A Wrinkle in Time - just awful.
Catcher in the Rye - Salinger was just nuts and that book sucked.
Lord of the Flies - Not my cup of tea.
The last two volumes of Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn - Williams played leapfrog with the POVs like a school child.
Gift of the Magi - More of a short story really, but it was a tired old joke with a foreseeable punchline that attempted tragedy and comedy at the same time and failed both spectacularly.
Othello - Shakespeare, in my opinion, was long-winded, far too flowery, and more than a little pompous.