Discussion -- August 2011 Challenge

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

This challenge was so much fun, it was nice to see what everyone did with the theme. I really liked Hex, Mouse and StormFeather's work. I voted for Hex because, for me, I felt it captured the theme perfectly.
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Okay, I shall remember to vote this month! I promise ;)

A lot of entries and the ones I've read so far have been fantastic and I'm looking forward to reading the rest. I shall be glued to my PC when I get home from work.

Good luck to all :D
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

In a mad dash my final comments.


Moonbat – A grim observation of dysfunctional sibling rivalry. There was something almost inevitable about the conclusion to the story, but seeing the way it was going did not make it any less terrible (in the way it was meant to be). Horror provided from the broken heart of a mother.

Ursa – This was another I seemed to work out where it was going before the end. But I loved the way Ursa put it together. Sometimes working out the way something is going to end can only be enhanced by the words used in the execution. Just the feeling of that tingling from the carpet was as good as a shiver.

Chel – Children at play seem to be playing a strong part in the stories this month, but they are a different and all so good. Chel’s is no exception, made solid by the last line. I read so much into this one that it gave me a much bigger story than what was presented – it really triggered my imagination.

Sid Hawkins – A first entry and a great one, it sent a shiver up my spine as I reached the end. Not so much the situation, but rather the feel of the escalating need to crush/kill bigger each time. I also felt there might have been a slight echo of the butterfly effect in there, cleverly inverted.

TheTomG – There is so much unexplained here, left open to your imagination, that it gives a great sense of uneasiness on top of the story itself. Who the character is, why he is being to forced to play, what the consequences are – apart from not being nice. Very unsettling.

MstrTal – I thought at first that this was going to be a tale of someone trapped in an old fridge – which it was to a degree. In itself that would be horrific enough , but the hint that there might have been something else in there was just the icing on the cake.

TJ – I was not quite sure what to make of TJ’s this month. It seemed almost cyclical in nature, although it really wasn’t, a blurring of reality and fiction? The landlord is mucking with her mind? And so much more. And that is what I really liked about it, the fact that you could draw so much from it, different every time. It made it even more... chilling.

RJMCorbet – I’d like to say that this one was particularly disturbing, but it was just like a night out in The Horse and Groom when I was a little (alright a lot) younger. A really good story that was a fitting capstone to this month’s competition. What looks like a rather saucy end to an evening, turns into something a lot darker. But then some people might enjoy that.

Now the real horror story starts as I try to choose a favourite.
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Peter Pumpkin, pumpkin keeper. Had A wife and couldn't Keep her. He put her in a pumpkin shell, where he kept her very well.​



Shudders, that rhyme gave me nightmares as a child and TDZ's entry brought it all back. Guess who got my vote:D
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Peter Pumpkin, pumpkin keeper. Had A wife and couldn't Keep her. He put her in a pumpkin shell, where he kept her very well.​

I believe said nursery rhyme refers to the aphrodisiac effect of pumpkin seeds? :)
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Well - that's my tuppence worth in...

Honourable mentions from me would be to:-
TheEndisnigh
Culhwch
Perpetual man
Glen

But my vote goes to Slack - still sends a shiver down my spine!
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

I had put up a possible alternative entry in the August 75 word story which I put up in the discussion page (which was subsequently deleted) - I hadn't realised that it was a no-no... Anyway, here it is again

Seems remarkably similar to No-one's entry.
.
.
.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Brev -- On the Wrong Side -- the panic in this one was awful. The end still makes me shiver.

Thanks for the mention. :D


Another month done already?? Where does the time go? I've got a top three after my re-read, ones that I remember from when they were posted that still caught me .. but I'm going to try to make some time to go through them all again, before my final decision, cos they're all good..
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

I voted for TheDustyZebra's keep'er. I almost went with Mouse and the soul man, almost went with Hex who was red in tooth and claw, almost with Chrispenycate and his stage fright, which are my honorable mentions.

In the end though the delicious dark irony of the one line " She makes the best pies!" won me over and got my vote.

