Discussion - December 2011 - 75 Word Challenge

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well done, Hex.

This is a case of "another month, another concert." When, on the 7th of December, I posted that I'd had an idea, I'd just returned from watching the BSO play (the 1947 version of) the ballet. No sooner had the performance begun than I'd seen the obvious parallels with this month's topic. The rest is histrionic....



EDIT: Sorry to hear that, Stormfeather. You take as much rest as you can. Christmas can be very wearing.
 
Even if I have not been here for a while, I still know that today was the deadline for the stories and yet is voting. I would like to ask to consider my contribution even if I should not be here daily. I have my reasons and I have to finish one thing first, try to understand what I only partly understand as my thoughts are the opposite. So I have to go through things several times even to grasp them roughly. Perhaps I will be able to speak out things more clearly afterwards? I do not know.
But I follow the forum and reading all the interesting bits and stories here. You must not consider me while voting, but I would be glad if you would do.

Till then I wish you all a merry Christmas. May peace and happiness be with all of you.
 
What a great month for stories.

Here's a list of some I especially liked (I liked others too, but the list was so long it was embarrassing so I shortened it). Stars beside my Very Short list.


* reiver33 -- 'The House on Jeter Lane'
* HareBrain --'Naval Engagement'
Mith -- 'Poor Rudolf...'
odangutan
Stormcrow -- 'Why play on'
Phoenixthewriter -- 'Wind up'
High Eight -- 'The Little Giant'
Tisiphone -- 'Short on Time'
The Spurring Platty -- 'New Haiti Mischief'
* Quokka -- 'To mop and murder'
Aun Doorback -- 'The Trojan Plan'
* Culhwch -- 'The Toymaker'
Boneman -- 'Need Revisited'
Alchemist -- 'From Prussia with Love'
Teresa Edgerton -- 'The Mice will play'
Ursa major -- 'Shrovetide Fair'
The Judge -- 'Nursery Crime'

I really struggled to choose between 'The House on Jeter Lane' and 'Naval Engagement' . When I read reiver's story I didn't see how anyone could beat it, but then HB's was so clever and different. And I so want to know what happens to Miss Featherhill.

Anyway, I didn't toss a coin in the end. I voted for reiver's brilliant story. I suspected I would as soon as I read 'The slow beat of a heavy ventilation fan...'
 
Well my short list was a little shorter, but my they could have been in there was about the same length.

Revier 33; still confused that this is only 75 words, it's just so incredibly described.
Harebrain; loved the dialogue and the underlying just, frankly, nastiness of the admiral.
Mith; the name says it all, poor Rudolph. Nice pie, though.
Hopewrites; I just loved loved the last line.
Culwych; so cruel, so memorable.
Moonbat: i wondered what on earth he was building and got rather worried.
Bob S.; the sheep in their scratchy coats stayed with me.

Anyway, like Hex it came down to Revier and Harebrain and my dice fell very slightly the other way; HB got my vote.
 
In the end I too was swayed by the mechanical mice...
 
Thank you Spring for the shortlisting. I've decided to start posting mine again since we only get one vote and there were so many stories that I loved.
HareBrain - Naval Engagement
Hex- The Toymakers Legacy
AnyaKimlin
odanguan
Phoenixthewriter - Wind Up
Abernovo
Tisiphone
Highlander- Praxinoscope
Culhuwch - The Toymaker
Boneman - Need Revisited
TheDustyZebra - Cinder Klaas
Perpetual Man
The Judge - Nursey Crime

really enjoyed reading all the entries over again.
 
alchemist - There is something at play here, beneath the words, and emotional subtext. There have been just enough words used to give you a structure and to fill in the rest that it is inspired. A child worship of a father; an ongoing war, the chance of sacrifice in the line of duty; the child following in a father's footsteps...excellent.

Teresa - The mice are on the loose. There was so much I liked in this one, the mice 'waking up,' it might be a technological waking, or it might be a magical one, but either way the mice doing a pre-emptive strike on the cat is scarily intelligent and the making of another wonderful little tale.

Ursa - The story is very abrupt, the sentence structure truncated and short, making the tale read in short bursts, which really gets the point of view of a machine across. You can almost imagine it's movements, given life through the way the story is structured. A full life time in 75 words!

mosaix - Note to self: Never get give Perp jr. any construction sets. There was a distinctly British feeling to the story - probably fed by the pit reference; and there was the feeling of the father being worn after working so hard, but perhaps not showing an interest in what the son was up to, and just how intelligent and creative he was. The final scene is a well drawn image, that really stuck in mind.

TJ - Almost a steampunk Toy Story, but with a very sinister edge. You could almost feel the oppression as one by one the normal toys are transformed into nasty caricatures of themselves. There really is a sense of dread as one by one the toys are consumed, and there is the sense of hope as one of the last is prepared to stand up and fight, but almost an irony that in order to preserve the comfort of the toys, it must become a thing of violence.


This has to have been one of the most incredible months for entries. Just when I thought we had reached an impossibly high plateau, you all raise it again. I don't think there was a single weak entry this month, everyone a potential winner (something that seems to have been reflected in the early stages of voting).

Just getting a shortlist has been harder than it has ever been.

So I feel honoured to get a mention, many thanks Hope.

And my shortlist:

Reiver33
Harebrain
Mith
Abernovo
Parson,
Aun Doorback
Cul
Boneman
TJ
 
The stories were of such good quality, it was a nightmare to choose from them. A few of those that stood out for me were:

Phoenix
hopewrites
AMB
Parson
Aun Doorback
Boneman
Moonbat
Bob S Sr and
mosaix

In the end, it finally came down to a choice between four: Reiver, HareBrain, Perp and Teresa.

It was incredibly difficult to narrow it to one but, in the end, I voted for HareBrain.

I just saw the characters and scene so, so clearly, especially that devious admiral.
 
Thanks for the vote, hope, and the mentions, Hex, springs and Perp - a lovely early Christmas present to discover as I log in at 11.30 pm Christmas Eve, local time.
 
Wow, I was in someone's notable mentions. Thanks Abernovo.

I just got stuck with chrispenycate's 'O Teknibaum' in my head. It was fun, clever and I think the last two lines will stay with me forever more. I'm voting for it in the hope that it doesn't devour me along with the children.


Other than that, I really couldn't choose between them enough to give notable mentions, there were so many good ones. So let's just say every third one was really special and pretend I know what I'm talking about.
 
Last edited:
Thanks Hopewrites for the short list mention - Much appreciated.

Still to decide who to vote for myself...
 
Thanks for the shortlisting Hex, Springs and Perp :) After the madness of work today it was a nice way to destress lol

Here's my short and shorter list:

*Reiver33 - The house on Jeter Lane
Springs1971 - Christmas on the cut
Phoenixthewriter - Wind up
Tisiphone - Short on time
Quokka - To mop and murder
Aun Doorback - The Trojan plan
*Highlander - The Praxinoscope Mk 11
*Culhwch - The Toymaker
*Boneman - Needs revisited
*Perpetual Man - A Christmas miracle

Again there's lots of wonderful stories, I always feel bad just choosing one, but there can be only one and I have given my vote to Boneman. A cracking story, gave me a few chuckles and some very good imagery. Well done Sir!!
 
Hey! a couple of mentions. Yea!! Thanks Perp and Abernavo.

Will read and vote soon/someday/whenever Christmas you know.:)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top