

Similar threads


Back
Top