Great contest, I look forward to the next one!
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Oh wow, thanks for the mention, Hex, and the votes, nixie and TheTomG!

I must get around to making a list tonight, arrrgh!
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

After reading them all again -

Hex

Red in Tooth and Claw

Is my pick of the month


 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

I was looking for stories, and stories that had the ring of Joe Average finding himself completely out of his depth and in the middle of something really awful.

I think I've noticed a theme in voting. We are getting fewer short lists. But to keep with tradition; here's my short list.

Star Girl -- "Final Scene"
Brev -- "On the Wrong Side"
Qobba -- "Company"
The Dusty Zebra -- "Keep'er"
Storm Feather -- "Hexed"
Moonbat -- "Tommy's Gun"
Ursa Major -- "Shortening the Working Day"
Mstr.Tal -- "Then and Now.


Ursa
and Moonbat both had the kind of horror story that just sticks with you, and if you're me you wish they didn't. But they do make for great stories and lost by only a whisker to

The Dusty Zebra for building creepy upon creepy. I thought this story had something because although it did not qualify inside my guideline for judging about what to look for in a horror story, the story and the nursery rhyme would not let me go. I must be in prison somewhere. Perhaps inside a pumpkin?
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Thank you Star Girl and Parson for the mentions - really has cheered me up!

I have an inkling of who I'm going to vote for, but will make my final decision tonight after another read through.
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Wow. Thank you so much for the votes RJM and Deathfrommassive! And thank you for the mention TheTomG (I am red in tooth and claw). More dancing!
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Well, I haven't finished filling in my spreadsheet yet (it got a little behind with my trip to the UK) but it's looking as if there's a fair risk of Hex coming out on top, despite my having planned a demoniac kitten story which was dumped as being too similar in concept, if not writing style. There, see, I'm not really vindictive and nasty.
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

I think the pumpkins might be coming from behind (which is such a terrifying image that I'd need to go and sit down if, you know, I wasn't already).

The mention of kittens on the discussion thread alarmed me because horror and play immediately said 'cats' to me -- sorry for posting before you did (but I loved your stagefright story, so I'm not that sorry). I'd spent the day marching around a super-crowded museum thinking about cats and trying not to ram people with a pushchair or lose the wildly overexcited small boy in the crowds. It really put me in the mood for writing horror.
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

There we go, all done! And that was really tough going to choose. Congratulations to everyone who put forward an entry, you did fantastic! I'm just sorry I can't vote for you all :eek:

After reading, and re-reading, every story last night, I managed to wittle it down to just four: -
  • Boneman - Oh, I Say
  • Parson - Child's Play
  • TheDustyZebra - Keep'er
  • StormFeather - Hexed
Alas... I'm only allowed one vote on this one. So, struggling with my thoughts all day I finally decided to vote for Parson :D

From the very first read this story really gave me the goosebumps. It seems an almost innocent tale, to begin with, and then... the 'Bloody liver'!!!
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

I was able to narrow it down to the following:
  • mosaix - Final Curtain
  • Hex - Red in Tooth and Claw
  • slack - Sunday
  • Aun Doorback - I thought you should know
  • Culhwch - The Gallows Tree
    [*]StormFeather - Hexed
  • TheDustyZebra - Keep'er
My vote went to slack for the ghastly image it put in my head when I first read it.

And many, many thanks to Talysia for the vote!!
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

Sid Hawkins – A first entry and a great one, it sent a shiver up my spine as I reached the end. Not so much the situation, but rather the feel of the escalating need to crush/kill bigger each time. I also felt there might have been a slight echo of the butterfly effect in there, cleverly inverted.


Thanks for the positive comment on my first attempt. The butterfly effect (well chaos theory in general) and Bradbury's story are huge influences on me in many ways ... so much so that the reference in my story was entirely unintentional! Really pleased you spotted it for me though, thanks.
 
Re: Discussion AUGUST 75 Word Writing Challenge

LittleMissy, Thanks for the vote!!!

What a nice way to start my work today.

[Picture of Parson doing a jig in his desk chair!]
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top