Theory: Coldhands=Benjen Stark, Three-eyed Crow = Brynden BloodRaven Rivers

Just my opinion, but in ordcer for this thread not to be a spolier for pre aDWD readers, all posts after the publication after aDWD would need to be deleted, and the thread would have to be locked. It was a great guess, but now it's not a guess any more, and that fact is confirmed by the rest of the posts in the thread.

It's a pretty big spoiler IMO. I'd ask that one of the mods corrects this situation.
 
Lol, talk about complicated.
Btw, till when do we need to add spoiler tags.
Till a year from the release of the book?
 
KiwiBird said:
Lol, talk about complicated.
Btw, till when do we need to add spoiler tags.
Till a year from the release of the book?
Click to expand...

That's how I would have done it when i used to mod on a different forum. To be honest, i don't know the tools (superpowers) that mods have here, and if what I suggested is even possible.

I personally think that nothing other than the most basic of info should be in a thread title. Better to err on the side of caution than potentially spil a suprise
 
KiwiBird,

Go buy a lottery ticket. And feel free to post any good stockmarket picks here. You picked that one right.

Really amazing considering the obscurity of the character that is the three-eyed crow. What, was he mentioned once in passing?
 
dang, only had 1 right then, unless he changed it since.
So Coldhands, is the night king?
 
Coldhands could be the last hero. Maybe. I was really on board with the Benjen theory.
 
Here I thought it was an original thought, and it's been sitting there in the margin notes all this time!! LOL
 
I lovethat in just this one instance, the editor actually got drawn in and straight up asked for a spoiler.

this looks like the only note that the editor left that had nothing to do with actually editing the book.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
Boaz Theory: Dumbledore's Hand J K Rowling 0
Boaz Theory: Dumbledore's Horcrux J K Rowling 1
Boaz The failure of my Grand Unified Theory George R R Martin 9
B Adopted language theory in Herbert's Dune Book Discussion 22
S Are there any time travel stories that use "ghost theory"? SFF Lounge 8

Similar threads


Back
Top