Discussion - February 2011 - 75 Word Challenge

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ty Scott (and Warren, and TDZ) I kind of hid for a while today, so only going back over thread tonight.

I'm looking forward to Perp's comments, he has a lot to work with this month...

I've noticed. Stunned by how many entries have come up in just two days!

I thought I'd try something different and not read any until I had done mine, I might have to rethink that if I'm going to get on top of the comments!!
 
For what it's worth, Karn, I liked it. A lone soldier out to defend the world, one demon at a time. Hard-bitten. And the character squeezes, doesn't pull.


I understand the basic concepts of how one should wield a gun; my grandfather was a rifle marksman.

Beyond that, the "soldier" was not actually a soldier, not in the basic sense. I had hoped the title had given a clue away; he was actually an angel, cast out of Heaven about a thousand years prior for his single-mindedness on destroying demons, but had lived amongst mortals until the demon invasion. I wasn't able to get that part into the 75 words, though.
 
And the first run of comments begins:


AlcubierreWarp – The month kicks off with a cracking tale, of someone prepared to give up their life in the service of the demon they follow, giving the creature free reign to walk the world. Well presented and truly catching the willing sacrifice of the supplicant, despite the pain and cost.

High Eight – A read or two and I think I see the impossible love story coming into play here. A man so deeply in love with his wife, no matter what she might me (I’m guessing were-wolf, but am prepared to be wrong!) that he is prepared to sacrifice all for her. It must be returned to some degree because she does not eat him!

Karn – A well presented story that is simply the devotion to duty and to the task at hand. Someone willing to stand in place no matter what the odds and do the job allotted to them. I could just see him there, for some reason he seemed cold as he fired his gun...

AMB – This was the first story to make me smirk this month. I just really appreciated the ending. It is an old trick but it nearly always works. The imparting of great knowledge seemingly cut short just at the crucial point. Great idea and well presented.

James Coote – The feel I get from this one is more about catching the essence of the theme which it does so very, very well. Someone dedicating their life to a cause, but what happens when they fail at the task, do they give in or is there that little hope that they might find some form of continuance?

Starbeast – Well... this was just explosive. A magnificent little story that plays with all expectations while staying true to the theme. In some ways it starts off wrong footing the reader as it looks like fun but you cannot see the theme there, it all comes together with the kiss at the end.

Scott – As much fun as the previous entry was this is the antithesis. Slow building, dark and with a darkly brilliant closing line. All the information is given to you, and the ending puts the sinister into the opening lines. There is just enough ambiguity for the reader to make their own mind up about what is going but the details are subtly blurred. Delicious.

Warren – Another ambiguous one that gives a lot more than the word count should allow. Most obviously we have the devotion to a deity, perhaps even preparing to go and fight in that god’s name, but it leaves it open as to whether she would go and fight after she discovers the new path she is on.

Abernovo – A good solid story that not only seems to catch the theme with ease but squeezes a whole relationship into 75 words and just how that kind of love can change not just a person but the people around them.

Alchemist – A clever piece this taking perhaps the most common prayer in the Christian world and updating it for the modern age. Incredibly well chosen words, keep the flow of the original intact, while conveying the updated message with ease.
 
Perp, I guess you decided you'd better get going with your reviews after all Perp! I thought High Eight's was a spider or some such from the reference to chitin.

Oh and Karn; don't knock it, yours is already on my short list! I thought it was great and absolutely fitted the theme.
 
Oops, you're quite right about the spider Vertigo, head in the wrong place....
 
Beyond that, the "soldier" was not actually a soldier, not in the basic sense. I had hoped the title had given a clue away; he was actually an angel
Karn, that came across perfectly. Sorry, somewhere in the recesses of my religious education classes at school there was the comment that an angel was not simply some white-robed figure on a tree, but a messenger and warrior. I should have made myself clearer.
 
Alchemist,

What is a poor Parson to make of that story? My more conservative colleagues would say very unkind things indeed.:D

I liked it. Hope you are forgiven.:D Hope I'm forgiven too.:eek:

In time, we'll find out...

And thanks for the review, Perp.
 
I have a story it's just breaking it down to 75 words aghhh lol. hopefully I can get it to convey the story like I'd like
 
I guess the challenge is really to get across in so few words, a condition that is usually built up over a long period of time.

I found it quite hard to not end up with obsession instead of devotion, especially when not doing devotion to duty or devotion to a loved on.

Still, is my first attempt at this challenge, so hopefully I'll do better next time :p
 
Now that slap was unwarranted. It wasn't an unprovoked attack against myself, just pointing out that I don't think it could truthfully fall under a "fun" or "heartfelt" category.


My entry this month was about a cold, emotionless angel cast from Heaven because of his devotion to destroying creatures of darkness. As I said I think it could fall under the "drama" category. I was quite proud of it and surprised.


The only one I truly wince at, looking back, is my "goblin invasion" piece. That had started out so well, but was over five times as long as was allowed here, and the edits I made on that one suffered the quality by quite a lot.
 
Seriously, I don't think mine could be considered fun or heartfelt. Drama, perhaps, but unlikely.

How about "supernatural thriller"?

Your tale Karn was quite clear to me, I liked the idea of an angel on Earth with a mission to cleanse the world from demons. If you had 300 words to use, I'm sure you would have put a great deal of action in it, but with only 75, we have to get our point across with just a few words (however that is the challenge).

Plus, one other item, I would need 10 to 20 votes in order to truely reward the many gifted writers here.
 
Re your last point there Starbeast I have to agree with you. I'm going to have to post soon or I'll get scared off! Problem is I just can't get the title I need for mine.
 
How about "supernatural thriller"?

Your tale Karn was quite clear to me, I liked the idea of an angel on Earth with a mission to cleanse the world from demons. If you had 300 words to use, I'm sure you would have put a great deal of action in it, but with only 75, we have to get our point across with just a few words (however that is the challenge).

Plus, one other item, I would need 10 to 20 votes in order to truely reward the many gifted writers here.

I would have probably put more background to the sniper if it were for a 300.


And to Anya, well, that remains to be seen, in a broader sense.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top