Discussion Thread - SEVENTY-FIVE WORD WRITING CHALLENGE May 2013

Thanks for the vote, abernovo :)

I voted for the Judge...I have a rule, that if a story sends a shiver down my spine, I gotta vote for it.

Fortunately, I haven't had two shivers in a contest, and only one vote...yet...
 
Well I've read through the stories and there sure have been some different takes on what "Legacy" should mean. Short List:

Luiglin “You Will Not Want”
Springs “Braving the New World”
Chrispenycate “Respect Your Elders”
TheDustyZebra “We’re Counting on You.”
Ursa Major “The Limits of Military Intelligence”
Brev “He Came from the North”

If I were going to vote for one for sheer comedy there would be only one choice:

Lenny “The Printing Dead”


But the winner, once again, from the moment I read it:

The Judge “A Mother’s Will and Testament”
 
*starts re-writing the rules to allow moderators to close the poll early...*

Thanks for the mentions, Starbeast and johnnyjet.

Big thanks with laboratory work to enhance them to RoninJedi (and Mrs RJ!), DEO and Parson -- and many thanks for the kind words, each of you.


Sorry to see you missed posting, reiver -- put it up here, so we can see it, though. I always love reading your work.
 
As per request (and a tad obscure, I know)


[FONT=&quot]One Moment, Please[/FONT]

[FONT=&quot]He was a figure sculpted from muscle, silhouetted against the neon city. Yet his shoulders sagged, as if bearing the weight of the world. [/FONT]

[FONT=&quot]I stood beside him, looking down at the metropolis. “Can nothing be done?”[/FONT]

[FONT=&quot]He shook his head. “No. In every possible future I destroy all that is important to me. Even you, my non-judgemental friend.”[/FONT]

[FONT=&quot]“Captain-”[/FONT]

[FONT=&quot]He roared at the night sky. “Marvel upon my works, ye mighty, and despair!”[/FONT]
 
One read through later:

Luiglin
SB
Victoria
Anya
Aber
TDZ
Cul
Parson
AJB
Mary Faerie
TJ
Lenny

All make the short list.

Most sadistic short story worthy of a mention goes to Harebrain, and an extra special mention to Moonbat for his wordplay.

The top three for me:

TDZ
Cul
Parson

with the vote going to TDZ by a zebra's nose
 
Short list

fishii - A Beary Great Love
Chrispenycate - Respect your Elders
TDZ - We're Counting on You
Parson - A Long Line of Love

and the winning vote for me this month is

BONEMAN - The One True Gift

The story just flowed nicely like music somehow, and it was very touching. Well Done!
 
Oh my goodness, I woke up to find that I got two votes overnight! Yippee! :D

Thank you for the honorable mention, johnnyjet, and the shortlistings, TacticalLoco, Parson and ratsy, and big thank yous and hugs all around to Perp and EloiseA for the lovely, lovely votes!

I spent my weekend cleaning house, and did not have a chance to vote, but I'm at work on this holiday Monday when nobody else is, so maybe I'll get to it today. :)
 
Thanks Perpetual Man for shortlisting me! :) There's hope for me yet! Yey! And for your review.

And also Starbeast for your review; it's nice to meet you too :)

Thanks jonnyjet for your honourable mention!

And thanks to Victoria Silverwolf for your comment.

I've never let anyone read so much as this since I was at school!!! So this process is good for me... if daunting. I'm terrible with being knocked back. So much so I never put anything out there. Stupid I know blah blah blah...

Some thoughts I had;
AMB: It just had to be Rick Astly! It's the epitomy of 'so terrible it's funny'. Apparenty the same happened with a set of runic tablets found in a burial. There were huge hopes of what secrets of the past they may tell but they turned out to be jokes!

Ursa Major: Loved it. A picture of being 'your own worst enemy'. The end's told without needing to be.

Parson: I agree with Starbeast; a breath of fresh air. So much is shocking, nasty, fast or bleak that it's a simple pleasure to be calmed by a positive futuristic image of what's actually most defining of us; our closest relationships.

Glen: This touched me. The Captain's comic name starts you with an emotional impression which is so polarised from his actual situation. Everyone who's ever lived would wish to be able to tell the person they lost that they loved them. This is excellent as, even without death, and communication still being rudementarily possible, Dad's loss of his son is no less.

Mootbat: A fine comment on the end product of an ever increasingly automated, churning world that actually produces nothing of value. Linked by a childs toy in a humerous way... but therin lies it's darker legacy...

Luiglin: Poignant to me. The Silent Running nod was the bit that got me; childish in their cartoon origin, the 3 charaters are so finally sad and lonely in the film; I cried for the last little robot. Without her Dad, is that how the girl, and the next generation, will grow up out there in space? (And that's without mentioning the psycho computer.)

