Alright, well I 'll put in my two cents here then!
Springs: I did quite enjoy the voice that you had in yours, and I didn't personally feel like the ending was 'ruined'. For me, it just didn't capture me as much as others. While it was very well-written and I couldn't pinpoint anything wrong with it, it didn't grab me. It wasn't as funny or as unexpected as a few. I think more it is a matter of personal taste and the fact that there were so many good entries, that some don't get picked without any specific reason against them.
BigJ: I liked your story a lot, and it actually went in and out of my choice for votes. I personally liked the ending best, but perhaps because I preferred it over a darker ending. In the end, there were just too many that demanded my votes.
Mr Orange: While I enjoyed your story, it didn't stand out to me as much as many others. One of the things I look for in making my decision is how much the story matches the image. There were other ones to me that seemed to incorporate the picture more clearly and connect to it more closely, so that was one of the factors for me. Still, though it wasn't my first choice of style, it was very well-written!
Sancho: I loved your story! Like with BigJ, it was one of my votes more than once, and in the end only missed it by the narrowest hair. In the end, I'm not really sure there is a reason why something else got chosen over it, other than mere necessity. I liked the idea, I liked the narrative, I liked the characters, I liked the ending; what can I say, I liked it a lot! Sorry I can't give you any constructive criticism; I was surprised your story didn't get more favour to be honest, but my personal preference doesn't always align with others.
And since, I'm here, I'll throw my story out for consideration.
It did quite well actually, so I'm not too concerned with it, but I'd be interested to hear what people thought anyway.
The Alien Gate
The alien’s prison was nice enough; smiling ladies served him food, kept his cell clean, and took him for little walks about the enclosure. But Forester didn't care; he wasn't about to let those body-snatching villains conquer Earth without a fight.
Forester had played his part, pretending to be content and harmless. Now their guards were down, and he could escape. The moment he was left unattended, he made his move; stealing a car he sped off, soon arriving at his destination.
He only had a few minutes, but that was all he needed; pilfering supplies from the shed, he then hurried to the wooden totem through which the aliens’ souls came to Earth and invaded human bodies.
Forester doused the carven device with gasoline. His captors arrived, yelling at him to stop.
“Too late Space Fiends!” he cried, and lit the carving.
Forester was dragged away. Flame consumed the wood, and the gate was ruined.
* * *
Becky stared at the charred remains of her sculpture. Grandpa had always loved her work. Now he was breaking out of the Home to burn it.
“He really believes that alien invasion stuff, doesn't he?” asked Jordan, incredulous. “I knew he was senile, but I can’t believe he thought your carving was an alien transporter!”
“Dr. Morrison said he was improving…” Becky sighed. “I better call Mom and tell her what happened.”
* * *
Frowning, Dr. Morrison watched Forester through the observation window. “So, he still remembers…”
“Not where the real gate is, luckily for us, or this invasion would have ended before it began.”
“We can’t risk that happening; drastic measures must be taken. Making Forester senile clearly wasn't enough… I think it’s time the old man had a heart attack; don’t you Nurse?”
“I’ll see to it Commander.”