Discussion -- August 2011 Challenge

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Dusty Zebra

That was an interesting and logical conclusion to what has to be considered a rather warped tale to begin with. You made me think about it, and I like what you did.

Yay! Thanks! :D I'm glad somebody got the reference, anyway -- it's always a hazard when you have to depend on everyone's knowledge of a particular thing.

At this point, I had to go with what I had, rather than spend time finding something else -- my time is all taken up from now to mid-October in the Victorian Steampunk Navajo Afghan Project.
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

I'll be looking for the next New York Times article on the VSNAP. I hear it's going bonkers.:D
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Even I heard that it was being dogged by problems....
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Culhwch

Sorry - hadn't realised that there was a policy on second stories being posted. I will be going on holiday the day after the end of posting and had thought of posting it then but I would not be able to interact on any feedback (he says in all confidence!) - assuming there would be feedback!

I still wont see the results of the voting until I get back on the 6th Sept though I do think I know where my vote is going... (he says mysteriously!) - unless another really startling one appears in the closing days.
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Bravo, Alchemist! Definitely one of my favourites so far.
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Not sure if anyone will get mine - but there is a documented basis for it.

I'll leave your minds to boggle on that!!

:D:D


And now I can relax and actually read the rest of stories without worrying that I've come up with the same concept as everyone else!
 
Last edited:
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

... there is a documented basis for it.

Hmm. I thought I'd got it, but it turned out I hadn't when I looked it up.

It was a great entry, though -- made me go all shivery (and I really liked the title...!)
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Hmm. I thought I'd got it, but it turned out I hadn't when I looked it up.

You may well have guessed! It was only the basis for my idea, so I haven't stayed totally faithful to it. If it helps, it all started in 1972 . . . . .

It was a great entry, though -- made me go all shivery (and I really liked the title...!)

Thank you!! :D:D:D
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Perp - Not sure that this was the story that I should have gone with, but I like it. The more I think about it though, some of the others were more suited to the theme.

Anne Martin - I liked this one, there seemed to be a nice undercurrent of humour - at least it amused me. I felt that it was a jinxed play, and an actor was trying to stop the jinx happening by having the play closed, even though he was probably instigating the jinx himself. Good fun.

Nixie - Someone else mentioned that this reminded them of the devil playing the fiddle (for me it was the song The Devil Went Down to Georgia, but in this case mixed with the Pied Piper. It deepens that though, with no specific player on the instrument, making it haunting, strange and unsettling. Great story.

Quokka - This story reminded me slightly of one of my own I rejected. Of course being a father with a youngster anything with children hits home. I sit now looking at the monitor waiting with trepidation and fear. What is that cuddly duck up to. Excellent.

TDZ - This one was fun, excellent and a subtle unspoken horror, rather it is what it hints at that feed the tale. There might be nothing in it. The wife might be happily working in the kitchen, or gone shopping, or staying with friends or she might be hidden away in a pumpkin patch.

Deathfrommassive - A twist on selling your soul to the devil. Like the previous story a lot of the reasons why this works comes from what is left unsaid. The uncertainty ratchets up the uneasiness of what you are reading. Are they aware of what they are doing? Are they doing it on purpose or playing? Is something going to come of it. Another brilliant entry.

alchemist - A great imaginative piece. It starts of as though we are part of any generic horror movie, but it switches into something else, unexpectedly. No longer scary for the reader it become disconcerting for the characters... with a superb pay off.

Stormfeather - As always from SF's poems the rhyming is absolutely brilliant, and the story running through it flows wonderfully. It feels like a whole epic slipped into 75 words. There is a lot more going on than I would have thought possible. Brilliant.

No-One - There is something so innocent in listening to children at pay that it easy to forget just how terrifying some of the stories they come up with can be. No-One captures that almost precisely here, with a beautifully presented tale, that sound horrific until it is revealed that it is only a child at play, that makes it all the more terrifying.

Glen - Halloween appears and brings a scary clown with it.. Two staples of horror brought together in a way that works well. The horror here is not in the story itself, but rather in the ending and what happens next. I don't think this clown will be making animals from balloons. Well not from balloons anyway.
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Perp - Not sure that this was the story that I should have gone with, but I like it. The more I think about it though, some of the others were more suited to the theme.

I like your reveiws on us Perpetual Man.

I wonder how much further most of would have gone with "horror" if this wasn't a family site. However, in my own story, I didn't want to conclude it with an expected outcome of violent wrath.
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

I like your reveiws on us Perpetual Man.

I wonder how much further most of would have gone with "horror" if this wasn't a family site. However, in my own story, I didn't want to conclude it with an expected outcome of violent wrath.

Thanks Starbeast, I quite enjoy doing them. (Also have to say that I enjoy a lot of your threads - even if I don't comment on them)
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

I have posted, my GF voted for the one I posted, it has more emotional depth than the others but less actual horror, so I'm not sure how good it was to enter it.

Surprisingly we only have 40 entries so far and only a day left to go, have I managed to choose a theme/genre that elicits the fewest entries we had for months? Or are there a number of entrants just waiting until the 13th hour to post thiers?
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Surprisingly we only have 40 entries so far and only a day left to go, have I managed to choose a theme/genre that elicits the fewest entries we had for months? Or are there a number of entrants just waiting until the 13th hour to post thiers?

We only need one more for the magic 42, and Teresa, the Judge, digs, Gary Compton and Chel of the ultra reliables haven't yet submitted.

Plus Hilarious joke, who's no longer travelling round the States, and has a tradion of last minitude, plus Arkrose, Chaoticheart, Christian Nash, crys, GoldenapplesJ Riff, MstrTal and TacticalLoco, all of whom have been fairly regular.

It might not have been a record-breaking subject but I, for one, had never considered horror before, so the exercise was interesting, if not conclusive.
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Stormfeather - As always from SF's poems the rhyming is absolutely brilliant, and the story running through it flows wonderfully. It feels like a whole epic slipped into 75 words. There is a lot more going on than I would have thought possible. Brilliant.


As always Perp, your comments have had me dancing round the house! Thank you so very much!

Whilst I hope a few more of the regulars do post a story, I'm well aware that those on Chrispy's list also write very good stories which makes voting even harder. However, I think I'd prefer to read more great stories than less, so am hoping you all manage. . . . .
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Surprisingly we only have 40 entries so far and only a day left to go, have I managed to choose a theme/genre that elicits the fewest entries we had for months? Or are there a number of entrants just waiting until the 13th hour to post theirs?

For what it's worth, Moonbat, your topic/genre combination didn't leave me desperate for an idea with only a few hours to go, which is what happened in July, June and May. (I can't be bothered to look back further.) So, by definition, your combination couldn't have been that difficult for everyone. (Even Cul posted very early.)
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

We only need one more for the magic 42, and Teresa, the Judge, digs, Gary Compton and Chel of the ultra reliables haven't yet submitted.


It's at about 90 words.... but I might just rewrite it and ditch the first half for a more (hopefully) hairraising second half.
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Aww man, you mean I just read the second volume first? I hate when that happens!
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Don't worry, TDZ, I ended up rewriting most of it so consider it a complete 1-volume work.

Hope you didn't spend a lot of time on doing your hair today (if my flu-addled brain understood your comment right).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top