Stormcrow: A book martyr. An object as sacred as family ties. And, similarly, worth dying for.

The Spurring Platty: Evocative. A rich picture of place and race in so few words.

The Judge: Cor blimey. Seriously moving sadness. From the lawsuit to decades of determination to 'cure' the grief. A curious perspective on the nature of a mother's love, for if it were any other would we not call it obsession?

Brev: A very neat, tiny snippit that's all needed to tell the circle of that world's history over a thousand years. Ripe for a 'break the cycle' sequel focused on Agger's son?

which leads me on to

The Dusty Zebra: The many short lines of like and like form the cycle which gives the last line something firm to break.

HareBrain: Wondrously lovely silliness! Simple as :)

Perpetual Man: A splendid twist, not only in the tale, but in the mood. From grandiose, classic fantasy to chin rubbing, 'sickener' chanting peevishness. SO THERE!

Faves in no order:
Ursa Major
The Judge
Glen
Luiglin

Vote.... tough one.
The Judge.
 
Thanks for the comments Starbeast, Victoria, and Perp. As always, they're a joy to read. And thank you for the mentions, Starbeast, Luiglin, johnnyjet, Parson (mind if I mark it on my list as a "half vote"? :p), and Perp!

---

On the subject of bleakness (yeah, I was a bit late to this thread...), it's something of a recurring sentiment - I'm pretty sure it's been discussed before (the discussion thread for the "Trick or Treat" theme springs to mind. October 2010, was it?), and I've definitely thought that some themes particularly attract bleak and dark stories. Personally, I kind of enjoy them, and I'm definitely not against writing something dark or bleak and adding a bit of humour to it.

---

Shortlist, Shorter List, Vote (in order of posting):

fishii
DEO
johnnyjet
TDZ
Aun Doorback
alchemist
Moonbat
jimness
HareBrain
AMB
 
Another month over. Here is my short list and whys.

Perp Man – I like the vengeful vitriol in this piece, amplified so greatly by the ‘little turd’ line. I think the pace - and rhythm of the words chosen - made this a really well constructed and enjoyable story.

Bowler1 – the idea of self upgrading robots in an overarching story of decaying cycles is a compelling concept. A bit 2001, a bit AI and a lot Bowler1.:D

Victoria Silverwolf – That’s no moon… For me, this is one of the standouttiest of standout stories in this month’s challenge. It brought so many images to mind, and not just because of the cool concept; I love the image of the helmets touching juxtaposed with the coldness of a machine. There’s so much in 75 words.

Anyakimlin – I liked the childlike feel to this which headed me in the wrong direction as I read on to the end. It’s a great idea, too, and I can never ever resist anything with derelict, moody or ancient houses in them.

TDZ – I really don't know what to say about this except that it's a lifetime and morality in 75 words. That's rather an incredible feat and really has the wow factor.

Moonbat – a surreal slice of absurdism. Right up my street. I loved the idea of the updated magic porridge pot and wonder who will stop the darn thing? I need a load of grey side wings from Space Lego. I wonder if some could end up being shipped to Walthamstow?

Stormcrow – As usual you make it into my short list <sigh> Will you please at least attempt to write something rubbish? I want to know why they have this info depository in space and why Brandt was purging. I guessed it was just a usual limitations thing but there’s something desperate about Covacik’s actions that hints at something bigger. Anyway, great dialogue and pacing, and the contrast of cold airlock-y space with the smell of Father’s briefcase is an evocative one.

TJ – for the ultimate legacy any of us can leave, but twisted because of a mother’s terrible anguish. Such a beautiful bracket at the beginning and end - summing up the narrative in itself and a whole world in between.

It was a fight between Moonbat, TDZ, Stormcrow and Victoria but I had to go with TDZ because that one gave me the goosebumps (in a good way) when I read it.


pH
 
Wow, another vote! Thanks, Phyrebrat, for that and the humbling commentary. Thanks as well to Mary Faerie and Lenny for the shortlistings!
 
Mary Faerie - thanks for the comments, and Phyrebrat thanks for the ahortlisting and the kind words!
 
Mary Faerie - Nice to meet you and "Thanks" for your including me in your comments!

Phyrebrat - Thank You so much for your massively positive comments and shortlisting - I'm left short for words (pretty rare thing, that!).
 
No entry for me this month, I'm afraid my inspiration died this month. I can only hope that it is resurrected for next month, but in the meantime I bequeath my vote to Ursa's legion of back-stabbing automatons. Respect your elders by chrispenycate came a very close second.
 

Back
Top